An alternate discussion SINAL and Anand

Page

paradigm

@paradigm

Dazzler

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

Guys one scenario has often intrigued me. What if it was logically possible for Anand to return. Dont kill me.. I love Kunal-Siddhi (i am sure my numerous posts are testament to that ) I have always wanted a coming-back-from the dead scenario to be dealt with maturity on TV. But it hasnt. One of the persons always turns psycho or negative

My question to you is "how would the situation unfold if kunal siddhi and anand remained true to their characters-the lovely; positive souls they are"

Siddhi: I think in terms of clariity the situation is easiest for her. She liked Anand no doubts. But the liking (i dont wanna call it love) was at a very nascent stage. And she has been married for over a year to Kunal and loves him passionately and his also carrying his baby. So to see herself as Kunal's wife foremost, even after Anand's return would be easy.

Anand: for anand ; accepting the whole scenario would be tougher. for him time had stood still (lets say he was in coma in the interim) at the juncture when he was about to wed siddhi who he liked a lot... to see him married to his idol; his elder brother Kunal and to see how passionately the two love each other would be tough.

Now coming to the star Kunal Chopra; the scenario would be hardest for him; he is married to his soulmate; yet she is the same person his baby brother loved and seeing Anand in pain (at least initially) on seeing SINAL togther would cause Kunal even more pain.

So if they stayed true to their characters; Anand would eventually realize that his feelings for siddhi wasnt love and that Kunal and siddhi are in fact soulmates; the three of them would adjust to their new relations; SINAL blossoming as an in love couple; Kunal and Anand re-discovering the awesome brother bond they shared; siddhi and anand discovering a new relation of being friends and buddies; not typical devar bhabhi

I had begun hating anand due to the anand jaap. But honestly i miss him for the awesome rapport he shared with kunal; two brothers with a heavenly bond.and also for being a genuinely nice guy who realized the value of Kunal even in his bad phase.

Edited by paradigm - 13 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

vidhisalot

@vidhisalot

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 13 years ago

hey i have thought abt this long b4...since the consummation days...pata nai bt i thought it would be good to watch it...bt as they have shown anand face's so no comeback posss...

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

norzar

@norzar

Trailblazer

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

enjoyed reading your topic

i have always believed that siddhi has loved both anand and kunal in her own way and will always do. Yes she didnt spend much time with anand as compared to kunal, however anand was the man who introduced her to the concept of love, he will always have a place in her heart and she will have sweet memories of him.

She married the man she disliked for the man she loved, that sums up her love for anand. if you see Siddhi;s scene with anand's photo after the consummation on anand's barsi you could see that she still loves anand somewhere deep down. Just because a loved one dies, that doesnt mean we stop loving the person, love will always remain for the person but maybe in a unique form.

Anand coming back is impossible, his dead body was shown

kunal is siddhi;s soulmate and if at all cvs decide to such a illogical track with anand's comeback, i believe siddhi will make the right decision and will stay with her soulmate who is kunal and only kunal. Yes she will probably be affected by anand's presence but she will want him to move on in life and be happy, bec she naturally wouldnt want anand to sit down and sulk

i believe kunal may feel bad for anand, but i dont think he will be able to let go of siddhi bec it will pain him much more seeing siddhi with someone else even if its his own brother. i rem bef he had his full realisation of love for siddhi how he had stated to siddhi in hurtful way tumse toh mujhse pyar bhi nehi karti hooh, he was insecure and it was paining hi that siddhi doesnt love him and still loves anand. those episodes proved that his own feelings for siddhi overpowered everything else. even if anand came back he wouldnt be able to see anand with siddhi.

anand loved both sinal, so for him they happiness will come first, he would never come between both

norzar

Quote

jay_bpm

@jay_bpm

Stunner

Posted: 13 years ago

I have often thought about the issue. We did see SINAL dealing with Anand issue well enough.

Now if Anand comes back, it would be too complicated.

Siddhi sure would be uncomfortable but she knows Kunal is her true love.

Anand eventually may be able to accept it.

Kunal would have really hard time as we already saw, but he would overcome it as Siddhi is his true love and he really is incomplete with out her.

I have problem with Anand coming back as it would create a whole lot of issues. When Siddhi decides to stay with Kunal, people will think it's because she married him and they are having kid together, not because Kunal is her soul mate or true love.

Anand would accept it, but again people may see it as sacrifice on his part due to his niceness. But would he be able to accept it as SINAL has true love or because he's nice person? that is major concern and I really don't like it when people are saying Siddhi lost her love before Kunal.

According to everyone, Siddhi-Anand were in love. I did address this issue in my post.

@norzar - you are right that Anand does have a place in Siddhi's heart. but it is not the love as actual love. Siddhi-Anand relation started with mutual attraction and even though they had good rapport, it wasn't deep enough to be called love. Even after SINAL marriage, Kunal was the one who remembered Anand more often than Siddhi. If Siddhi had married someone else, she could still have been able to move on alright. But Kunal being her true love - soul mate; amount of happiness she has with Kunal, that could have never been achieved with Anand or anyone else.

One may say Siddhi lived longer with Kunal. Well that's the point. You need to spend appropriate time for love. We say in psychology, "it's a process". If you see all of the interaction between Siddhi-Anand, they did not have deepness we see in SINAL. And I believe they would not have achieved anything more than what they already had. They got some comfort and trust, some understanding, playfulness in their relationship. They called it love and fine with it as nothing more was to explore but more kisses and hugs reaching one level and that's it.

With SINAL we saw gradual process in achieving all factors of relationship and eventually becoming one, inseparable, not just willing to die for each-other but willing to fight with others and each other so they can always stay together. We saw relationship starting from a tissue to right now at hugs and kisses. and Hey it's still not over yet, we will still see more. Just shows deepness of their relationship, which just wasn't there with anyone else.

Again I am not saying this because I love SINAL & KUNAL most, but I am saying what I see. Even when Anand was alive, I saw more honest interaction that showed true connection between SINAL, this is when they were fighting.

If Anand was alive and SINAL ended up coming together, it would be little like "Hum Dil De Chuke Sanam" one of my favorite movie. But now if Anand comes back, it raised questions for SINAL as it seems that only reason they came together is Anand's death.

Sorry for long psot and if I offended anyone, but ..

Edited by jay_bpm - 13 years ago

Quote

Padmini

@d.padmini

Dazzler

Posted: 13 years ago

Well..even I have thought many times how it would be if anand returns back..
Actually the turns of events would be interesting to watch..
I really want to see the reaction of kunal .one side is his baby brother whom he is very close to and shares an awesome relation, ready to sacrifice anything for him and another side his love without whom he cannot even imagine his life..
I have always imagined this scene, when Anand comes back...how things would be ..
to add to spice , if doc says something in the lines that since he is just out of trauma /comma and so should not be given any shock and sidhi has to act as his girl friend or wife ..
Kunal ,his expressions, his feelings would be a treat to watch..
but I am sure..SINAL love would win , but the passage from awkwardness to guilt to right on Sidhi to Sidhi being his to overcoming the past would be wonderful esp with Sammy being there

Quote

Riddhi (Ridzz)

@sandy118_RiDdHi

Sparkler

Posted: 13 years ago

ya that wud be interesting to watch mainly how SiNal deals with it how their relation remains infront of anand n how anand reacts by seeing their love omg i have so much of curiosity 😆 but still 1 q. remain from where n how anand will come back now 😕 he is dead rite 😛

Quote

tanyashrivastav

@tanyashrivastav

Inactive

Posted: 13 years ago

interesting post padigram ...though i dont wish to see anand coming bak in sinal's life ...there is already lot of tension nd problems dont wish to see more ...

Quote

An alternate discussion SINAL and Anand

Related Topics

Explore Topics