Qarz E Jaan (HUM) #4 - Usama, Nameer, Yumna | DT.N. Pg 136 - Page 126

Originally posted by: blahblah131

Mujhse jo lag raha meiney bool diya, Apko excuse lagta hai tu ap wohi samaj le

No problem. It's upto one's perspective. I might not have felt like this had writer or actor didn't sell ammar as some saint for whose end people will cry.

I just wish they were careful during their interviews. Because it really killed whatever the optimism I had on this show.

Originally posted by: nightingale1234

I m seeing nameer n yumna getting bashed for a colab post, specifically certain section who weren't even watching the show has picked up the topic n bashing actors unnecessarily, specifically yumna is the target. Apparently nameer n yumna pic in IG is enabling "shippers". All m seeing is people bashing them in comment section n few people asking them to pair up in a new drama bcoz ammar nashwa can't be shipped.I dunno about nameer, but, yumna definitely doesn't need all these tactics.She all reached the level of stardom where people watch a show only bcoz of her presence.She rarely posts n people are nit picking unnecessarily n bashing actors .

I know very well who are these people n why suddenly out of no where we have this "selective outrage" n bashing is happening. People were waiting for one opportunity n they got it. (Iykyk)

But yeah, better to stay away n not indulge in these mess.

If it is about me. Then my intention was not to bash her. I am just disappointed that's all.

Originally posted by: blahblah131

This is the first time that I disagree with you on this forum. I couldn't get passed the I can fix a rapist line to concentrate on anything else

Totally understandable. For me her countenance, her body language, the nuances that are showing how miserable she feels are more honest than her actual words. Something even Burhan has brought up. She’s lying but her eyes say something else. Her words are just a cover to appease her mother and herself of this decision. And that’s all.

If you’re taking the lines on face value, yes. But Yumna + direction is just selling it to me that Nashwa is neither currently at peace nor will be with this decision.

Also I’m generally not looking at her through the lens of a heroine. She’s not your typical heroine. It’s a story of a very toxic house which reflects many houses in our society and generational trauma. It’s a criminal household and Nashwa is far from normal. Its not about lessons but her full journey for me. How can I take lessons from Nashwa or expect her to bestow wisdom on me, the audience, when she herself accepts her weaknesses and humanity so openly through the writing? “Main darr gayi thi…” “Main aakhir insaan hoon” and all that. She’s so deeply flawed so of course her decisions will be too.

Right now we are at the rock bottom phase for her. Which is fine, because she will not be rewarded for her bad decision in the story. She will suffer. For me this was necessary - I want to see her in Bisma’s shoes and later fight and escape this house. Otherwise the pay for me with her closure wouldn’t be that interesting. The main hook point IS that will she or won’t she turn out to another Bisma? (She won’t).

Abhi dukh ho raha hai tou baad main mazaa aaye ga. And honestly even this dukh is part and parcel of this kind of story. I’m totally hooked either way

Originally posted by: nightingale1234

I m seeing nameer n yumna getting bashed for a colab post, specifically certain section who weren't even watching the show has picked up the topic n bashing actors unnecessarily, specifically yumna is the target. Apparently nameer n yumna pic in IG is enabling "shippers". All m seeing is people bashing them in comment section n few people asking them to pair up in a new drama bcoz ammar nashwa can't be shipped.I dunno about nameer, but, yumna definitely doesn't need all these tactics.She all reached the level of stardom where people watch a show only bcoz of her presence.She rarely posts n people are nit picking unnecessarily n bashing actors .

I know very well who are these people n why suddenly out of no where we have this "selective outrage" n bashing is happening. People were waiting for one opportunity n they got it. (Iykyk)

But yeah, better to stay away n not indulge in these mess.

What’s the problem with cast taking pictures? Achi photo hai. Beautiful dresses. Looking fab. Kya masla hai People need to separate reality from fiction

Idk if this was the comment section of this post or what but I saw clips from one where someone said “Nashwa should fight for herself like she fought for Bisma” and Yumna replied “Step by step”

Sharing this here in case people didn’t see her comment

Originally posted by: Sparkle232

If it is about me. Then my intention was not to bash her. I am just disappointed that's all.

Hey, no, I was talking about X, reddit n insta comments.

Originally posted by: nightingale1234

💯

All these things makes sense!! I really really hope they aren't going that route . I will be so disappointed.

I really dont understand how can even the writer and Nameer are claiming to the extent that audience will cry for Ammars character. I mean seriously. Like someone pointed out, it's like public will cry for Nirbhaya culprit 🤔. Unless now they will show, that he has not done the crime. How can Ammar be justified. So there is going to be no sympathy for Maheen Nashwa and Burhan. Even if she tries to show Ammar personality disorder because of upbringing, but is thst a valid reason? Burhan and Nashwa have infact seen a much more difficult childhood, but see how both of them have turned out to be. Here Ammar has always been overpampered by Sidra and Barkhat. So he just cant complain about not receiveng love.And I won't blame Bakhtiyar to bash him either. He has always been a useless son. Which Father will tolerate such a son. Plus he keeps getting into some mess or the other from which Bakhtiyar only saves him. I always wonder, from Ammar get so much money to do drugs and Cigarettes?

I was baffled by Nashwa dialogues yest. And on top of that, she had the audacity to say, Burhan always had a golden life. Is she also on weed😡. I wish Burhan had heard that dialogues, then maybe he would have started hating her. I still wonder why Burhan is there in this show. His character has just been reduced to crying love sick character.

Originally posted by: pilot100

I really dont understand how can even the writer and Nameer are claiming to the extent that audience will cry for Ammars character. I mean seriously. Like someone pointed out, it's like public will cry for Nirbhaya culprit 🤔. Unless now they will show, that he has not done the crime. How can Ammar be justified. So there is going to be no sympathy for Maheen Nashwa and Burhan. Even if she tries to show Ammar personality disorder because of upbringing, but is thst a valid reason? Burhan and Nashwa have infact seen a much more difficult childhood, but see how both of them have turned out to be. Here Ammar has always been overpampered by Sidra and Barkhat. So he just cant complain about not receiveng love.And I won't blame Bakhtiyar to bash him either. He has always been a useless son. Which Father will tolerate such a son. Plus he keeps getting into some mess or the other from which Bakhtiyar only saves him. I always wonder, from Ammar get so much money to do drugs and Cigarettes?

I was baffled by Nashwa dialogues yest. And on top of that, she had the audacity to say, Burhan always had a golden life. Is she also on weed😡. I wish Burhan had heard that dialogues, then maybe he would have started hating her. I still wonder why Burhan is there in this show. His character has just been reduced to crying love sick character.

https://x.com/pakidilemma/status/1908832178747605437?t=HsBy0OrlkPrGT0rr9u5jlg&s=19

This is the narrative the writer trying to sell too.

PTV actors and writers need to be media trained . Once show blows up there is horde of IV’s and everyone spills something and boom all social media drama starts and kinda kills the show. Especially writers they just need to stop giving spoilers.

Still believe QEJ ain’t going Nikkah Ka Taqat way ! Ammaar can realise his mistake and own it up and should face consequences - Death or Jail but no way it should be coz he falls in love with Nashwa.

Finally Yumna should like stay miles away from shows with Abuse in plot ! She has done quite # of shows with that theme. It’s time she picks up urban story with work place BG or romcom.

Originally posted by: nightingale1234

Hey, no, I was talking about X, reddit n insta comments.

omg, there is a thread against Yumna every hour on Reddit. I figured out why, People are especially salty because she got nominated for TB and some trolls/haters are using the dialogues in the latest episode to hate on her without watching the show.

For all we know, they can somehow undo all the problematic dialogues in the next few episodes. It could be a monologue to herself that she said that to pacify her mom which is obvious from her body language but it still boiled my blood

I think it is the dragging and repetition that is hurting this show.

Originally posted by: Sparkle232

https://x.com/pakidilemma/status/1908832178747605437?t=HsBy0OrlkPrGT0rr9u5jlg&s=19

This is the narrative the writer trying to sell too.

This is very problematic and disappointing