Melancholic One Sided Goodbye - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

79

Views

10.9k

Users

40

Likes

773

Frequent Posters

svkworld2 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#41
Thanks Tanu for the wonderful post after such an emotional episode. I am ready with my tissue boxes for tomorrow :(

Everyone covered all the points, so nothing much to add but I do have a doubt. Can anyone tell me why NAvya was telling "Thanks Anant tum bohot acche ho"?? (I have stepped into Anant's mandbhuddhi shoes now !!!) Haven't they passed being formal stage?😕

I feel like I am in a home stretch forever in my project :(, unable to be active in the forum as much as I want to be .

P.S: Tanu/Nisha - Totally off-topic but I want to ask this...Remember we had talked about Shirtless Anant all wet...and you guys thought it wouldn't be a pretty sight. I hope you have seen the new pics posted (chicken wings -still WIP). Do you still think the same?? bolo bolo??😃


..Anita.. thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#42
I love this post!!!!
i agree that soumya is improving day by day
pixiegirl thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: anyafan

Dear all

I wanted to see the epi and then comment ... so here goes:

1. ANANT's Reactions: Let me defend Mandhbudhi this time!

I think he didnt expect anything as dramatic - when Navya hugs him tight - you can see a puzzled expression on his face. He then actuallyu asks her ki kya hua.. so hes slow but he picks up something. He looks a bit puzzled when she peeps out of the auto as well... so I think he was very good...

2. NAVYA's character:


Sorry guys - she was much better - but not as much as I thought - I think just because I have a hard time relating to the fact she can't say anything to him...????

Haan - are you going to be like Dukhi Atma and Meeta Ma - whi hide things from their hubbies? I mean you should be able to tell him anything... :) yes, he is going to be hurt anyway... Navya cant stand up to Anant and tell him shes hurting too / stand up to her mom... and she is like this "Im the OH SO MARTYR" ...ACHI BACHCHI??? This is sooo different from the reticent but determined and brave during mushkil waqt Navya that was portrayed so far... so a bit strange...

3. Ritz - Appy:


Really wonderfully acted out ladies...bang on expressions - the works. KUDOS... you were the best today!

4. PRECAP

Am ready for the tissue box - I cant wait to see the hear wrenching good bye...silent or not.. I am ALL SET to be VOWED by Anant

DROOL SUM WAS SO handsome today - the shirt, the white Tee, the Blue shirt - FINALLY
!! Even Navya looked good in her nightie - beats the travel outfit!


Hi Dee, I saw the epis. again on TV now in it's entirety rather than in a hurry like I did this AM, and loved your reply and my thoughts are exactly like yours.

1. ANANT's Reactions: Let me defend Mandhbudhi this time! - Agree, I found his acting completely justified today (As always, ahem 😉). I am one of those few people on the forum who doesn't mind seeing his high-on-candy behavior. He is completely adorable when he does that, not that I mind at all when he is being sensible too. He is probably the only actor whom I don't mind seeing being a little idiotic 😉 for want of a better word, at times. It suits his role completely of being a "head over heels in love" guy, whose brains do fly out of the window sometimes. But if there is anyone out there who can pull it off, it's Shaheer, love him for that. Am, so in love with this guy 😳

2. NAVYA's character: When I saw the epis. this AM in a hurry, her acting I thought, was much better, but now that I have seen it again, it leaves a lot to be desired. Sorry guys, don't mean to offend any one, but really, Soumya's acting doesn't do a thing for me sadly. She does a much better job in happy situations but literally sucks at sad situations. And I'm tired of seeing her one glycerine tear everyday, why is it never more than one, I wonder? Glycerine too expensive??

One of the contributing factors to her expressions could be her hair-style. As it is, she has lost weight and her face looks exhausted and taut all the time. At least, if she sported a different hair style that would soften her looks, she may look better when she looks sad. Who leaves, long hair like hers, open on a couple of days train journey??

I know, not many people will agree to what I'm saying and don't get me wrong, her attempt at laughing at Anant's jokes thru her tears, her hug and peeping from the auto were all good, but they could have been a lot better IMO. Any other actress would have nailed those scenes, b/c they by themselves were such heart-breaking scenes. Only a little display of emotion was needed to make them perfect.

But the only scene I really like about Navya today was when she was driving with the car window down and reliving those special moments with Anant, that really touched me.

Another reason for me being so critical of Soumya's acting is prolly b/c of Shaheer's acting being perfect each & every time. Even Appy, Ritz & Ranbir are such good actors. Why can't she learn something from them??

Again waiting for all the ande tamatars. As always, just my opinion, sorry.

Edited by pixiegirl - 14 years ago
Savithacrao thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#44
haha when u mentioned about Navya going away from Anant for 6 weeks and asking us to pretend we don't know about the spoiler 😆, i was wondering what would have happened if we had no spoiler... Most of us would be busy cursing the CVs for the long separation track...Thank God because of the spoiler, we are able to enjoy the current emotional track...😉

It was very sad to see Navya suffering all alone without even giving a hint to Anant...As you mentioned, Navya's decision to hide about her travel to Kanpur was absolutely right because sometimes our Anant gets very stubborn especially when it involves Navya 😳 and it becomes very difficult to control him 😆 So sweet, our Navya has understood Anant so well...

Overall i just loved today's episode, especially Anant & Navya scene and Appy & Ritz throughout the show...😃

Something the CVs can avoid is showing Navya carrying the same bag wherever she goes 😔. they can make her carry a hand purse when she is not going to college...In today's scene also, when she goes to meet Anant, it would have been great if she was shown without that bag... Nevertheless i dont want to complain much about these small things, because just watching our Anya and her lovely friends itself is a big treat...😳

Edited by Savithacrao - 14 years ago
imnowhere thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#45
Already 6 pages!!!
Well nothing much to add today. Everything said and done. Tanu u just spoke my heart.
Agreed to all...Soumya stole the show. Her portrayal of Navya fighting her inner turmoils without letting it come to her face was simply brilliant. She knew that the news of her departure would snatch the smile off Anant's face and so she chose not to be the person to disclose it.
The most memorable scene for me from the episode was that of Navya in memories of her bygone days. I was almost lost before I recovered.
Good bye scenes have always been teary for me in real life. And I am getting ready to be moved to tears yet again with a reel scene in the next episode.
And I won't lose the opportunity to appreciate the dialogue writers. All of yesterday's funny and sentimental dialogues were great. Kudos to them.👍🏼

Meeta's reactions surprise me no more. I think, yes, she needs time to reflect and react(as sajni786 aka Shilpa said earlier) before accepting and for this she needs to be lonely. Navya's absence is definitely going to boost it. The countdown has begun at the station I guess.

BTW Shilpa(sajni786) are u quite busy these days? I m terribly missing ur diary entries...specially after yesterday's episode. Hope to find one at least after today's episode.

Edited by mridula.shome - 14 years ago
shreya789 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#46
@pixiegirl, no anda tamatar... everyone has his/her opinion... personally i think soumya has improved and in this episode she was probably at her best. As for Shaheer, he is the best looking guy on TV. In fact I started watching this show after falling for him during the picnic episode... and he acts quite well. love his expressions... saw his face in tue episode when he saw ritz and appy with navya getting off from the auto ?? so cuuute !!
pixiegirl thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#47
@pixiegirl, no anda tamatar... everyone has his/her opinion... personally i think soumya has improved and in this episode she was probably at her best. As for Shaheer, he is the best looking guy on TV. In fact I started watching this show after falling for him during the picnic episode... and he acts quite well. love his expressions... saw his face in tue episode when he saw ritz and appy with navya getting off from the auto ?? so cuuute !![/QUOTE]

I agree with you, Soumya's acting has definitely improved a lot, but she should pull it up even more, now that she has had considerable practice.

And @ Bold, I wanted to mention that too, completely slipped my mind, I too loved his expression on that scene, he looked so frustrated on seeing those two haddis once again crop up in their kabab 😆 😆
Idealistic thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#48

Originally posted by: laddoo598

Today's episode was such an emotional one for me..Navya and Anant's last proper meeting before she left for Kanpur was so sentimental..Navya tried hard to fight her inner turmoils and succeeded in keeping her departure a secret from Anant..In her own way she bid goodbye to her beloved..She was all intent on leaving silently, without telling and thereby hurting him but he came to know about it nonetheless..If today's episode was such a tear jerker then what will happen tomorrow??very true agree wid ur each and every word...


However, the most hilarious part of the episode is what was going on in the background.. 😆😆😆As Navya devi was preparing to dig her own grave, Appy and Ritz were banging their heads on the wall..🤣🤣I burst out laughing seeing their expressions- especially Appy's which were on the lines of "Stop talking, for the love of God, stop talking, khud toh maregi, aur hume bhi le dubegi"..🤣🤣Kudos to Appy-Ritz for providing the much neeeded touch of humour in the otherwise sentimental episode..😃
it was too hilarious ...appy ritz really bring humour in dat senti epi ...in d dat scene i wasnt seeing navya n her mom ..m eyes wer on appy ritz ...lol dat banging scene was 🤣🤣🤣
The GoodBye-everything that was sweet: Haiii this scene was so sweet and so sad at the same time..Seeing Navya in her house clothes Anant said "Main tumhare liye taiyar hone ke chakkar me ghayal ho gaya aur tum taiyar bhi nahin huyi" while pointing to his booboo..😆😆Navya asked him whether she wasn't looking good and lover boy said "Mujhe toh tum kachre ke thaili pehenke bhi acchi hi lagogi" 🤣🤣🤣🤣...Awww he manages to make Navya and all the phangirls blush while talking about making her wearing a garbage bag..😳😳😆agree ..my god he so sweet



really 2day's epi was really emotional ...bt i cant take meeta nw...enough z enough ...poor navya z always trying nt to hide wid her mom nythin bt ...meeta neva understand dat ...man she z goin 2day ...wil cum bk after 6 weeks ...or dono for hw long ..coz remember she dint book for return ticket 😡😡😡😡...i jus wan meeta to soon cum to knw abt renuka's issue ...


d most awaited scene anya's meeting ...😳😳😳😳...as i was expecting ...even i was expecting der hug before leaving kanpur ...bt wow ...the way navya came back n hugged anant tightly conveyed everything dat ...she dono wana go ...yesterday sowmya was at her best ..i must say diz ...though many ppl dislyk her acting ...bt dono y i love her acting ...she jus giv me a real one ...nt doin ny ova acting ...acting jus lyk hw ppl act in real situations ...i think dats wht z one of the specialty of navya ...(i knw many won agree) dats only my opinion ..

shaheer looks more n more cute in tensed scene ...i jus love dat ...😳😳😳😳...d tym wen anant got to knw dat navay z leaving😭😭😭😭 ...n wen he said to ritz dat hw can she go widout even tellin me nythin 😭😭😭😭...n even after seeing navya's msg ...he kept on driving d car so dat he cld see navya jus once before she leave to kanpur ...awww..

as per d sbs ...i think anant wil meet navya in train ...wen everybody wil b in platform .n poor anant wil b left alone wid navya's letter😭😭😭...n even in the precap anant was moving towards seeing navya ..hiz eyes can epxress d feeling of pain and separation😒😒in dat i dono wan meeta shd c anant even for once ...wating for 2days epi eagerly ... .


btw nice post tanu ...2day ur post was really really amazing ...

sajni786 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#49
Tanuuu🤗...ya m late today in posting my tit bits...but sweetzz...u have outperformed ur own posts today with that philosophical touch u gave it...I loved every bit of details n description u gave...
U really have left not much to say for me today...but I do wanna thank u for the mention in ur post...it makes me humble😳...but u very rightly said...Anant today totally spelled out his denial mode in point black! HE really bragged on n on in innocency about how he has won over Meeta n now needs to work only a tit bit more to get daddy dear in the pockets...least does he know..."pyar mein imitehaan abhi aur bhi hain"...

True testing times has already begun for Navya n Anant shall follow in no time...separation is on the verge n Navya with her constant battle of her inner n outer self...stood facing Anant with a smile that was beaded in shattering pieces of the heart. What was so not digestable to see as u very acurately pointed out was Anant not being able to see thru her ...thru this facade of happiness that she had put on!! It really hits u in the gut to realize the level of denial this guy has reached that u just wanna bang his head n knock some sense into him at that moment...but alas...I suppose the separation will suffice as a good lesson for now...

Anant is one guy who symbolizes a coin for me...banda flips his sides from one to another within a split of a second...n while he can manage to irritate u to point where u wanna say "oh come'on mandbudddhi"...he just as quickly takes u by surprise with his utter sensibilities n maturity as well that just comes flushing in...It was really endearing to see how he instead of getting angry n began throwing tantrums on his poor books n wat not in his room...he actually managed to gauge the level of seriousness of the issue at hand n without having a mind to rebel ...he is set off to do the only choice he is left with...at that is to meet Navya n see her off 1 last time b4 she leaves him sulking in pain...M sure banda is all set to empty our tissue boxes tomorrow!!!
😭


Edited by sajni786 - 14 years ago
supria thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#50
tanu..i stay away from this forum for just a day n i miss so much...n on the 8th page n there's nothing much left to say...just loved the way appy-ritz handle things for navya...their expressions sre simply adorable...they read n see thru every feelingof Anyas...n wish ur mandhbuddhi hopefully will not land up in front of meeta ma at the station today...he's so adorable...the expressions he gives when appy-ritz got out of the auto at the park...good he didnt say haddis...they've actually proving to be the spine for Anya ever since meeta ma has entered the pic...Soumya was actually navya at the park...her hidden tears...her hug to absorb as much of him n the way she peeps out of the auto...poor mandhbuddhi felt something was wtong but was so happy that he got some time with her that he missed probing further...hope the separation wont be for long...now that the families r going to come face to face, hope it will be a pleasant meeting, else our Anya are in trouble...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".