Judges being biased towards certain kinds of acts.

FanNoOne111 thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#1
Lately I've been wondering that if its only me or you also believe that Judges give higher scores to Emotional & Sensual acts.

1. Pritam & Amnajot KATE NAHI KATTE (28)
2. Pritam & Amanjot JANAM JANAM (30)
3. Mohit & Sanaya AAJ JANE KI (28)
4. Siddharth & Trupti HAMDARD (30)

Right after Pritjot did something other than Emotional & Sensual Acts they came down to the bottom. Dancing should be judged only, Putting aside all the kinds of Emotions.
Have just heard that This week all Three Top Scorer couples will perform either emotional or Sensual act. I'm not against any couple but I'm really disappointed by biased scoring towards certain Dance forms. What do you think..???

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

1.7k

Users

6

Likes

22

Frequent Posters

Guinea thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#2
I think it's more imp that a well done act is scored well whether it is emotional or sensual . Out of the 4. Acts you mentioned I felt two were correctly scored ...
Pritam and amanjot's Janam Janam
Mohit and sanayas aaj Jane ki ..
FanNoOne111 thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: Guinea

I think it's more imp that a well done act is scored well whether it is emotional or sensual . Out of the 4. Acts you mentioned I felt two were correctly scored ...
Pritam and amanjot's Janam Janam
Mohit and sanayas aaj Jane ki ..



I agree those acts were given fair scores but I believe even if they had been badly performed Judges would still had appreciated it with great marks.
Guinea thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: FanNoOne111



I agree those acts were given fair scores but I believe even if they had been badly performed Judges would still had appreciated it with great marks.



Dunno abt that ... But maybe their is a pattern .. Let's see .
AraBearxo thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#5
I honestly don't think there's anything to do with the dance forms. Some couples follow a certain path.
Like Monaya are sensuous and have begun experimenting with shit scary lifts and different dance forms. They have good choreography and show improvement.

Divek, together, is mostly emotional tv serial types serenading and dancing around. Nothing high energy or fast paced.

Brent-Aashka highlight for me was the Broadway like performance. Their mistakes are ignored, performances are good and basically worth the watch but they owl won't last for long.

I have stopped bothering with Deepika Shoaib. This is after me being thoroughly impressed by them during promotions and that time frame. I'm so done with Deepika's emotional atyachar and rona dhona. Shoaib is such a sweetheart, honestly. Such a nice down to earth guy. I'm not saying they're bad but there's a certain limit of drama that they have crossed. Same goes for every couple that has over shared.

Sanam and Abigail are such a treat to watch. Like Monaya, they experiment a lot and most of their stuff is so complicated. So proud of Abigail for keeping up.

Bharti. Oh my, Bharti. If that girl concentrated on dancing as she did on talking and hitting on random men. Then... Bharti iz the nicest, clean hearted person that there is and her life stories focus on her life during her struggle not the aww stories. It's nice to hear and listen. But then, the hitting and cringiness is what uncalled for Bharti. I would love to see you in the finale. Win even. You're inspiring.

I don't watch Monalisa Vikrant closely enough to comment but I do know that they do fun dances. Since the eliminations are mostly popularity wise then they could be in danger soon. Mona is a nice soul. I haven't watched her in BB. Vikrant too.

Despite being someone who follows Divyanka, I hate the negative publicity the recent acts have gotten her. Can someone please tell her PR that this isn't helping her but ruining her image? Ardent Star plus followers who don't follow sites like IF and other viewers are fed up of her. And I'm talking about people who I struggled to find to have Nach Baliye watch companions in real life. People who voted for Divek the first week with me because hey, no matter what they danced they are their favorites and they will vote for them no matter what because divyanka is star plus Ishita. The same people have now begun voting for other contestants.

Dear Divyanka, please fire your PR. They're out to ruin you. Also, remember, you rose like a Pheonix from the ashes of what the industry did to you and your bad experiences. Please don't burn that away by being "nice". Winning Nach Baliye 8 does nothing for no one. Who cares about the previous winners now? I'm sure you earn more that what Nach and the reward money is by the events bestowed on you by sheer public love. Please don't mess that love up for validation you do not need. The same goes for every contestant out there who is shredding the self respect they have on national and international television. This is the age of the Internet. Nothing put out there fades away anymore.

And if I get quoted by any "troll" quoting for some fun: either have the guts to come with your original account or don't bother while I report your newbie one.
justprati thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#6
well, had emotional stuff / dance form been favored than sanam abigail's 2nd performance "had se jyada pyar..." would have got more points. But, apparently the judges felt their act had less dance. Though, I felt their act had more dance than any other emotional acts till date in NB8.
I think it depends on the jodi, each jodi's performance is compared to their last performance while scoring. They aren't competing with each other, they are competing with themselves and scores are given for their growth, not for their acts.
FanNoOne111 thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: justprati

well, had emotional stuff / dance form been favored than sanam abigail's 2nd performance "had se jyada pyar..." would have got more points. But, apparently the judges felt their act had less dance. Though, I felt their act had more dance than any other emotional acts till date in NB8.

I think it depends on the jodi, each jodi's performance is compared to their last performance while scoring. They aren't competing with each other, they are competing with themselves and scores are given for their growth, not for their acts.



You know what, your reply just satisfied my concerns.
sadhnasoumya thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#8
I feel the second and third were correctly scored
And the fourth to some extent maybe little over scored
The first one I haven't seen so no idea about that
WhatTheF thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: justprati

well, had emotional stuff / dance form been favored than sanam abigail's 2nd performance "had se jyada pyar..." would have got more points. But, apparently the judges felt their act had less dance. Though, I felt their act had more dance than any other emotional acts till date in NB8.

I think it depends on the jodi, each jodi's performance is compared to their last performance while scoring. They aren't competing with each other, they are competing with themselves and scores are given for their growth, not for their acts.


+1


I guess only terence can be fair while giving scores.. Mohit and Sona like you said 😆
FanNoOne111 thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: sadhnasoumya

I feel the second and third were correctly scored

And the fourth to some extent maybe little over scored
The first one I haven't seen so no idea about that



My point is not that whether these 4 dances were correctly scored ot not. My real points is how are all the highest scored acts either Emotional or Sensual. I hope I made myself clear.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".