they got 30/30...not fair!

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

petticoat

@petticoat

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 18 years ago

#11

Originally posted by: srkthebest
i don't think it's fair that Hussain and Tina got 30/30 just for the concept (2nd song) of their song. That's totally unfair!! Being a judge, aren't you supposed to judge the performance also?? It's not only the concept that matters. Judging by their performance, they clearly didn't deserve a 30 for their performance. 😡 TB and YG deserved a 30/30 for their 2nd performance. The concept was great and their performance was great also.

exactly...
I was wondering how they got a 30 will TB ened up with a measly 25...

and yea neither HUTI performance was excellent.. both were average..coordination was absent..look at kserasera video... this does not even come to half the original performance's level... gimme a break

To me TB's first performance was the best among judges' choice songs.

jodi's choice i liked tb & yg....yg were too good

Quote

kriti

@remixer

Inactive

Posted: 18 years ago

#12

I guess u guys are wrong kyonki there concept they way they danced ............it was mind blowing i guess malaika kunal and masterji was apsouletely write.........Agar main unki jagah hotii to i would have give them 30 A 😃

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Not Given

@Chippeshwini

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 18 years ago

#13

no one is wrong with opinion...

and yea their concept was execllent 👏 ... i really felt like hugging HT and saluting. lekin we cant ignore the fact that there was a bit of physical discoordination between Hussain and Tina.

it was just that bit that i felt was wrong...everything else was greatt. I think they deserved a 29

Quote

petticoat

@petticoat

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 18 years ago

#14

there is no wrong or right here..

it is only that your opinion is different from my opinion...

Quote

srishti bhutani

@srishti bhutani

Voyager

Posted: 18 years ago

#15

i dun think that thr was lack of coordination or something!they did deserve a perfect score
and someone said that none of their performances deserve a 30 but every1 knows that their blindfolded act and dancing with rope act did deserve a 30!infact i think that a very few of TB performances deserve a 30 but evrytime they got 30 becoz of their so called energy level jumping is not dance!no offense!but a fact

Quote

Nadaanmasakalli

@naadanmasakalli

Master

+ 11

Posted: 18 years ago

#16

they deserve it they were fabolous n i tink yash gauri too deserve a 30 for their 2 performance

Quote

Alishba

@*Alishba*

Sparkler

Posted: 18 years ago

#17

I loved the concept & performance too👏
They deserved 30👏

TB,s Concept was v.good but their performance was OK!

Quote

nitya

@preethi

Sparkler

Posted: 18 years ago

#18

huti did a great job.there concept was just grea and there performance was just fab.they def deserve 30/30
HUTI u just rock come on you all can do it 👏 👏 👏

Quote

*Resham*

@*Resham*

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 18 years ago

#19

I do say tht yg deserved 30 for their second performance bt I also maintain tht why all of a sudden this hutina started up?

When others missd coordination noone even raised a hint to it bt when now it came to hutina everyone has a point to it..

Secondly I wd say tht they got 30 in second round was most probably nt for the steps bt the feel they gave to the entire audience which was exceedinly well..

Almost everyone cried seeing tht and so didnt looked for the coordination..

Quote

Ekta

@Eksie

Stunner

+ 3

Posted: 18 years ago

#20

Originally posted by: srkthebest
i don't think it's fair that Hussain and Tina got 30/30 just for the concept (2nd song) of their song. That's totally unfair!! Being a judge, aren't you supposed to judge the performance also?? It's not only the concept that matters. Judging by their performance, they clearly didn't deserve a 30 for their performance. 😡 TB and YG deserved a 30/30 for their 2nd performance. The concept was great and their performance was great also.

Many think HuTina did not deserve 30.. while most think they deserved it. Fair enough.

IMO.. it all boils down to IMPACT! HuTina's performance had an 'impact' on the judges and audience (barring a few!) alike.. and thats whats counted as a 'good performance'.. and in such cases, a teeny-weeny mistake doesn't really matter.

Dancing is dancing 1-2-3 steps.. whereas a Performance is dancing and much more (concept & emotions included).. Being a good performer is whats important..

Take SRK & Hrithik's case.. both Live in Concert! SRK is a good dancer, while Hrithik is a perfectionist dancer! SRK does goof up at times on stage.. but bottomline is, his performances on stage have a resounding impact on the audience sitting there.. Its his live-wire energy that connects him with the audience. If you were to sit across a table and judge Hrithik & SRK's performances.. while you give Hrithik full 30 marks for being brilliant... you will also give SRK full 30, inspite of his goof-ups..simply coz it leaves an impact!

I'm not comparing here.. this was just an example.. No offence to Hrithik & SRK's fans.. 😊

Edited by Ektaj - 18 years ago