Gauri and Hiten werent that good - Page 6

Created

Last reply

Replies

117

Views

5.3k

Users

42

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

ishimukh thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#51

Originally posted by: farzana98

****************** the mentors gave gauri-hiten wut they deserved...n wutever keerti-sharad deserved..who r u to point out at gauri-hiten huh??

yeah gauri-hiten got the 2nd highest votes....their fanz r voting for them.....do u have any problem??

******************************

XCUSE ME HITEN AND GAURI GOT THE HIGHEST VOTES FROM THE AUDIENCE!

********No personal attacks. Please take it easy.This is not a fan club,but a discussion board.Please substanciate your arguments with good clean reason. Thanks.*********

Edited by Minnie - 18 years ago
Minnie thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 18 years ago
#52

Hey friends, please chill out !!!!!

Let me put down a few lines which will segregate discussions from 'instigating'.

This is a reality show,and that too performance based. All the participants are real life people,not characters,but because they are diectly involved in the show as themselves,their performance will be a topic of discussion.

So you CAN discuss their dance. Their movements, what you felt could have been done better, who you thought had better movements,ahd better choreography.

All the jodi fans,please understand that if there is a performance,there will be discussion,and there will be criticism. Criticism do not mean hatred. Please do not take every adverse comment on them as an attack. Try to counter the posts with valid points,backed by reason.

For example, a post saying ' XYZ dance steps were bad, I feel at this sequence,the hip movements were wrong'.....if you do not agree, you can counter with ' that sequence required it. Their movements were better than ABC who moved this this way....'.

This is part and parcel of a discussion board. If we do not like anything that is connected to the program,we do have a right to criticise.This is not a fan club where we come to praise, praise and praise.Please try to engage in critical analysis,instead of 'don't like them leave them alone,don't watch,don't criticise' etc etc.' Please understand,this is NOT a fan club,and please don't attack people who criticise your favs,be it Hiten Gauri,Hussain-Tina or Gurdeep Arjun.

2) However,no actor can be bashed on anything other than his/her actual performance. So what ABC did in Kyunki serial has nothing to do with nach baliye,the colour of his/her pants in a party 3 months back and the repeat costumes have nothing to do with Nach Baliye. Rediculing what she ate and what he drank in a party cannot be a topic of sattire,as it serves no purpose and only contributes to negativity. So such topics shall be trashed without any warning.

Anything that happened in an episode of nach Baliye can be a topic of discussion,as long as the discussion is done in a positive and sensitive manner. Also,a very important note.

Just as you are free to engage in critical analysis,and positive criticism, you need to do in a positive manner,keeping in mind the feelings and respect of your other fellow members. Please remember,criticism is a part of life,and if done properly,it promotes discussion. But criticising simply because you want to settle scores or you do not like someone is not allowed. Please avoid rediculing actors, instead, critically analise their performance. Instigating, baiting,trolling,profane,abusing posts are not allowed,and nor are personal attacks or shouting on the forum by writing in all caps.

Hope this helps.

parii833 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#53
Thankyou......hope these kinds of posts will be taken off.........thankyou
Minnie thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 18 years ago
#54

Originally posted by: ritu26_sh

My question to Lonely whatever ...
U said Gauri and Hiten were not that good
I am a bit confused here, BTW what was ur main purpose of starting this thread ?
Gauri and Hiten were not good for what ?
Did they get top scores ?
Did they got out of ordinary remarks by the judges ?
Did they say " we are the best " and U are protesting against it ?
Ur messages are plainly showing that U want to create trouble with Gauri and Hiten's fans, knowing very well that U are hurting their sentiments and provoking their outburst.
Cud u please do something more constructive for this Forum.


Ritu,this topic is valid. Gauri and Hiten did not score high,and their performance in the first round was nothing to write home about,and it was that on which the votes were supposed to be based, so their getting the top votes does not match their dancing prowess, as this being a dance competition,top votes should go to people who dance the best,and not the ones we like the most, so this is a valid discussion topic. You have a right to voice what you feel and give reasons for your stand. However,please do not start questioning topics. If you feel there is a problem,please use the report option to report it to mods. Being constructive means generating discussion topics,not opening fan clubs.

Hope this clears it up.

parii833 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#55

i agree......its unfair.......since only posts being directed to are at GHT......its getting out of hand......and its not positive critism but negative...almost harsh and brash

if everyone was psoitively criticising them it would be fine .but directing post in their direction and then getting discussion out of hand is wrong

Edited by parii833 - 18 years ago
parii833 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#56

well thats bad then i guess i can go ahead and criticise HUSSAIN and Tina, Shweta Raja, shweta manav, Sharadd kirti etc etc...as I wish

THE ONLY REASON I DIDNT was out of respect for their fans...when they dont have any for us ...why bother respecting them and their choice

Edited by parii833 - 18 years ago
Minnie thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 18 years ago
#57

Originally posted by: komal_life

GENRALLY DISCUSSING DOSNT MEAN INSULTING MINNIE b4 writing plz read the topic carefully ! I just wish tht this forum dosnt turn biased ...as for telling moderators about all this we have done it b4 so plz read allthe msgs thoroughly and then comment if in yr view talking nastily and insulting others is aloowed so i guess we r all free to do it so we'll star also!!!!!!!

Yes, generally discussing do not mean insulting. If you can provide me with specific posts which you feel have been insulting and are not based on their current performance,and no action has been taken, please give me the link. I will rectify it right away. For that you will have to go back and check all the messages,so I understand it will take time. I will wait.

Hope this helps 😊

Minnie thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 18 years ago
#58

Originally posted by: parii833

well thats bad then i guess i can go ahead and criticise HUSSAIN and Tina, Shweta Raja, shweta manav, Sharadd kirti etc etc...as I wish

THE ONLY REASON I DIDNT was out of respect for their fans...when they dont have any for us ...why bother respecting them and their choice

Yes you can.This is NOT a fan club. As long as your criticism is based on reason and not revenge, it will be welcome as that will generate discussion.

parii833 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 18 years ago
#59

Originally posted by: Minnie

Yes you can.This is NOT a fan club. As long as your criticism is based on reason and not revenge, it will be welcome as that will generate discussion.

Thanx Minnie...now i will deifnately voice my opinions with good reasons..and there will be posts on my opinons that will be justifiable too

Minnie thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 18 years ago
#60

Originally posted by: komal_life

pari i rea minni's post and it kinda says wht ever is being said is f9 as it is critisism and its allowed irrespective of wht people r writing? so now im defintaley gona write stuff what i feel for other couples !

Yes Komal,you can. My stand will be same: be sensitive in your criticism,and base your criticism on their performance. Don't criticise for the sake of it,because just as this is not a fan club,it's not a bash club either.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".