Originally posted by: J2lover
I agree with every word of yours! We say as progressive audience we should support strong female characters! And that's what we thought bani is initially! She came across as very leads who came in between to save the hero and not the other way round...as in bani came in between jay-veer's first fight ever at noor's wedding and tried to give Veer a piece of mind when usually its the hero who becomes the savior of the heroine! So, they really established her quite strong! But as you said, she was supposed to be this tender, soft hearted but emotionally strong hearted girl who feels deeply! In reality when hina's naageshwari was stating to nia's character that she was seperated from her love for 10,000 years I could feel that tadap a bit! But bani never conveyed that tadap! Bani had to highlight two emotions inside her! As that was the crux of the story! Ek taraf extreme nafrat aur dusri taraf extreme pyaar! She sucessfully potrayed her hate for Veer, but the pain of why she hates him so much was never delivered through her eyes or tears! Shallow hi rhe gya usska character! You know bani ko aadi-naagin dikhane ke chakkar mei ussko robotic bana diya! Jay ke liye usska pyaar aur Veer ke liye nafrat, that should have been extremely strong! VaNi ka story baad mei kaise shape up krte usske 1000 raaste the, but jay-bani ka equation unhe deep banana chahiye tha! Every ounce of bani's character was only hate hate and only hate! Neither was she lovable with Veer, nor with jay in these 3 months. Bani wasn't supposed to cry buckets but she was supposed to feel and make us feel what she's feeling! Woh din kabhi aya hi nai!😆
Exactly...This is what I try to say when I keep saying emotions emotions like broken record.😆I personally didnt like hena as naagin and naageshwari hriday had zero chemistry....But in that scene with Brinda, you are right....uski pyaar, pyaar khone ka dard, 10000 saal ka tadap, and in sab k lie guilty uss akesh k taraf nafrat...it was all very well expressed in that scene...u cud see it all...But its like Bani hone k baad vo only nafrat chod k baki sab feel karna bhul gayi...Robot ban gayi....noor death episode tak thik tha...but uske baad se itna poor characterization she started coming accross as a very negative jhagralu hateful person who for no strong reason gives everyone grief and is not capable of any positive emotions for anyone...how thanda she was with jay it was very odd and it didnt go with the hate she felt for veer on his behalf....bohot sare episodes waste karne ki ya ansu bahane ki zaroorat nehi thi jai-bani k piche...kaise portray karna tha, mukta could have very well taken notes from N3...vikrant and Ruhi ko exactly one episode sath dikhaya tha, the one where he gets killed and Ruhi saw the pistol in Mahir's hand...and then next episode Bela(Ruhi) Mahir story started but nobody ever questioned her pain of loosing the other half and her need for revenge or why she was so rude to mahir in initial episodes...Her pain and love and loss came through so well that everyone connected instantly...the character was that well written from start....Bani was not well written at all, depth hi nehi hai....
Even now it could be rectified to some extent! They must make bani extremely passionate in love! Nafrat mei hadd paar karr di na, toh pyaar mei bhi she has to! She cannot stay this aloof all the time! Veeranshu jaisa character is such a passionate lover! Its unlikely to show a heroine like bani to stay this balanced all the time! Love born out of extreme hate could be actually shown in a beautiful manner!❤️ Romance na sahi, people need to feel that pain and tadap of bani! But madam ek din rooti hai dusre din dhakka deti hai!😆 Upar se soch kya rhi hai kise pata! Bani ko heroine hi bana diya bss, ussko ek 28 saal ki ladki jiss mei feelings hai, woh likhna bhul hi gye writers! Ab bhugto!🤔
Even I feel only bad for SharBhi! How good they are at their craft! Especially for Surbhi! I saw IB ke ek do scenes...her as anika....she was terrific yrr!😭 Kaha ek, one tone character de diya usse! Surbhi can potray a gamut of emotions at once! Wish they would utilize it!
sach mein....Sharad and Surbhi itna accha kar rahe and Vani itna popular hua hai phir bhi only coz of bad writing and execution unke hard work waste ho rahe...I feel so bad...Veer k to writting bhi accha hai...bas bani ki character kharab likha itna k sab kharab ho gaya...varna emotions and reactions and drama surbhi does very well, anyone who has seen anika knows that...10000yrs apne andar itna sab kuch dabake suffer karne k baad jab bani ko satyug yaad aya she should have been a very deep intense mass of emotions type of characters...istead we got a robot...Wish makers would still wake up and utilize their resources properly...I mean this is the same mukta responsible for Behir and Drikshit....she needs to wake up, watch the episodes so far and rectify what went wrong...