But the thing is tragedies in between the show make them interesting. I mean already the emotional factor in this show is missing. All the previous season had that so they kind of worked, and Indian audiences being emotional themselves get drawn to shows where emotions like bereavement and sadness are present as they are a driving force to them connecting to the show.
Perhaps Veer ends up killing Jay yet again, because there was supposed to be a battle between the two for Markaat’s powers. Jay deceitfully attack’s Veer but ends up getting defeated and killed in the process without knowing that this would make him inherit Markaat’s dark powers which then take over him and begin altering not just his body but also his mind which gets him out of control and out of fear that he might hurt Bani or anyone else he either asks Bani to kill him again or ends up killing himself instead. Perhaps Bani does save her clan, but Markaat through some underhanded means petrifies Bani and she remains that way till Veer returns back alive to release her as apparently only he has the ability to undo fake Markaat’s spell.
Well, to be honest, this is something very American supernatural show worthy and ITV lacks creativity. I am not saying that this won't work, but I don't know if they will show it this way. I agree with the tragedy being an emotional connector, but they might not show it the way you say, they could show it in another context altogether. And for some reason, they have tried to uphold the rawness of supernatural original shapeshifting creatures and keep the emotional quotient down. But honestly, I have no problem with connecting with any character - be it villain or not. I only cannot connect with Bani.