Wildcard Round: Himesh Reshammiya - Page 6

Originally posted by: saq123

Annuji u r amazing👏 This time i will give u a tribute by posting one of Annuji's biggest chartbusters. Funnily enough i even like the song. Feel no shame in saying I am following u😉

www.youtube.com/watch?v=QYH6kRWu3gs

I'd like to reciprocate with an Anu-KK collaboration 😃:

[YOUTUBE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RzNmIhYjeJs[/YOUTUBE]

Originally posted by: xobile

Frankly, your 'hater' nonsense bores me.

Anyone who reads my review will see that I have given proper, valid reasons for my score. I didn't just say 'Himesh, therefore automatic 1 mark'. My points were objective and fair, not dogmatic like a 'hater'.

Thankfully summer3 and a few readers have supported my right to express my honest opinion without labelling me a 'hater'.

Yes I am the only judge who has the guts to give a professional recording artist below average marks for their singing. But can you fault my argument? NO. Can you prove that (roughly) more than 50% of Bollywood singing is worse than this? NO.

Despite these disagreements I have with your argument/opinion, I am not labelling you at all! I could just say that you're a Himesh fanatic who clearly has a soft spot for HR and is therefore a biased judge. But I don't believe in challenging an argument by discrediting the person presenting that argument (known as an argument ad hominem). And before I slip into ad hominem mode, I shall end this post...

xobile, you missed the main reason I'm calling you biased/hater, and why you can't label me as anything like "HR fanatic"

Judge's Scores: (The ones who for sure think and listen to performance before grading)

4

7
10
9


Do you see the outlier? It's you. Not me. That's why it would be a legit opinion to say you are a biased hater rather than me a HR Fanatic. The scores are in front of you. Yours is the one that stands out as "odd". Not mine. So please, there is much stronger support for you being a biased hater than me a HR fanatic. The numbers are in front of us. My score was in the middle of the judges, yours was in the low end. 😆 If the scores were, 3, 4, 6, and then 10...you would have a point and I no argument for calling you a biased hater. But that is not the case. IT's the opposite. And wait and see that even the audience supports my 9 rather than your 4. YOU are the biased/hater.


Also xobile, I didn't choose this song. But there are some HR songs I'll post that even you will have to give a high score to HR for it!

LOL yes ssk - you are not biased towards HR at all, sorry my bad

And calling me a hater because I gave a different score (whilst ignoring all the reasons I gave for that score) - that is very good form!

Wah ssk wah!

Yes I gave a low much lower score than the other judges, but that was OBJECTIVELY reached - i.e. I was not biased at all. The other judges disagreed, that's fine! Doesn't prove I am biased at all. If risingabove chose different judges, u cud have been an outlier!

Anyway, I'm not gna get pulled into making personal attacks at u... Just prove to me that more than 50% of Bollywood singing is worse than this. Prove to me that nasal singing is NOT an easy way out of actual singing.

Of course I don't expect you to face up to any of those challenges - you'll just continue spewing your boring old 'hater' comments. Again, I'll end this post before I fall into the ad hominem mode...

Originally posted by: xobile

Anyway, I'm not gna get pulled into making personal attacks at u... Just prove to me that more than 50% of Bollywood singing is worse than this. Prove to me that nasal singing is NOT an easy way out of actual singing.

Go listen to any album, and Himesh's singing in this sing will be better than 90% of any of the songs you listen too. For me, it's more like 100% unless someone delivers a gem.

You want proof?

Here it is





Jai Matadi!
Jai Hindustan!

😊

Originally posted by: ssk13809

Go listen to any album, and Himesh's singing in this sing will be better than 90% of any of the songs you listen too. For me, it's more like 100% unless someone delivers a gem.

You want proof?

Here it is





Jai Matadi!
Jai Hindustan!

I think Mohit got one too.I mean that stuff Himmesh holding in his hand.

^^^

That's not filmfare. This was awarded to him by the rickshawallah union. That is why Himesh has million fans but not many on IF because most of them are rickshawallah's who don't know how to browse.

Originally posted by: brahmabul

^^^

That's not filmfare. This was awarded to him by the rickshawallah union. That is why Himesh has million fans but not many on IF because most of them are rickshawallah's who don't know how to browse.

That might be GOLDEN KELA AWARD

Polls are closed!


Audience Avg: 8.6
Judges Avg: 7.5


Final Avg: 8.1

Originally posted by: brahmabul

^^^

That's not filmfare. This was awarded to him by the rickshawallah union. That is why Himesh has million fans but not many on IF because most of them are rickshawallah's who don't know how to browse.

👏

Look like breadsticks or bones tied up together. 😆 😆