Spoiler 5thSemifinal Shreya's Team Vs Shaan's Team - Page 13

Created

Last reply

Replies

128

Views

21.2k

Users

33

Likes

83

Frequent Posters

Supremo thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

I remember a show , " Sa Re Ga Ma " first started on TV hosted by Sonu Nigam where judges were the great legends such as Anil Biswas, O.P Nayyar ,Jagjit Singh, Bhupinder, Pandit Jasraj, Ashaji, Anandji and many more .

That show had real class and all the singers were trained and of terrific calibre.Shreya Ghoshal, Kunal Ganjawala , Sanjeevani , Shekhar(of Vishal-Shekhar duo) and many more were winners in that show.Now these are successful singers and musicians.
Do you know why?
Thats because of the calibre of the judges and the decision lying completely with them and not the audience.
I recently saw the finale of a show called "singing star" on doordarshan which had khayyam sahab, kavita krishnamurthy, bhappi lahiri and ismail darbar as judges . Amazing show with amazing songs and singers and zero dramatics.The judges only decided the winner and it was the correct judgement.By the way the host was Aabhaas.
But such shows are ignored because they do not raise crores of rupees for the channel and producers.What a shame!!!!🤢
rahulfan94 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

I want Rahul to be winner. So I want Shankar team to win. I want Shankar v/s Himesh final. I not want Shankar v/s Shaan because Shaan team has all good singer and Shankar team danger in being lost. Shankar team have two best singer Rahul and Shankar and Himesh team have two good singer Vineet and Aishwarya. So Shankar team will be won.

Jay Ho Shankar Bhagwaan!

susm8 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: ashraynaik

I remember a show , " Sa Re Ga Ma " first started on TV hosted by Sonu Nigam where judges were the great legends such as Anil Biswas, O.P Nayyar ,Jagjit Singh, Bhupinder, Pandit Jasraj, Ashaji, Anandji and many more .

That show had real class and all the singers were trained and of terrific calibre.Shreya Ghoshal, Kunal Ganjawala , Sanjeevani , Shekhar(of Vishal-Shekhar duo) and many more were winners in that show.Now these are successful singers and musicians.
Do you know why?
Thats because of the calibre of the judges and the decision lying completely with them and not the audience.
I recently saw the finale of a show called "singing star" on doordarshan which had khayyam sahab, kavita krishnamurthy, bhappi lahiri and ismail darbar as judges . Amazing show with amazing songs and singers and zero dramatics.The judges only decided the winner and it was the correct judgement.By the way the host was Aabhaas.
But such shows are ignored because they do not raise crores of rupees for the channel and producers.What a shame!!!!🤢



Somewhat true.. Yes judges make right decisions (not current singers/MDs but old ones.. hehe)!! BUT sir those became great singers composers because they got break and they were talented too.. Success in this industry depends on breaks which 'godfathers' can give may be to the right persons.. There were/are still many skillful/talented singers who are btter than reigning singers in bollywood BUT they are not given breaks because they don;t have godfathers.. Vineet however cudnt make use of Himesh who gave him so many songs in movies as a godfather.. BTW singers in this show sing in bollywood butmay be not in mainstream as there its all Shaan and Sonu Nigam.. Success don't come in one jump.. one has to struggle a bit to get it if he/she doesn't have a Godfather.. 😲
susm8 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: ashraynaik

I am not an NRI. And let me tell you that many NRI's are very patriotic so please do not make derogatory comments against them.
Secondly please make a note of all Indian idol and voice of India winners and tell me how many of them have really , I mean really become stars...?Why is this happening?
This is because the winners are decided by audience polls .Most of the audience do not really understand music and give votes based on looks, personality, regionalism,item numbers , dramatics, family backgrounds etc.As a result the mediocre singers with all these above mentioned attributes win.



Abhijeet Sawant is a very successful Pop singer and quite a few songs in Hindi movies, Raja is a regular Playback singer now, Debo is amazing in Asamese/Bengali movies Playback and quite a few (not mainstream though) hindi songs in movies, Anwesa a regular playback singer in Bengali movies, Vineet sings for Himesh only though, Aish a regular child artist in gujrat and like these u have a lot of these reality show singers.. It will take time for these singers to replace current playback singers.. may be in next few years time.. Same way Shaan, Sonu replaced Udit Narayan and Kumar Sanu... Cheers!! nothing personal..😃
susm8 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: rahulfan94

I want Rahul to be winner. So I want Shankar's team to win. I want Shankar v/s Himesh in finals. I don't want Shankar v/s Shaan because Shaan's team has all good singers and Shankar team will be in danger of losing. Shankar's team has two best singers Rahul and Shankar and Himesh's team has two good singers Vineet and Aishwarya. So Shankar's team will be the winner.

Jay Ho Shankar Bhagwaan!



Honest and a fan.. best of luck..!! 😉
safeenafarheen thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: rahulfan94

I want Rahul to be winner. So I want Shankar team to win. I want Shankar v/s Himesh final. I not want Shankar v/s Shaan because Shaan team has all good singer and Shankar team danger in being lost. Shankar team have two best singer Rahul and Shankar and Himesh team have two good singer Vineet and Aishwarya. So Shankar team will be won.

Jay Ho Shankar Bhagwaan!



🤣🤣🤣..God Bless u Rahul fan!!

Vijay Vyas thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: susm8


Abhijeet Sawant is a very successful Pop singer and quite a few songs in Hindi movies, Raja is a regular Playback singer now, Debo is amazing in Asamese/Bengali movies Playback and quite a few (not mainstream though) hindi songs in movies, Anwesa a regular playback singer in Bengali movies, Vineet sings for Himesh only though, Aish a regular child artist in gujrat and like these u have a lot of these reality show singers.. It will take time for these singers to replace current playback singers.. may be in next few years time.. Same way Shaan, Sonu replaced Udit Narayan and Kumar Sanu... Cheers!! nothing personal..😃

Raja ke liyen aapne sahi likha. Hum Raja fans ko ab reality shows ki performances ke saath bahut saare naye gaane bhi sun ne ko milte hai. 2 saal main 25 gaane release ho chuke hai Raja ke aur usne dher saare songs recording kiyen for all MDs woh bhi aa jayenge dhiren dhiren.
rahulfan94 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: Vijay Vyas

Raja ke liyen aapne sahi likha. Hum Raja fans ko ab reality shows ki performances ke saath bahut saare naye gaane bhi sun ne ko milte hai. 2 saal main 25 gaane release ho chuke hai Raja ke aur usne dher saare songs recording kiyen for all MDs woh bhi aa jayenge dhiren dhiren.

Himesh bhi regular playback singer hai. Aur woh bhi naak se gaate hai😆😆
susm8 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: rahulfan94

Himesh bhi regular playback singer hai. Aur woh bhi naak se gaate hai😆😆



Bhai everyone has his own style😛.. Cmon.. You can't compare singers with different styles.. They rule in their own styles.. Raja is getting more songs and exposure because his style suits the sufi/classical fusion which is currently in trend😊.. and others are not getting so many songs because their styles are not in trend and very few hit songs are there in recent past in romantic and melody numbers or pure indian classical😭.. And again no particular style of singing is better or worse than the other😉.. So even if there are so many talented / skillful singers they are not singing playback in large😭..

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".