Enough with the Hate on the Captains - Page 5

Originally posted by: purva

I don't get it... just because the captains are established singers they can never be wrong? Why can't people have opinions about the judges? Are they not human? And no human is perfect.. there is bound to be a mistake somewhere. If some people felt that the judges made a mistake and were being partial.. why can't they express it on a public forum?

The topic starter is saying Amey is not a good singer... so that should be called as bashing too... right? I don't have a problem with that because I don't consider it bashing.. it's criticism just like "Shaan is being partial" is.. so it should be ok.. no?

I'm just saying it's very very probable they are right. It's highly unlikely they are all wrong and having a conspiracy. Maybe 1 or 2 might be up to something, but all together? No. The contestant is just is performing bad and thats why he gets low marks.

Originally posted by: ssk13809

I'm just saying it's very very probable they are right. It's highly unlikely they are all wrong and having a conspiracy. Maybe 1 or 2 might be up to something, but all together? No. The contestant is just is performing bad and thats why he gets low marks.

Again.. who is speaking about ALL the captains here? We too are talking about those 1 or 2. When they are constantly giving low marks to a certain team then someone needs to speak up. And I think you too will agree that 1 or 2 points make a lot of difference in MKMM.

Anyway.. it will be better that we stop here because we are going around in circles. You believe that the contestant is performing bad hence low points... I believe that the contestant is performing good still getting low points.. now when our basic beliefs are so totally opposite then there is no point in further discussion.

But please don't stop people from expressing their opinion because this is a public forum after all so you stick to your opinion and let people have their opinion 😊

Originally posted by: purva

Again.. who is speaking about ALL the captains here? We too are talking about those 1 or 2. When they are constantly giving low marks to a certain team then someone needs to speak up. And I think you too will agree that 1 or 2 points make a lot of difference in MKMM.

Anyway.. it will be better that we stop here because we are going around in circles. You believe that the contestant is performing bad hence low points... I believe that the contestant is performing good still getting low points.. now when our basic beliefs are so totally opposite then there is no point in further discussion.

But please don't stop people from expressing their opinion because this is a public forum after all so you stick to your opinion and let people have their opinion 😊

And again, ALL the captains were blamed by Ameya not 1 or 2 in particular. And he was getting lower than deserved marks from all of them according to him. And he said ALL of them made a mistake in giving 10s.

But you haven't watched that episode.

But the point is, its not 1 or 2 that are being blamed here. Its ALL of them. So there is no reason to single out any of them. I think last episode I saw Himesh gave more points to Ameya than anyone else .Could be wrong.

But ALL of them were being insulted by Ameya.

Originally posted by: ssk13809

And again, ALL the captains were blamed by Ameya not 1 or 2 in particular. And he was getting lower than deserved marks from all of them according to him. And he said ALL of them made a mistake in giving 10s.

But you haven't watched that episode.

But the point is, its not 1 or 2 that are being blamed here. Its ALL of them. So there is no reason to single out any of them. I think last episode I saw Himesh gave more points to Ameya than anyone else .Could be wrong.

But ALL of them were being insulted by Ameya.

Originally posted by: purva

No.. I caught up with the show after seeing all the commotion here on the forum. 😆

So now I can talk about it... don't know which show you watched.. because from what I saw, Amey didn't have problem with Sharib's 10 points.. he was asking why some other performances didn't get 10 points earlier.. there is a difference mate. Also I never heard the word ALL captains in Amey's speech.. he did not take any names but that does not mean ALL by default. And even if he meant ALL of them... it's his opinion. I am not speaking for Amey here.. I am speaking for myself because the topic is addressed to the members here and not Amey. And I have said it again and again that I don't blame all the mentors. You are mixing Amey's opinion with his fans opinion which are two different things. How can I be answerable to what Amey did on the show. 😕

Well he said that he thought other performances deserved a 10 also since Sharib's got a 10, thus he was wondering why ALL the judges didn't give earlier performances a 10 thus blaming them. He basically said if you give this performance a 10, why not the earlier ones Blaming all the captains on that.

Also, the fans support Amey's actions. Which is where I was saying is just not right. You might not blame all of them, he did, he was wrong, so no one should support their actions (well if you are reasonable).


And I'm not sure why you don't blame all the mentors. Because really I've seen Himesh give the highest score to Ameya at times. Other times lowest. Why only remembering the low ones and blaming him? (Assuming you blame Himesh)

Originally posted by: ssk13809

Well he said that he thought other performances deserved a 10 also since Sharib's got a 10, thus he was wondering why ALL the judges didn't give earlier performances a 10 thus blaming them. He basically said if you give this performance a 10, why not the earlier ones Blaming all the captains on that.

Also, the fans support Amey's actions. Which is where I was saying is just not right. You might not blame all of them, he did, he was wrong, so no one should support their actions (well if you are reasonable).


And I'm not sure why you don't blame all the mentors. Because really I've seen Himesh give the highest score to Ameya at times. Other times lowest. Why only remembering the low ones and blaming him? (Assuming you blame Himesh)

Originally posted by: purva

I support Amey's action because I don't think he was talking about all the captains there.. I never heard the words ALL which you are assuming Amey meant.. to me it was mainly about Himesh.. so I agree with Amey.. if you are assuming Amey meant ALL then I can't help it 😊

And yes.. I do blame Himesh. Because he did give low points to many good performances(not just Amey's) according to me. I also blame Shaan but not on the basis of points. I don't like the way he tried to pull other team down in order to put his team on top. And Mika.. I better not talk about him. According to me he is the least knowledgable judge... 😊

Also you didn't tell me why members should stop voicing their opinion about the captains on a free forum like IF?

Um did you not read what I typed?

Ameya said he felt that since Sharid received a 10 from everyone, earlier performances also should have received a 10 from everyone. Thus, he is blaming ALL the captains for either giving 10s to Sharid, or not giving 10s to earlier performances.

I don't know how you look past that and say he is only blaming Himesh. He is talking about the 10s Sharid received from EVERYBODY and saying other performances also should have received 10s from EVERYBODY

Originally posted by: ssk13809

Um did you not read what I typed?

Ameya said he felt that since Sharid received a 10 from everyone, earlier performances also should have received a 10 from everyone. Thus, he is blaming ALL the captains for either giving 10s to Sharid, or not giving 10s to earlier performances.

I don't know how you look past that and say he is only blaming Himesh. He is talking about the 10s Sharid received from EVERYBODY and saying other performances also should have received 10s from EVERYBODY

Originally posted by: purva

@bold.. That's what I am saying.. it's what YOU TYPED.. did not hear that in Amey's speech 😊

I say that he is blaming Himesh because Himesh was the only one who gave him 7 for the earlier performance and not others.

And you didn't answer my question so I am going to assume that you are ok with people voicing their opinion about captains. So there is no need for me to debate this any further 😃

You need to watch it again. Even though you yourself said that he said other earlier performances deserved 10s also, and thus he is blaming all the captains on that one.


Oh but wait quickly forget that. You didn't hear anything. 🤔

Originally posted by: ssk13809

You need to watch it again. Even though you yourself said that he said other earlier performances deserved 10s also, and thus he is blaming all the captains on that one.


Oh but wait quickly forget that. You didn't hear anything. 🤔