Enough with the Hate on the Captains - Page 4

Originally posted by: tinaasania

what status? LOL.....as if I care about PR agency n media created hype...some of these captains declare flops as hits....
some of them have no scruples or ethics....i've seen their judging on other and this reality show....

Respect has to be earned, not demanded.

U may have diff. criteria for looking upto ppl, I have diff. So pls do not tell others what to think.

We have our own values n brains. We live in a democracy. This is a democratic forum.

Ameya is a terrific singer and he is being under-rated so I will question judges ability n ethics also. They are being paid to do a good job.
I will question Star Plus channel n makers of MKMM also.

I like Mohit Chauhan's voice and I respect him bcoz he is not indulging in cheap, fake drama or politics.

well said 👏 agree totally 😊
singers in MKMM r not kids or newbies .....some of them r already pros.....sum judges hv egos n they want every1 2 s*** up 2 them. 🤢

Originally posted by: ssk13809

Coming into this show, I saw the captain lineup, and was very impressed. We had 4 legends in the music industry, Himesh, Shankar, Shreya, and Shaan. We had a rising star in Mohit. And we had, not that great, but stil solid, Mika.


Back to the point, I'm tired of everyone supporting these contestants and taking shots at the captains. Especially Himesh, but others too. Questioning the credibility and knowledge of these captians in music, and thinking people like Ameya are speaking the truth. 😕

That's ridiculous. First of all, Ameya is a joke. If anyone honestly thinks the judges all have some agenda against him, they are crazy. People are saying things like the "judges are biased and do this and that". Well, those people are too much into their "favorite" contestant. The truth is, that none of these contestants compare in their music knowledge to that of Himesh and Shankar, who are music directors as well as singers. These 2 have dominated the music industry at times. Himesh at one point used ot have all hte Top Music Album Hits. Shankar we all know has put out legendary music album hjts along with Esaan and Loy. Shaan and Shreya are also very knowledgable about singing. They are arguably the best male and female singers we have in bollywood. Countless amount of hit songs they have sung.Though I won't say they have the overall knowledge of Shankar and Himesh because those 2 also direct music.

None of these contestants compare to the singin Himesh, Mohit, Shreya, Shaan, and Shankar. Maybe Mohit isn't as good as the other 4.. But Himesh, Shaan, Shreya, and Shankar have won countless playback singer of the year, national awards, and have gotten overall tons of recognition for their singing. Who are these contestants to say what they think about their judgement.

No ones. They don't compare from a singing standpoint, nor they do they compare from a music standpoint. Ameya is just a immature baby who can't take bad remarks, and is really nobody compared to the captians (aside from Mika maybe).




So really all I have to say is, people need to start showing respect for the captians.

kya bakwas hai! isko kehte hain slave mentality. hamesha jhuke raho, jhuk ke baat karo, pair chuke salaam karo... kaheka legends? himesh jaisa log hazaaron aaye aur gaye. most these people dont want new talent to come up. himesh kya gaata hai? naak se gaana bh gaan hai? yeh sab "legends" nahin, adharmi log hain. they take crores and crores of rupees and spoil the lifes of young kids. shaan aur shreya ka bhalayi shankar aur himesh ke saath rehne mein hai. shaan aur shreya ko chance mila dats why they got songs to there credit. if ameya or ravi or aneek or raja or any contestant get a chance they can do better than shaan or shreya. sab kismat hai bhaiyya. naseeb ki baat hoti hai. himesh ka career kab ka khatam hua. aur shankar bhi aaj kal kuch nahi kar pa raha hai. jaake dekh lo. baat karte hain!

kya bakwas hai! isko kehte hain slave mentality. hamesha jhuke raho, jhuk ke baat karo, pair chuke salaam karo... kaheka legends? himesh jaisa log hazaaron aaye aur gaye. most these people dont want new talent to come up. himesh kya gaata hai? naak se gaana bh gaan hai? yeh sab "legends" nahin, adharmi log hain. they take crores and crores of rupees and spoil the lifes of young kids. shaan aur shreya ka bhalayi shankar aur himesh ke saath rehne mein hai. shaan aur shreya ko chance mila dats why they got songs to there credit. if ameya or ravi or aneek or raja or any contestant get a chance they can do better than shaan or shreya. sab kismat hai bhaiyya. naseeb ki baat hoti hai. himesh ka career kab ka khatam hua. aur shankar bhi aaj kal kuch nahi kar pa raha hai. jaake dekh lo. baat karte hain!

🤣

Was this a joke? Did this guy just say that if Ameya, Ravi, or Aneek, or Raja, got a chance to sing, they can do better than Shaan and Shreya? Did this guy say Himesh can't sing? Did this guy say Shanker is able to do nothing these days.

That is all funny. These 4 are award-winning singers, beating the whole country through their singing. Beating every other singer in the industry and receiving national and bollywood playback singer of the year awards. All of them have already left a mark in the history of indian singing that can't be erased.


The fact that you think Ravi, Aneek, Ameya, or Raja can sing better than Shaan or Shreya when given a chance takes out all credibility from you. You don't know what singing is. Too blinded by your "favorite" contestant living their small dream. You like the contestants will be awaken that they are nowhere near the level of these legend judges.

As the topis starter has said, all the judges are so well established and accomplished, then when all the judges gave Ameya a 9, why did the so called gyaani himesh gave a 7? an 8 wud still be acceptable but a 7? So either Himmy is all the know all end all of music and other judges don't know anything or (I won't say Himmy doesn't understand music) Himmy is just trying to get Mohit out for some personal reasons...Ameya, a good singer is getting squished in between his dirty politics...

Originally posted by: desicrowd

As the topis starter has said, all the judges are so well established and accomplished, then when all the judges gave Ameya a 9, why did the so called gyaani himesh gave a 7? an 8 wud still be acceptable but a 7? So either Himmy is all the know all end all of music and other judges don't know anything or (I won't say Himmy doesn't understand music) Himmy is just trying to get Mohit out for some personal reasons...Ameya, a good singer is getting squished in between his dirty politics...

It's just 1 performance that there was a 2 point difference. I remember when Aneek once performed, all the judges gave him a 9, but Shaan gave him a 7. So whats your point? Now Shaan is all the know all end all of music and the other judges don't know anything? Or does Shaan have something personal with Shreya. 😆

See my point. That its just 1 performance where he differed. Shaan has done the same. I've seen other times when all judges gave like a 7 and one of them gives a 9 or something too. But you can't blame Himesh for just 1 performance for nothing.


And to get in depth, many times in 1 performance, the judge could have had other things things in his mind, not concentrating on the singing, and just giving a 7. It's a reasonable explanation that their mind wandered off somewhere just ONE performance. And thus they gave a different score. But it's nothing to base an opinion of the judge on.

Originally posted by: ssk13809

It's just 1 performance that there was a 2 point difference. I remember when Aneek once performed, all the judges gave him a 9, but Shaan gave him a 7. So whats your point? Now Shaan is all the know all end all of music and the other judges don't know anything? Or does Shaan have something personal with Shreya. 😆

See my point. That its just 1 performance where he differed. Shaan has done the same. I've seen other times when all judges gave like a 7 and one of them gives a 9 or something too. But you can't blame Himesh for just 1 performance for nothing.


And to get in depth, many times in 1 performance, the judge could have had other things things in his mind, not concentrating on the singing, and just giving a 7. It's a reasonable explanation that their mind wandered off somewhere just ONE performance. And thus they gave a different score. But it's nothing to base an opinion of the judge on.

Its not a matter of one performance but a culmination of various performances which deserved more than what himesh has given....I don't say Shaan is a saint...even Shreya for that matter gives low marks...but thats the point here, this is unfair to a good singer. Just cos his captain doesn't speak up and doesn't shake his butt to impress the crowd doesn't mean his singers are bad....Its not that Ameya is a bad singer, cos he has proved his caliber in other shows...but somehow he doesn't do the Chaaplusi which Rahul does, hence loses out....The judges should not forget that this is a singing competition and not an Orchestra type performance...

i think every judge sees the performance in their own way and they are free to give whtever marks they give and contestants have to accept it. There is no point of arguing with judges, yes you can request them.

I like the was Anwesha or members of Shaan's team accpeted all low marks and move on to next performance. All should learn from them to be humble. No one here is a master and this is just an opportunity to learn from mistakes.

God bless all

Why insult someone who are recognized in the Industry ... that way ppl will never ever respect anyone .... why respect Himesh kyu ki woh nak se gaate hein ????? what a comment .... it's public who made his albums hit ... and he became a popular ....

Originally posted by: desicrowd

Its not a matter of one performance but a culmination of various performances which deserved more than what himesh has given....I don't say Shaan is a saint...even Shreya for that matter gives low marks...but thats the point here, this is unfair to a good singer. Just cos his captain doesn't speak up and doesn't shake his butt to impress the crowd doesn't mean his singers are bad....Its not that Ameya is a bad singer, cos he has proved his caliber in other shows...but somehow he doesn't do the Chaaplusi which Rahul does, hence loses out....The judges should not forget that this is a singing competition and not an Orchestra type performance...

Really because I think Himesh has been partial all throughout and at times is giving more points than anybody. He's just like any other judge actually if you watch unbiasedly when giving marks. When he gives a low score it just gets noticed more, the host always also picks on Himesh and asks him questions on his marks. Making it look worse. But Himesh is no different than the other judges in judging is my point.

And as far as they all go in giving Ameya low marks, I think he deserves them. I don't feel his singing is that good. I agree with what the Judges think. The judges know it's a singing competition and give it based on singing. The audience sometimes doesn't, but the judges can differentiate. Maybe not Mika, but the others are good. You think Shreya pays attention and gives higher scores when people are being loud? No. Same with Shaan who is all about honesty. If all the judges give you a low score, you deserve it.

I don't get it... just because the captains are established singers they can never be wrong? Why can't people have opinions about the judges? Are they not human? And no human is perfect.. there is bound to be a mistake somewhere. If some people felt that the judges made a mistake and were being partial.. why can't they express it on a public forum?

The topic starter is saying Amey is not a good singer... so that should be called as bashing too... right? I don't have a problem with that because I don't consider it bashing.. it's criticism just like "Shaan is being partial" is.. so it should be ok.. no?