::Nupur's behaviour : Is that really justified??:: - Page 19

Created

Last reply

Replies

352

Views

21.7k

Users

62

Likes

865

Frequent Posters

EtherealRati thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 15 years ago
By god pari.........it was so awesome to see a topic from u on this...........please continue making topics on others too.........or i should say do continue making other than mohit topics.........😆
yaar i am so happy to see a topic where both sg and mn fans took part enthusiastically .......without fights......waise i dont read whole topic........but till i read........i dint find fights........atlast a healthy discussion ........... i loved the pics................yup sam looking nice in the outfit in precap...............
ok let me come to the topic now..................
i completely respect your pov................but i disagree to some extent.............dear u are right my angel is a fighter............yup she is..........she proved that many a times............but think of a situation dhruv attacked someone. or killed someone ...........he had been in jail even.........and nups whole family was scared of him and thus send the girls to mumbai as said in the article ...........now thinking of a person who have killed someone already makes a normal human being scare for sure........may be the person is a fighter but than too its natural that the person will be scared of a person like that.........and we never know ...........may be dhruv killed someone because he touched nupur or said something to nupur only........that would have developed a scare for dhruv in nups heart from morena only...........she never thought of meeting him again in her whole life...............
and one day she opens her eyes and saw she is alone..........no one from her family is with her..........and a murderer or a mad obessed lover is sitting in front of her............u tell me she has just open her ees........can she show braveness there.........no ofcourse not.......moreover it was dhruv only who saved her life........and i would definately say........nups do care for that......she is thankful to dhruv for saving her life...........may be dhruv and nupur were friends before dhruv fall madly in love with nupur which nupur never imagined...............but she was scared at the same time.........as nups love her family..........she must be asking where is mayank..........where is sajan.........and dhruv shouted.........because atleast he hate all the threre except nupsi............he wanted to get nupsi at any cost..........may be dhruv was the only one who put the mangalsutra and chunri.......and exchange the bodies..........we never knew...........imagine a situation where u are sitting in front of a mad lover who did tried or did killed someone and he tells u that you are dead for your family..........and if u did try to return..............your family will be dead..........will u not be scared.........i will die at the situation........its damn scary for me..........
yup............if it has been any simple person telling u that u will stay with me.............u will definately not listen..........but it was dhruv,..........whom she was already scared of..........who have killed a person.....who was the saver of gher life...........and he was giving nupur open warning that he will kill all the three if she did return..........
ok now the trusting thing comes............that she could have trusted mayu and sam.............that they will fight with dhruv........but tell me would dhruv have let her escape then...............may be she was under observation only for three years..........may be she tried to escaped.........and dhruv beat her..........may be that was the reason of not escaping.......may be any other reason...........after winning dhruv's confidence.....and getting well......atlast she reached mumbai to see that how is her family is.........and dhruv keep on threatning her...........
imagine a guy who love someone to the extent that have went in jail just because someone talked to his love rudely , touched her.................did tried himself to beat his love with the belt...........what can be pathetic than this............would have done what to mayank and gunjan who can take his love nupur away from him..............and aftyer knowing all this truth now........what will mayank do for dhruv.........nupsi is selfless ...she did care for dhruv after all this even..........
and moreover even mayank and sam could have faced dhruv..........what about pari and the most important for nupsi is pari only..........may be dhruv was threatning her of attacking pari only.........because i think he met mayank and sam now only...........
ok i am hell confused but i do found nups behaviour justified...................and i am liking the track........and i know its full of bloopers.........but none of the track in mjht is without bloopers...........😆
sorry pari for making you feel bore with such a long comment................
jhappis..................🤗🤗🤗.🤗🤗
love
sur
Edited by Surbhi123 - 15 years ago
sheebs_ratifan thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
surbhi di aapka comment padhke thoda achcha feel horaha hai
SunshineGirl6 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 15 years ago
Paruuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu...............🤗🤗🤗..............awssmm topic sweets.........waise b4 thinking all thz u shud hve thought that this is "mjht".........bloopers are common here.......😆.........i guess uptil nw they hve ruined all the characters of the show to some extent and mostly of Mayank's........🤔..........nd abt nupz behaviour i know that is not justified but one reason for her to behave like this is that she loves her sister friend and husband way too much........and as we all can see that dhruv is a physcic maniac.......😳.........why wont she b afraid for her friends nd family???......but still they shud hve shown it in a better way........😛
EkPaheli thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 15 years ago
😲 a post by pari and one which is quite popular well will love to add to this later so would be back in a few

atm what bugs me the most is how come dhruv was ready to send nupur to mumbai all alone if he was so possessive and obsessed with her ? dint he know her family and friends in mumbai could see her ?


and in all the movies about a possessive lover or an obsessed psycho even if he is the husband - the woman tries to run away at least once - why did nupur never try this even once ? 😕
piya2025 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 365 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 15 years ago
@ Nidz- yeah i can see..
@ Preeti di-Got ur pm & checked it..
From PF 4-7 i was der..& I didn't really were on Topic..Im always off topic when it comes to MJHT dis days Phew..
anyways,i actually feel..der is simply NO point of bashing an actress Be it Sanaya or Rati or d actors Mohit / Arjun..
Its kinda simple thing which each & every1 need to understand its not d actress or actor who write d storyline but d CV"s or d writers.. I've less things to say abt MN track.. Im not being harsh but its a truth i dont follow MJHT like i use to do b4..i just watch what i like..So NO comments abt how,why,what going on in d show..
Pari started dis topic 4a healthy discussion..I've read her post completly dat her intension wasn't mocking @Rati at all..it was simple..Some lines here n der & some comments make things a bit un-manageable..
But yes..what i noticed i wanna say day,I wish ppl over here were stick to d Topic..(Me too though lolz)rather dan bringing those charecter who r not related to dis topic + if any of d member were feeling some1 mocking @ Rati here,dey could have easily say to d person to stick on d topic rather dan mocking @ other actors in d show..

If i say Dont bash,dat wont help i know coz some just cant change :O


-Preeti- thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 15 years ago
Hinu
Waah waah
Thats a nyc answer ....BLOOPERS😆😆😆😆😆😆


Originally posted by: aahana86


atm what bugs me the most is how come dhruv was ready to send nupur to mumbai all alone if he was so possessive and obsessed with her ? dint he know her family and friends in mumbai could see her ?


and in all the movies about a possessive lover or an obsessed psycho even if he is the husband - the woman tries to run away at least once - why did nupur never try this even once ? 😕



Aahana
Could you please Mail this to that MJHT ID .... i mean it ...CV's need to know this ... MJHT ke Future ke liye ....😆
Forget about coming to Mumbai alone .... think this that she stays with the Gang for 3-4 days and this fellow comes behind her after a Week ..... how would Cv's justify that?🤔
DiyaS thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: -Preeti-



Diya

After going through ur Long Post .....i feel i am not the only one banging my head over this Show and trying to fix things between the characters and story

All that you pointed out there were some of the facts that Me, Senny and Divya already assumed it to be in our last few Posts
Except for that Trauma Centre waala part we had predicted these things keeping in mind both the tracks into considerations > Amnesia and Another Man in her life.

And there we justified each characters actions towards the tracks ... as that what they did was justified somewhere of the other.

This Topic had objections on Nupur behaving scared and Weak, which was the Discussion and many raised many questions against her this behavior.



To add to my Previous Post i would also add another Point here.


May be people forgot that Dhruv is supposed to be Nupur's Childhood friend and as we saw in day before y''day's Epi ... that she does care for him as a friend. Though he hits her torture's hear to Death but when she saw him bleeding she went to help him. This also gives out the reason for her to be going through all that Pain. If she fights back here she has to fight back to her friend who's turned an enemy to her Family and her husband. And fighting with a friend is much more difficult than fighting a Stranger.



okay, I don't read too many MN threads ... almost none, in fact 😆 so I don't know what you guys have been discussing ... my original question was not really about her being weak or scared ... it was about one huge doubt which STILL hasn't been resolved to my satisfaction ... when Nupur found herself ALONE with Mayank, WHY did she not at least try to give him some hints ... rather than keep chasing him away? Especially once she realised that he was very much pining for her ... like I said her choice is between his safety and what she feels would be his happiness .. but he's not happy without her ...
(actually my original question was about Nups trying to get SG together and why she waited 3 years, but I answered that myself, as I didn't get a single sensible reply to that one, only outrage over how I could question Nups' perfection as a sister 😉

As for Dhruv being Nups childhood friend, agree to that all right, and that's why I liked the touch they added of her concern when he got hurt ... but if he's beating her up on a regular basis, she should realise that he needs help ... does she know that he went to rehab? or has that not yet come up in the show and is confined to TB? As is the reason for them shifting to Mumbai being Dhruv in the first place ...
As for helping Dhruv, by submitting to his beatings she is not helping him ... quite the contrary ... helping him would be by taking the first opportunity she could to get him help ... again I come back to ... WHY didn't she confide in mayank when she had the chance? He's not hot headed, he's cool, calm and sensible and he would try to figure out a smart way to get her out of the mess ... not just rush in with dishum dishum ... as how they showed ... i finally managed to watch it 😉

As for her being weak and scared, well, that part i do understand, especially if she's been with a guy like that for three years and he's belted her regularly ... but AGAIN ... sorry, I sound like a broken record here ... why not tell Mayank when she had the chance???!!!! Before Dhruv ever reached Mumbai?
Sorry, CV's have left tones of loopholes big enough to drive trucks through ... I could rewrite this story to cover many ... but can't manage to cover them all 😆
sheebs_ratifan thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
ahhhhh!!koi bhi kuch bhi bolle galti cv ki haiiiiiiiiiiiiii🤣cv pls nupur ka character ko aisa mat kijiyee dekhiyee yaha kitne ppl fight karahe hai u pay for it cv🤣god please do something please...
sheebs_ratifan thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago

🥱

Edited by sheebs_ratifan - 15 years ago
DiyaS thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: aahana86

😲 a post by pari and one which is quite popular well will love to add to this later so would be back in a few

atm what bugs me the most is how come dhruv was ready to send nupur to mumbai all alone if he was so possessive and obsessed with her ? dint he know her family and friends in mumbai could see her ?


and in all the movies about a possessive lover or an obsessed psycho even if he is the husband - the woman tries to run away at least once - why did nupur never try this even once ? 😕



@bold ... my point exactly ... and when she HAD the chance, when sha managed to come to Mumbai alone without Dhruv, why has she not taken it???

For your first question .. read my thesis a few pages back ... I did try to find a reason for that 😆 if you have the patience to go through it! 😆
Edited by DiyaS - 15 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".