Okay ... after beating my head over all these posts ... and ignoring most of them 😉 ... but mainly from ishita's and preeti's POV's 😉 ... here's what I could come up with ... please pick holes because I can still find lots of loopholes in this track ... am only going for Nups side, because we know what happened to MSG ...
Dhruv the demon psycho released from rehab comes in search of the love of his life only to find her happily married and ready to leave for her extended honeymoon to the US. So he rigs the car - presto, accident happens, and he's on the scene to rescue Nups and carry her off.
Initially he feeds her lies about the other three dying (maybe) or otherwise keeps her busy and Nups is so badly hurt that she takes a while to recover anyway. Plus as there is no threat to his love (or so he thinks) he shows her only his sweet side ... and as I said in another post, perpetrators of domestic violence DO have a sweet side, they are alternately loving and violent, and psychotic lovers even more so, becos they're mentally unbalanced and are genuinely remorseful everytime they hurt their lover. So Nups is devastated, she thinks the other three are dead so she stays with Dhruv to recover ...
I know, i know ... what about bauji, Bui et al ... well, if Gunji has forgotten all about them, so apparently has Nups ... so I can ignore them too.
Then, or alternatively, she comes to know the other three are alive, but Dhruv tells her more lies, that SG are happy, Mayank has moved on, so let them be ... maybe shows her his violent side again or more so now if she shows signs of wanting to return ... so she starts getting more scared ... now this part is because in the initial phone calls, Nups did NOT sound petrified of Dhruv ... she spoke very normally to him, so I'm guessing the worst violence has come now when Dhruv has actually seen M with his own eyes and seen the MN love ...
and also it explains to some extent what has been puzzling me since the start of this track ... why Nups didn't contact anyone ... because she thought there was no one left, and because Dhruv showed her only his good side for a long time ...
although there's a loophole in this, another option i thought was that Dhruv has warned her that HE had caused the accident and if she wants M's safety, she should stay away from him ... but she might have been more scared of Dhruv in the phone calls if that were the case ... so ... confusion here ...
Again, am ignoring the trauma center, becos I'm confused - did Dhruv rescue her from the trauma center or directly from accident site - those who've been following this track more carefully would have an answer ... or again, they might not, cos CV's were pretty confused at that point themselves ...
Then, Nups comes to Mumbai ... either to see for herself that Mayank and Gunjan are all right, and Dhruv lets her becos he's confident that she cares for him enough ... which might have been the case otherwise a guy like him would not have let her out of his sight ... or she acts loving enough to give him that confidence ... she was always a good actress ... which again might explain the normalcy of the phone calls ...
Mayank's accident - Nups is there becos she was looking out for him, takes him to hospital, sees SG rushing in, taking care of M, thinks that what Dhruv said is true, they're all happy without her, they've moved on and if she doesn't want to endanger their lives, she shd stay away from them ... hence the cold behaviour at the bus stop ...
So at this point - Nups was here only to reassure herself that MSG were all okay, after seeing them at the hospital all together, she thought they were okay and doing fine without her, and with Dhruv's threats about mayank, she decided for his safety to stay away ...
But at the bus stop Sam talks about "he WAS Gunjan's fiance" ... not is ... and for the first time, she realises that everything is not okay, especially for her little sister, whom she thought was fine, happily married and safe ...
so she comes back ... to see what exactly is happening on that front, becos although SG are not married, they're not enemies either, they seem to be together ... she needs to figure out what happened to them ... and why ...
and the play acting and fighting in the college track is for one reason ... to make mayank hate her, forget her ... because she realises he also hasnt .. in short, she slowly realises that Dhruv has been feeding her a pack of lies, but his threats are still very much there ...
And she finds out why SG are not together - it's because of her presumed death ... so now she's majorly upset - one consolation she had was that at least her sister is safe and happy, but even that is not the case ... she has to try and get them back together somehow ... the other consolation was of course mayank's safety ... now her choice is his safety or his happiness ... tough choice to make ...
okay, am too tired to think of more 😆 ... I know there are still lots and lots of loopholes but that's the best I can do right now ... have tons of other things I need to do ...
And I still don't have a good explanation for why she doesnt tell them everything once she has found out the true state of affairs ... and i think the reason she will tell Sam is actually most logical among all these illogical happenings ... to ask him to look after Gunjan, because Mayank can look after himself plus she can hope he will move on ... and she has realised that Gunjan won't ... and that of course will spill the beans ...
now i need to actually watch yesterday's episode 😆 or at least the precap 😆
Edited by DiyaS - 14 years ago
Cricket
Kyunki Saas Bhi Kabhi Bahu Thi 2
Current Affairs
Anupamaa
