Nupur's Condition-New Theory-My Take - Page 2

I hope something sensible like this is shown with proper execution and a strong emotional story for MN. It certainly looks much more promising than any of the other tracks.

Thanks for sharing!

Originally posted by: Senny

I hope something sensible like this is shown with proper execution and a strong emotional story for MN. It certainly looks much more promising than any of the other tracks.

Thanks for sharing!

Senny,

You, me and all us MNians wish for something different and you are right, it looks much more promising...

imagine: the new Nupur (who has the same, yet different qualities from the old Nupur) falling in love with Mayank but in a different style. So far, I am loving her style...especially her excessive usage of English and "By God" and then the whole annoyance...that gives Mayank more ideas of how to convince her and make her fall in love with him. Not to mention the whole Dance teacher personality...imagine her giving lessons to Mayank, instead of Mayank giving her lessons. this Nupur looks more intelligent. I loved the old Nupur but this Nupur shows more strong character. Idk but i see a new story unfolding...

then the whole dramatic raaz that will unfold later, which adds more to the story. If this track is shown, then I can see our Mayank trying to help Nupur in bringing her back and I can see Gunjan and Nupur bonding differently. As for Nupur and Samrat...a new bond of friendship...

But alas...the CVs only know how to begin something and not execute it.

rooj

PS: you're welcome 😊

although I like your argument in favor of DID, I think its highly unlikely that the CVs would decide to go that way in this track.......because DID is a very complicated disorder and even the doctors dont know the exact signs, symptoms or even cause of this disorder....and truth to tell some dont even think its a real disorder....but even if you ignore all that, DID according to some research needs a very strong cause for it to happen....I mean it has to be something so bad that you create a whole new personality for yourself to shut out your other persona......so if they show Nupur having it just because of an accident then it would be over doing it.....

Originally posted by: gina87

<font face="Comic Sans MS, Times, serif">although I like your argument in favor of DID, I think its highly unlikely that the CVs would decide to go that way in this track.......because DID is a very complicated disorder and even the doctors dont know the exact signs, symptoms or even cause of this disorder....and truth to tell some dont even think its a real disorder....but even if you ignore all that, DID according to some research needs a very strong cause for it to happen....I mean it has to be something so bad that you create a whole new personality for yourself to shut out your other persona......so if they show Nupur having it just because of an accident then it would be over doing it.....</font>

</div>
<div>

<font face="Comic Sans MS, Times, serif">another thing is if they want to show a happy ending to this track in any way then DID is not the way to go because how exactly are they going to treat something like that?.....I mean realistically speaking even amnesia is hard to recover from but still more more believable in a showbut DID is almost a lost cause.....</font>

<font face="Comic Sans MS, Times, serif">actually after the way this track is shaping up for Nupur, now I am very curious as to how they are going to redeem this storyline....because at this point all I can say is thatthey digging their own grave 😆</font>

You seem like a psych major...

Anyways what you have described is true but don't forget a small chot can cause DID too if a person's mental level is weak...Also even though it is clinically proven because it is hard to prove, but there are rare cases where DID is heard of and maybe even exist.

I know it is too much to ask of CVs to come up with such a complicated explanation but hey you never know...in all this, they might even succeed and with the lack of creativity, the illogical may become logical...does that make sense? lol

anyways it is not hard to recover from DID and i think, since DID happens routinely, another accident or some emotional trauma may cause Nupur to go back to old Nupur like a major accident with Gunjan (high possible) or Mayank (not much possibility)

Now even I am curious to know how they will execute this track because so far, they are not making heads and tails of it...mystery is working well with them and with this track mystery seems to fit (such as finding out how is Nupur Verma came to be? Who helped her? did she have something in her childhood that caused her to become Nupur Bhushan and now Nupur Verma? so many questions there).

let's wait and watch

we wont throw chappals at you...alothough this is highly dramatic...for all you know its true...and it makes sence cos nupur was in the trauma center...a place where people suffering form mental illness are put...
its memeory loss but as you said STRONG emotions get her real self out...
and maybe the person she is talking to i p-resume took her away from everyone seeing that her condition isnt proper..
but as you said going by the cvs track recor i DOUBT it theyll do something like that!

Originally posted by: rooj-i

Senny,

You, me and all us MNians wish for something different and you are right, it looks much more promising...

imagine: the new Nupur (who has the same, yet different qualities from the old Nupur) falling in love with Mayank but in a different style. So far, I am loving her style...especially her excessive usage of English and "By God" and then the whole annoyance...that gives Mayank more ideas of how to convince her and make her fall in love with him. Not to mention the whole Dance teacher personality...imagine her giving lessons to Mayank, instead of Mayank giving her lessons. this Nupur looks more intelligent. I loved the old Nupur but this Nupur shows more strong character. Idk but i see a new story unfolding...

then the whole dramatic raaz that will unfold later, which adds more to the story. If this track is shown, then I can see our Mayank trying to help Nupur in bringing her back and I can see Gunjan and Nupur bonding differently. As for Nupur and Samrat...a new bond of friendship...

But alas...the CVs only know how to begin something and not execute it.

rooj

PS: you're welcome 😊

I know that would be a treat. But first Mayank who has been devoid of emotions need to get them back and think straight like a sensible human who loves his wife and he should try and understand her instead of working on his new moto to make Nupur accept things forcefully.

I love Nupur, she is the only one who makes sense to me, out of all the characters. I like your idea about Mayank but he has to respect her, give her space and let her come back to him on her own, not by imposing him on her.

Originally posted by: rooj-i

You seem like a psych major...

Anyways what you have described is true but don't forget a small chot can cause DID too if a person's mental level is weak...Also even though it is clinically proven because it is hard to prove, but there are rare cases where DID is heard of and maybe even exist.

I know it is too much to ask of CVs to come up with such a complicated explanation but hey you never know...in all this, they might even succeed and with the lack of creativity, the illogical may become logical...does that make sense? lol

anyways it is not hard to recover from DID and i think, since DID happens routinely, another accident or some emotional trauma may cause Nupur to go back to old Nupur like a major accident with Gunjan (high possible) or Mayank (not much possibility)

Now even I am curious to know how they will execute this track because so far, they are not making heads and tails of it...mystery is working well with them and with this track mystery seems to fit (such as finding out how is Nupur Verma came to be? Who helped her? did she have something in her childhood that caused her to become Nupur Bhushan and now Nupur Verma? so many questions there).

let's wait and watch

Originally posted by: gina87

<font face="Comic Sans MS, Times, serif">no sweety like you said it will have to be a very weak individual to suffer from DID from an accident....and Nupur was never weak.....</font>

<font face="Comic Sans MS, Times, serif">its mostly seen in cases with sexual abuse and what not at a very young age....something your mind cannot accept about you and thus finds another way of dealing with it....</font>

<font face="Comic Sans MS, Times, serif">but treating it is next to impossible because we dont know how it comes about in the first place...thats the problem with most of the psychological conditions....the most we can do is maybe antianxiety meds and therapy.....I dont know much about the treatment because psych is not my cup of tea....I am a medical student and prefer internal medicine.....which is a field I can do something about....psych on the other hand is a whole new ball game and quiet beyond me 😆</font>

<font face="Comic Sans MS, Times, serif">and you are so right about the current storyline....it seems like the CVs themselves dont know whether to make it amnesia or anger and they flipping back and forth .....and if its amnesia, then I wonder if they will do that thing which is shown in all the movies...you know if she gets hit on the same spot again then her memories will come back 🤣....the way they showed in andaz apna apna 🤣....man that was a hilarious movie!🤣</font>

<font face="Comic Sans MS, Times, serif">anyways on a seriousl note, I feel like another accident is definitely on its way and this time its gonna be Samrat who is gonna be hurt bad...</font>

Hmmm A doctor in the house...maybe you can prescribe CVs with some Brain dosage. lol

Anways...you are right about Nupur and weak minded however I think in this case Nupur might not have been...simply for two reasons: one she was already feeling that Mayank might leave and hence the anxiety of losing someone. I know the feeling when you think about losing a close person and that brings me to the second one, she might be thinking, at the time of the accident, that her sister is in trouble and well...before an accident so many thoughts cross your mind and first ones has always been your family if you are with someone (I should know). As for DID happening at a young age. I did mention that maybe she had the split personality at a young age and well she forgot about it till now (I'm talking about how she was Nupur Verma before and then Nupur Bhushan and then Nupur Verma again 😕 and the only people who knew must be her parents or something---hey logic doesn't apply. lol)

but anyways, yea there is no proper way to solve it because we're never sure which is the right personality but you must stick with the one that has the most memories and that remembers a lot more about your adult life (at least that is my belief).

As for the memory track. lol oh man it's so repetitive that even I get tired of predicting. lol as for the movie, I never saw it sadly (ooh my friend Anam would kill me if she saw this since she is a Sallu fan. lol)

As for CVs 😆 🤣 don't you think this track resembles that of the pre-death suspense...I mean they kept us guessing till the day of...this whole Nupur-I'm angry/I'm lost- track seems to be going the same way. I wonder if they will show her to be angry in the end or really amnesia stricken...

on a side note: I am studying pre-med and psychology and media...funny how I can apply here. lol 🤣

As for another accident...you seem confident about Samrat...but then again it could be seeing how Gunjan treated him before Nupur's return and now her acceptance (I don't agree with that at all...I think Samrat needs to take minor revenge for the behavior he received)

@Shruti_nil: thanks for not throwing chappals...hopefully no Dandas either. lol j/k
yea it could be that trauma center might have changed her (possible) but as for the whole someone helping her. I considered that but somehow i think that person might have different motive...
as for CV's oh how i hope they get brains...

@Senny: You are right about Mayank...as the most sensible one from all four, he should've been more understanding. i'm not going to defend his actions but I will say this that when you meet someone after a long time, your whole logic with which you have been living with for 3 years goes down the drain and in the end emotions always win when you meet someone dear again after a long time. It's always been a proven theory your heart is stronger than your mind. But yes he shouldn't force himself upon her...I agree

Oh I love this Nupur the most...even I love Nupur out of all the characters and Dodo in season 1. lol I miss that...

btw I have another idea: Dodo coming back to revive Nupur...

And sorry I didn't see you guys post.

Also it would be helpful if you could tell me your name please.

Originally posted by: rooj-i

Are you a psychology student too? just wondering. lol 😉 😆

lol, no hun
I studied Philosophy, we only discussed pyschology...So i get the idea of it
😃