unbelieveable cast in devdas!! - do check!! - Page 27

Originally posted by: -Preeti-

<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif" size="2">I decided to not post here but then some of the comments here forced me to do so. SO i thought that being An MJHT Fan even I have a right to give my 2 cents so I am posting the below.
Also let me add all I am gonna post now would purely be based as a MJHT Fan and not being a MN Fan.

I found that people here are finding Logics behind the Show and the track. Well Good for you ... but then I would ask Was there LOGIC in this Show post last August 2009 Episodes ..... thats after the RV Case.
If I remember before that we had tiny miny bloopers and illogical tracks but that RV case gave us the Major Hit. With MAyank fighting Samrat's Case. Later On for sometime things went good with the Show with SG confession and another MN misunderstanding but at the End Allz Well ..... but not for too long as we had the MN MARRIAGE .... the major setback for most of the MN Fans and MJHT Fans as we never expected and wanted any jodi of the show getting married. But it happened and that was'nt enough so the couple was made to stay in College.
Are there any college authorities or No? And i remember how we objected this too. I mean staying in College campus would be the weirdest thing i would ever think of but MJHT did show us that.

Then came the Bachcha Track ..... why it was done or brought None of Us knew but CV's said it to be a Responsibility Test for the Youth. Responsibility TEST?
I would say instead of this bachcha they should have given them some project over the Current Youth or Current Generation and that would be the Real Responsibilty Test for them. But getting a kid and then having the guys play ring ringa roses with the Kid ..... No Comments on that as i feel we have had it done then.

Now comes the present situation .... Samrat as Devdas .... and Gunjan as Paro .... Why not? If i clearly remember Gunjan was made Paro for the time being as they did'nt have a good candidate for the Role of Paro. And for rehersal time they had Gunjan play the Role but now we have her Actually play that Role. Have CV's forgotten thier own script or are they doing this like all of a suddent ... "END MOMENT CHANGES". And Sam playing Devdas was b'coz Mayank could'nt make it and I guess Samrat had to step in as it was Excel's Reputation that would be at stake.

As for Nupur's Death and Return ..... i always objected the fact that they ended her character with .... Gunjan was given her dupatta and mangalsutra, which she showed to Mayank and both assumed her to be DEAD.
Why? Is that all people need to believe that thier loved one;s are NO More?

And Samrat .... blames himself for her not being there ....
Why? Does he believe that he did that on purpose? ...........Why? Why did Mayank and Gunjan believe it? Was thier Love just so much for Nupur that they believed her to be Dead by just seeing her Dupatta and Mangalsutra? Why did Samrat blame himself ... And Why did Gunjan and Mayank too blame Samrat for the same as if he did this on purpose? How did they forget that Nupur was Sam's Good Friend and he would never do anything that would harm her.

Three Years .... After three years we have Indications of Nupur being Alive ... through Coffee, Garland falling and Stuffs ..... Like Mayank believed instantly that Nupur is dead even this time it does'nt take time for him to believe that she's Alive.

Anything wrong the CV's does the Characters/Actors get mocked for the same...WHY? B'coz they are doing thier job Or B'coz They are the easist way to target i guess.
CV's are at fault. Its the creative's Team who are coming with such poor story lines and instead of rasing that as a point we end up blaming the characters and the actors.


All I believe and wanna say is that if we can have so many Illogical tracks in the Show then this Devdas or Nupur coming back is nothing in front of them.</font>

Originally posted by: pandemonia3

Originally posted by: bandicoot

you know it is never too late to start 😆


i keep requesting an mjht version of js


u even have zombrat nimbura miyang and ganja fans😆 (NOTE: all these character names are nt intended degrade anybody... just fictional characters from a fictional tv called stone tv... reported in a fictional newspaper called lunatic times...........shamil im ur PR)

Originally posted by: aj_observer

I told you..I told you... I asked you many times too... even when I watched ... it was total fun.... you did really miss out..🤣

Originally posted by: Sonya1986

Okay this will be the final post on this thread cuz I think it's been dragged too far now.

To Yamini, Surbhi and Senny:

I hope we all know which thread am I speaking about. The one where the topic maker said that Sanaya was an insult to Ash. I understand that you guys have the freedom to speak your minds about Sanaya's look, but we also need to have the intelligence of choosing our platform. A true critic will not go and speak out loud his view on a particular topic in a fish market, now will he? I'd expect him to be wise enough to know that he needs to write an article in a scholarly journal and get it published. Other critics with counterarguments will get back to him in a similar fashion. Okay not that I'm asking you guys to get your views on Sanaya published! But you could have opened a proper thread of your own rather than entertaining someone's foolishness.

Yes Yamini I'll call it foolishness cuz it qualifies every criteria of that characteristic. Actually you could also call me a fool for responding to a person like that, but I was having fun with those posts. Yeah I won't lie that I really intended to insult the topic maker to the core. Again, cuz I don't believe in reporting. The tone of his/her post told me that s/he is not from those who could be disciplined politely. I read some of his/her responses, and I went like no girl this person is not from those who understand human language.

Senny, I told you that I was labeled Samrat-Gunjan fan and I said fine be it so. Since I still like Arjun's acting, I wouldn't barr myself from talking about him when required regardless of how will nupur-mayank fans perceive that. I'm of the view that Rati usually looks bad in western outfits. She's one of those females who are made for eastern outfits. Now there was this thread where they had posted her pictures in a navy-blue dress in some award-function praising her to the core. Comparing that picture to seeing her in sari and all, I thought it was a disaster. But I just closed the thread without saying anything, because there was no need to pass a comment like "Oh I think she looks awful although she usually looks good in the show." Why do that? If I can't agree with the people who found her beautiful, why ruin their happiness for no good reason? unless I have a good reason! That thread was not even a bashing thread yet I decided to keep silent. Sometimes keeping silent is better than speaking up, you should have the intelligence of making the right choice.

Now coming to the most awaited question. Why did I bring in Rati? Simple: If you want to give a real blow to someone, hit it on his/her weak nerve. And you can't say I had absolutely no reason to think so. I mean when people talk with no logic, then it is pure jealousy, envy, or hatered.

So in summary, if I have committed any mistake, it is replying to that topic maker. But I still don't entirely regret it, because that was my way of guiding someone like him/her to discipline. In the process, if I have hurt true critics of Sanaya's looks supposedly Yamini. I'm sorry for that, but you're still more at fault. You ought to have found a better platform for your views than incorporating them in an undesirable place like that.

Dang! Only if the moderator could leave me alone with that topic maker for another hour....!!!! Guys, next time something like that happens, don't report it immediately to moderators. Inform me first, and then let the moderators know about it in the next couple of hours.

Originally posted by: DiyaS

Only CV's ... PLEASE PLEASE ... EDITINGGGGGGG!!!! DON'T intercut two such completely different situations ... throws viewers competely off gear and destroys the momentum of the scenes!!!

Originally posted by: shamil

thanks caro

yeah I guess its not too late..

why cant we open our IBL gallery again???😛

Originally posted by: -Preeti-

<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif" size="2">Akriti
I never went on in finding LOGIC in MJHT, that would be the LAST thing i would ever do. Infact Y MJHT</font>
<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif" size="2">

Guys

Diya
As said ...i dont find anything wrong in Gunjan and Samrat playing Paro and Devdas .... I too believe that it would have been weird to see Mayank or Rohan play Devdas in front of Gunjan as Paro. That would'nt give the required footage to this Show and the track too. CV's are now basically working on uniting MN and SG and it goes with the story that Mayank goes out searching for Nupur and so Samrat had to step in on his place.
</font>
<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif" size="2">
On this part ...... i dont trust the CV's ....as Editing is the best way in which they Ruin a particular Track .... And we fans are left with doing nothing but cribbing over here</font>

<font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif" size="2">

Charmie
Thanks for agreeing


Sonya
Sonya
here i would like to ask you one Question .... do you find it fair to held Responsible the entire MN Fan groups for the crime committed by a newbie? Even i saw that topic. And I agree with everyone who says that it was'nt upto the Rules. But do you feel by bringing in Rati there and then creating a comparison right?
You said it right ....Sometimes keeping silent is better than speaking up but No One here follows it.

I agree people have a right to Criticise and why not. After all they are the audience and if they have a right to appreciate so do they have the right to criticise. But one thing people must not forget while criticising is that you should also see that you dont end up hurting others here. MJHT is a huge forum with various set of members. Some are here for the Show, some for SG and some for MN and some are here just to have some Fun,
I wont talk about others but personally i believe in ignoring things more. There have been many things about MN track that i have never liked but i dont post here as i know if I do may be few of them would take it against. So i avoid discussing that here but rather get it sorted at the Msngers with other Friends of Mine.

I always believe retaliation would never solve the problem but it just increases the atmosphere more.

</font><font face="Georgia, Times New Roman, Times, serif" size="2">And by the way
how can you say that member who opened that post was a MN Fan? Dont you feel you'r being judgemental there?


I guess this topic has gone off the track i must leave this Topic</font>