Current MaYur Track - Discussion & Critical View - Page 2

current track is not a mayur track ...yet coz the topic of the post reads...discussion and critical view on current state of mayur......heres my view-

mayur always sidelined ....mayur used as screen fillers ...mayur not respected nor are mayur fans views and reactions taken into account.....brutal character assassination and no respect shown towards the sacred bond of matrimony...distasteful sense of humour served in the name of comedy/fun....bad editing and dialogues

edited...

I had realised it long back but now I think I should share it with you. We send a lot of messages to CVs suggesting ways and requesting them to improve mayur. it looks as if they are trying also but at the end there is not much help. The reason is simple-CVs don't go as deep into mayur as we do. Overall if you look at the scene like- Nupur-s victory n she cuming back frm goons, safe-----it seems great-----just as fans wanted-----but wht about inside it??? What about the reaction of every character?? It is important to realise the importance of details. There are some shows on TV who stretch small scenes for many episodes and we think they are fools....but it is not so...for a person to relate with a character it is very important. In MJHT, atleast for mayur, scenes seem to be prepared in a very crude way, without much thought. CVs must realise the significance of every single line spoken in the show. This may take more time but it's worth it. Quality is something that cannot be compromised. There should be scenes within scenes. Minute details should be taken care of. Great storyline, actors, plot cannot do what a simple, meaningful dialogue can do. One small scene can make a person love the show or hate it. Characters should be treated as real-life individuals....this can help in a great way as normal ppl have a way of thinking and living which cannot change instantaneously.....they are narrating a story and every small aspect should be shown......fast-moving story, interesting and new ideas, fun and romantic scenes are good on the surface, but to keep the show running for long and make the viewers identify with characters CONSISTENSY and QUALITY are required. The reasons behind biggest of problems in life are very simple....its the same here......the problem is basic and deep. Lack of attention, scenes not given the required amount of time and thought......every scene not viewed with the perspective of every charecter......every dialogue not given enuff importance. To write Nupur's dialogues, a person will have to think like Nupur has done till now, the Nupur who cant hear another girl's name can't suddenly accept her husband kissing someone else only because the fans want a happy track and that no1 wud like misunderstandings and fights at this.....things cant move as per convenience.....If u have started a track by showing mayank kiss sum1 then have the guts to give a proper end to it no matter what crtics say.....if u do it well, if it's justified n logical, ppl will automatically love it n ne case loyal fans will keep watching bcos they love mayur for what they are.....plzzz don't don't be so insecure and don't make fans more important than the show......CVs don't have faith in themselves or their story......

This is my optimistic best....this show doesn't have class.....I feel srry as a fan

Thanks,
Shilpa

i hope 2 c more of mayur chemistry onscreen. i think they shd focus more on mayur

I have again feel cheated as a viewer while watching the episode, we all fans are crazy and emotional freaks and thus our reactions some of it come more strongly than others, hope that such reactions and feedback would be read in a positive light and read that if at all, they would be given a serious thought too.

there was a time, long long LONG ago when MN wer dead for me .. but, today, they wer ripped apart ..

for once upon a time..long long ago it seems, when this show began, I'd actually prefered mayank over samrat on many instances and I m NOT kidding .. there was this guy who was sarcastic but sweet, street smart - yet a lil naive when it comes to love, a guy, who had absolutely NO qualms abt who he was and who didnt give a DAMN as to what the world thought of him or his 'image' per say, a guy who had a HUGE female following, but never really gave importance to them - absolutely diff than the usual cliched characters u get in every next serial/film .. a complete contrast of samrat .. and yes, I had actually preferred him over samrat on loads of instances and its wit THIS right that I m posting here ..

there was a nupur - lively and vivacious .. who believ in what her heart told her, more than what the blatant truth the world showed her, who showered love on her loved ones as much as she scolded them, who was severly filmy and dramatic, but absolutely innocent and simple at heart - atleast this was what I'd percieved abt her character as nupur .. and again, its wit THIS right that m posting here ..

and thats why, GuNur for me, were ideal sisters, they had their loads of differences externally, but internally, they both wer soo similar, since both wer essentially jus the same - innocent and simple at heart .. almost like made from the same piece of soul - I m saying this for the initial first few months of MJHT ONLY ..

and those were the times I genuinely adored MN .. I did .. I loved their cute fights and was waiting to see what it wud b like to see them in love .. so much that I also did wonder, their relationship lacked this trust and friendship factor right now, but mayb, once they are together, this trust wil b enhanced and increased beyond measure and they wil evolve much more knowing each other as a person WHEN they entered into a relationship?

and believe me, I HAVE seen such relationships around me..and they work .. I have seen two ppl going into a relationship very quickly without knowing each other much, and yes they fought too, but everytime they did, it only got them closer ..and they stayed together, because in their relationship they did develop the trust and the bond that was needed ..

but sadly, the CVs proved me wrong when they showed them falling in love wit each other and the WAY their relationship was then on potrayed to be ..

since that point of time til the MN track, I m not gonna comment, because I dont hav the right, since I havent understood/related to their characters AT ALL ...

there was, however, one thing I was TOTALLY sure abt was the loyalty that mayank always had towards nupur..since he had always been a one-woman man .. but this was brutally butchered today .. if it werent for the fact that I'd already lost respect for them long ago, then I wud hav lost all respect for them all over again at this point ...

however, if the CVs are actually reading this post, then I'd like them to please read thru the bold points .. because once those traits return back, I dont think ther is anything else to request ..everything within them wil b restored, once those traits in their basic characters are restored!

Okay after reading a lot of posts about mayur being butchered and what not and also comments on sajan giving "gyaan", I think I would also like to put in my two cents as well.....

I know that MN and uday holi kiss mess could have been handled with a lot more seriousness and shown in a better way by the CVs, but even this way didn kill their characters or their love.....

Because what you are not seeing is that nupur is not the kind to listen to anyone if she makes up her mind so if she had actually not trusted mayank then nothing gunjan said would have made a difference....its because she trust him all the way that she didn take this matter seriously but as a minor couple fight....which is actually really cool if you think about it cuz who would blame a girl for over reacting in this situation....

And as far as Mayank doubting himself goes...I admire him for that because it takes guts to admit something like that to yourself let alone in front of your wife and friends.....this shows his strength of character and his faith in his relationship with his wife....a weaker guy would have denied even the possibility of something like that happening and blamed anyone else rather than ever admit to making a mistake.....

Guys isn it really nice to see that even a thing like kissing another girl cant shake their faith in each other...but obviously this point was not shown in the best possible way and I hope that the CVs (after reading all those pages of advice) wont make the same mistake again.....

Originally posted by: dmgmjht4ever

Thanks DB for the post, this was needed.

All I'm going to say is that: It's a show, don't get so obsessed with it. Mayank and Nupur aren't real people, they are characters in a tv show. So it your choice to watch the show or not. Why are you complaining about it so much. It's just a show, it's not happening to real life to you. So don't worry about it. Your choice to watch it or not.

i agree.....at the end of the day its a tvc show after all...the strings of which arent in our hand.....so why simply get so depressed......

Originally posted by: gina87

<font size="3" face="Calibri">Okay after reading a lot of posts about mayur being butchered and what not and also comments on sajan giving "gyaan", I think I would also like to put in my two cents as well.....</font>

<font size="3" face="Calibri">I know that MN and uday holi kiss mess could have been handled with a lot more seriousness and shown in a better way by the CVs, but even this way didn kill their characters or their love.....</font>

<font size="3" face="Calibri">Because what you are not seeing is that nupur is not the kind to listen to anyone if she makes up her mind so if she had actually not trusted mayank then nothing gunjan said would have made a difference....its because she trust him all the way that she didn take this matter seriously but as a minor couple fight....which is actually really cool if you think about it cuz who would blame a girl for over reacting in this situation....</font>

<font size="3" face="Calibri">And as far as Mayank doubting himself goes...I admire him for that because it takes guts to admit something like that to yourself let alone in front of your wife and friends.....this shows his strength of character and his faith in his relationship with his wife....a weaker guy would have denied even the possibility of something like that happening and blamed anyone else rather than ever admit to making a mistake.....</font>

<font size="3"><font face="Calibri">Guys isn it really nice to see that even a thing like kissing another girl cant shake their faith in each other...but obviously this point was not shown in the best possible way and I hope that the CVs (after reading all those pages of advice) wont make the same mistake again.....</font></font>

<font size="3" face="Calibri"></font>

i agree with you...it was handeled in the way which apppealed to both the cherecters .....therefore i have no complaints!

Mayank and Nupur were souls of MJHT, coz they were real..............they had misunderstanding, they fought, sorted out and in turn came closer...........

They were not constantly insecure about their love, about their partner or talked incesstantly about some wordly things like saints............

They were like common people around and that was their charm.

Mayank was and had alwz been a one-woman guy...............so seeing him doubting himself as to he might wud have kissed someone else is not disgestable. Not at all...................

Ye would have sat and clarified with his wife, and not make a show of their fight.

and whom did they believe..........UDAY.............plz give me a break.

I guess a relook is required at the whole MN track...........or whatever it is.................

And last thing they require is gyaan on how to take their realtionship properly.............. not from anyone.................