MJHT and Remix - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

137

Views

12k

Users

30

Likes

317

Frequent Posters

AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#31
LadyM, YaRa4ever, Kavya: Fantastic posts! Very well said!


@topic: I've only recently had the opportunity to watch Remix re-runs from the beginning and honestly that show is a class apart as compared to MJHT.....let's not even begin to put MJHT in the same league....Remix was a show that literally launched Star One and gave it a big boost as a youth based shows channel.....it was pathbreaking that way....for all the reasons LadyM listed out so well....that it dealt with real issues like drug abuse, peer pressure, parental pressures so well....and ALL characters had something to do in the show....they had a POINT to them.

MJHT and DMG are the 'new age' version of Star One 'youth shows'.....the fluff, inane variety which only focus on showing romance b/w the couples and everything else including development of a storyline/secondary characters is secondary for the most part.....infact it hardly figures in the scheme of things.....Jab tak "passionate romance" hai, tab tak saari logic/sense gayi tel lene.....these shows revel in descending into mindless buffoonery from time to time...well this is what the audience of today seems to want I guess given the popularity of these shows.

These days the mantra seems to be just on focussing on creating a 'hit jodi', nothing else....and that's easy enough....show the characters clashing for a bit, then they fall in love later on and start romancing and tadaa....audience khush.

I won't deny that I'm also a fan of Mayank-Nupur from this show.....my only main reason for watching it....but that has other factors attached to it in how I identify with the characters especially Mayank.....the same way Mads identifies with Gunjan and that pulls her in.....but the fact remains that if we look at an overall perspective, there is hardly anything of substance in this show that can be applauded....in my opinion atleast......it's inane/slapstick fluff for the most part with occasionally good scenes......which have dwindled in frequency much more as the show has progressed.

Remix on the other hand, from what I've seen of it so far.....is much more realistic in depicting today's youth....and this isn't just a 'oh that's a high school based show and MJHT is a college based one' thing.....No, Remix depicted high school life MUCH better than MJHT has EVER managed to depict college life.....anyone remember the last time these ppl even managed to attend classes?? LOLL

Just my two cents. No offence intended to anyone. If anyone still wants to be offended, their choice.
427050 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#32
even MJHT is not original creatives have shown their SRK love now and then.
Bazinga thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#33
@fan_mjht: Nupur is innocent unlike Ashi because of their different roots- Nupur was a small town middle-class girl as against Ashi who was a city-bred rich girl. Also Nupur is not a rebel like Ashi but yes the erstwhile Nupur is closer in character to Ashi in many ways!
Edited by Kavya_KraZQueen - 16 years ago
FollowYourHeart thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#34
d only thing i find in common btw nupur and ashi is their love for living life in a king sized manner dey belive in grabbing small lil lil dozes of happyness insted of waiting for the big one to cme they belive in living the moment and nupur umm d orijnal nupr i shld say coz since d time she realized she loves mayank she kinda has takena 360 degree ka turn but the orijnal nupur like ashi was loaded wid self confidence but then i really didn't like her starting obsession in trasforming the way she looks and dresses just to blend inw id the hep mumbai crowd that is somehting which ahsi wouldn't do even in a hundred lives Its just their living life to the fullest wala attitude which is similar to a certain extent and thats the reason y i like Nupur as a char again the "orijnal" nupur absolutely detest her changed avtaar come on man love doesnt changes u it gives u d freedome to all d more be urself be who u r Besides nupur i like Sammy coz he reminds me of yuvi in more ways than one:)
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#35
I don't think Nupur and Ashi are alike, really.....Nupur does have a fiery temper as well and believes in standing up for her rights and all but Ashi was a class apart.....a rebel in the true sense of the word....and there were many more layers to her....she had a soft heart, despite being brash on the surface many times....she had a strong sense of honor....in standing up for what she believed was right.

Nupur is more in keeping with what MJHT is.....gloss as LadyM aptly said.....Nupur is a filmy, nautanki sort of character that is shown to be a bit of a dim bulb from time to time....there was scope for a lot of layers to be shown to her character as well but the creatives don't seem to care much to explore her in that direction.....LOL....
427050 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: FollowYourHeart

d only thing i find in common btw nupur and ashi is their love for living life in a king sized manner dey belive in grabbing small lil lil dozes of happyness insted of waiting for the big one to cme they belive in living the moment and nupur umm d orijnal nupr i shld say coz since d time she realized she loves mayank she kinda has takena 360 degree ka turn but the orijnal nupur like ashi was loaded wid self confidence but then i really didn't like her starting obsession in trasforming the way she looks and dresses just to blend inw id the hep mumbai crowd that is somehting which ahsi wouldn't do even in a hundred lives Its just their living life to the fullest wala attitude which is similar to a certain extent and thats the reason y i like Nupur as a char again the "orijnal" nupur absolutely detest her changed avtaar come on man love doesnt changes u it gives u d freedome to all d more be urself be who u r Besides nupur i like Sammy coz he reminds me of yuvi in more ways than one:)

@ bold-yup both of them were spoilt brats but sam sometimes becomes a YRF hero unlike yuvi(no offence to any sam fans, even I m one sam fan but just saying the truth)
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#37

Originally posted by: fan_mjht

@ bold-yup both of them were spoilt brats but sam sometimes becomes a YRF hero unlike yuvi(no offence to any sam fans, even I m one sam fan but just saying the truth)



Totally agree.....Sam is quite one-dimensional as compared to Yuvi....Yuvi had a lot of layers to him as well....his conflicted relationship with his father really added to that....so he was a typical flirt/bad boy of the school to begin with but as the show progressed, there was a reasoning shown to that and more and more layers unfolded.

I'm yet to seen any such layers to most of the characters in MJHT😆....Guess it's too much work to actually manage to develop the characters in a well-rounded manner....so much easier to show them prancing around in a new song sequence🥱
427050 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#38

Originally posted by: nureat01

I don't think Nupur and Ashi are alike, really.....Nupur does have a fiery temper as well and believes in standing up for her rights and all but Ashi was a class apart.....a rebel in the true sense of the word....and there were many more layers to her....she had a soft heart, despite being brash on the surface many times....she had a strong sense of honor....in standing up for what she believed was right.

Nupur is more in keeping with what MJHT is.....gloss as LadyM aptly said.....Nupur is a filmy, nautanki sort of character that is shown to be a bit of a dim bulb from time to time....there was scope for a lot of layers to be shown to her character as well but the creatives don't seem to care much to explore her in that direction.....LOL....

yup but considering the self sacrificing character of gunji nupur is closer to ashi gunji is close to BT heroines.
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#39

Originally posted by: fan_mjht

yup but considering the self sacrificing character of gunji nupur is closer to ashi gunji is close to BT heroines.



LOL yes Gunjan is quite the mahaan self-sacrificing kinds, but just cuz Nupur is not doesn't really make her Ashi-like I think......It makes Nupur more realistic, yes cuz she doesn't let ppl take her for a ride that way but she's still not as sharp as Ashi was.....plus if Ashi and Nupur ever met in real life, Ashi would make sooooooo much fun of her for her filmy obsessions.....lol....Ashi is not frivolous at all....while Nupur on the other hand is.....I think she would gel more with a Tia types😆
Edited by nureat01 - 16 years ago
Bazinga thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#40

Originally posted by: nureat01

LadyM, YaRa4ever, Kavya: Fantastic posts! Very well said!


@topic: I've only recently had the opportunity to watch Remix re-runs from the beginning and honestly that show is a class apart as compared to MJHT.....let's not even begin to put MJHT in the same league.(Exactly Anu jee 😆 😆, we should not even compare MJHT to Remix, the former is NOWHERE near the sensibility which the latter show cased very well !)...Remix was a show that literally launched Star One and gave it a big boost as a youth based shows channel.....it was pathbreaking that way (You have put it SO well. YES, Remix WAS a path breaking show- not only was it a maverick in its times (because the TV was RULED by BT soaps then) but it was also a YOUTH show in TRUE SENSE)....for all the reasons LadyM listed out so well....that it dealt with real issues like drug abuse, peer pressure, parental pressures so well....and ALL characters had something to do in the show....they had a POINT to them. (BINGO! Remix was one show which equally appealed to the masses as well as the intelligent viewers)

MJHT and DMG are the 'new age' version of Star One 'youth shows'.....the fluff, inane variety which only focus on showing romance b/w the couples and everything else including development of a storyline/secondary characters is secondary for the most part.....infact it hardly figures in the scheme of things.....Jab tak "passionate romance" hai, tab tak saari logic/sense gayi tel lene.....these shows revel in descending into mindless buffoonery from time to time...well this is what the audience of today seems to want I guess given the popularity of these shows.

These days the mantra seems to be just on focussing on creating a 'hit jodi', nothing else....and that's easy enough....show the characters clashing for a bit, then they fall in love later on and start romancing and tadaa....audience khush.

I won't deny that I'm also a fan of Mayank-Nupur from this show.....my only main reason for watching it....but that has other factors attached to it in how I identify with the characters especially Mayank.....the same way Mads identifies with Gunjan and that pulls her in.....but the fact remains that if we look at an overall perspective, there is hardly anything of substance in this show that can be applauded....in my opinion atleast......it's inane/slapstick fluff for the most part with occasionally good scenes......which have dwindled in frequency much more as the show has progressed.

Remix on the other hand, from what I've seen of it so far.....is much more realistic in depicting today's youth....and this isn't just a 'oh that's a high school based show and MJHT is a college based one' thing.....No, Remix depicted high school life MUCH better than MJHT has EVER managed to depict college life.....anyone remember the last time these ppl even managed to attend classes?? LOLL

Just my two cents. No offence intended to anyone. If anyone still wants to be offended, their choice.



@blue: I COMPLETELY AGREE with that! Its no less than a CRIME to expect SENSE and LOGIC from the current crop of youth shows on Star One. All these shows have more or less the same cliched scenes in the name of 'romance', the only difference being them enacted by different actors each time. Also, they focus on the SINGULAR aspect of love n mushy romance like nothing else exists in the characters' lives, they keep on adding new characters mindlessly irrespective of their contribution to the story (IF there is one) while failing to properly utilize the already existing side characters....I don't even want to draw a contrast between Remix n the current star one shows because my post would become a PAPER on the decrepit state of the current Indian Televison scenario then 😆 😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".