*~*TAZBU (SaiShi and RaghVi) AT 17*~* Meri Duniyaa - Page 57

Created

Last reply

Replies

1.2k

Views

68.5k

Users

38

Likes

3.4k

Frequent Posters

PSharada thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

I absolutely love MHRW for lot of things

- For casting local actors who look the part

- For casting the D family so perfect in the first episodes and getting the Maharastrian look on dot

- For Raghav still using beautiful telugu dialogues in between and not losing the feel of a Hyderabadi person. Believe me the way hyderabadis speak Hindi is little different

- For having the beautiful RR Mansion and the beautiful scenes that this PH shot using mirror as reflection

- For giving enough takkar to the FL and ML in the beginning episodes that I was rooting for Raghav and Pallavi by turns. During Lion track my sympathy was with Raghav and then dang I hated him during the defamation track.

- For making the forcible marriage at least reasonable and not cringy like in most shows where the ML has misunderstanding and goes on rampage by marrying the FL - How it suits the purpose is beyond me.

- For giving strong MILs who root for the daughter-in-law more than the son

- For the beautiful redemption of Raghav in Hyderabad track

- For the understanding and heartfelt conversations of Raghav and Pallavi

- For staying true to the characters for most part of the show - including Raghav's Ostrich tendency of burying his head in the sand and Pallavi being so pure and generous.


I can safely say MHRW will be my favorite show for a very long time.

PSharada thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago


Are they shooting ? Is this shoot pic? I think it is offscreen right.

laughingmonkey thumbnail
5th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: PSharada


I can't watch this story as I don't have an IG account. What is the story about. Can someone tell me please.

Image

joliefemme thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: PSharada

I absolutely love MHRW for lot of things

- For casting local actors who look the part

- For casting the D family so perfect in the first episodes and getting the Maharastrian look on dot

- For Raghav still using beautiful telugu dialogues in between and not losing the feel of a Hyderabadi person. Believe me the way hyderabadis speak Hindi is little different

- For having the beautiful RR Mansion and the beautiful scenes that this PH shot using mirror as reflection

- For giving enough takkar to the FL and ML in the beginning episodes that I was rooting for Raghav and Pallavi by turns. During Lion track my sympathy was with Raghav and then dang I hated him during the defamation track.

- For making the forcible marriage at least reasonable and not cringy like in most shows where the ML has misunderstanding and goes on rampage by marrying the FL - How it suits the purpose is beyond me.

- For giving strong MILs who root for the daughter-in-law more than the son

- For the beautiful redemption of Raghav in Hyderabad track

- For the understanding and heartfelt conversations of Raghav and Pallavi

- For staying true to the characters for most part of the show - including Raghav's Ostrich tendency of burying his head in the sand and Pallavi being so pure and generous.


I can safely say MHRW will be my favorite show for a very long time.


Plus 100.


The characters of Raghvi, the actors Saishi, their chemistry and the redemption track will be my absolute favourite.


Bold I agree with. I don't think any show can beat this one ever.. it's made such a mark in my heart ki main kabhi nai bhul sakti is show ko :(

fria319 thumbnail
6th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: rubys07


Lol Sunaina, I used to follow IPK very diligently (it was the only desi show I watched back then) and while I liked many things, I was not/am still not okay with the manhandling and lack of redemption (but that's a common problem with most of Gul's shows). Barun and Sanaya were asked in a recent interview about the show and why they thought it clicked with the audience. Both said that the angry young man falling for the bubbly girl was a somewhat different trope back in those days. If you notice, there was a sharp increase in TV shows following that same pattern after IPK's success. Gul's followed the exact same formula for most of her other shows since then (IB, Humsafars, QH, YJHJK to name a few). It's been done so many times by now that it no longer looks as appealing (to me at least). (There are people who still love IPK and I respect that.)

Compared to that, MHRW is just different, and it's not just one thing that makes it different. SS has done the best thing ever by casting SaiShi as RaghVi because I don't think RaghVi were originally written with such nuances on paper. The writing of these characters might have been good but Sai and Shivangi have made Raghav and Pallavi extraordinarily remarkable. I've spent more than half my life watching ITV and I've never rewatched any of its shows as many times as I've rewatched MHRW. Like we've discussed here earlier, the problem with SS is that while he usually has better plots and some originality, he doesn't know how to follow through his own story after a point. I'm assuming that all the criticism from the fans didn't help the matter either because it might've just made him more willing to get done with the show and move on.


The angry young man trope was HUGE back in the day.


I was actually worried MHRW would be like that too but they gave enough nuances to R and they softened him up enough that it his anger didn't feel unjustified. He got the situation wrong several times and went above and beyond to torture P but he was soft with her too and helped her too. It was very different from ASR-K pairing. P gave back as good as she got and R actually changed and wanted to change.


His anger towards P in the first set of episodes were because of her and who she was not because he just hated all women (they tried this and immediately retconned it so I'm just going to say this was not the reason).


Whereas if I think of IPKKND, they never showed ASR really appreciating K for who she was. He just fell for her beauty and bubbliness but there was no admiration of her as a person. He didn't respect her in the way that R actually does respect, admire and look up to P. Add to that they kept letting ASR manhandle her and they never gave him a redemption track = not rewatchable at all. In hindsight it's very cringe.

RishiGirl thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: PSharada


Are they shooting ? Is this shoot pic? I think it is offscreen right.

This is from today morning when she came to the set
rubys07 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: Shri_12

I always feel that audience are quite harsh on producers/directors. Majority of us do not work in entertainment industry, so naturally we don't know how exactly things work on ground level. However, at times, we pass judgements as if we know everything. At this point, criticism is no longer constructive.


At times, its like saying, if you are programmer you should know everything from hacking Facebook to repairing PCs

I agree Shri. I get annoyed too when a story I like gets ruined, like I've got issues with some of the tracks in this show but I kept my venting limited to IF. IMO, it's completely acceptable and good if people are using IG, TT or other means to reach out to the creatives and give constructive feedback but so many of the comments I've seen addressed to the creatives/actors of the show make me feel bad for these people because of how negative and toxic these are.

PSharada thumbnail
Posted: 3 years ago


Nope can't see 😭

joliefemme thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 3 years ago

Originally posted by: rubys07


Lol Sunaina, I used to follow IPK very diligently (it was the only desi show I watched back then) and while I liked many things, I was not/am still not okay with the manhandling and lack of redemption (but that's a common problem with most of Gul's shows). Barun and Sanaya were asked in a recent interview about the show and why they thought it clicked with the audience. Both said that the angry young man falling for the bubbly girl was a somewhat different trope back in those days. If you notice, there was a sharp increase in TV shows following that same pattern after IPK's success. Gul's followed the exact same formula for most of her other shows since then (IB, Humsafars, QH, YJHJK to name a few). It's been done so many times by now that it no longer looks as appealing (to me at least). (There are people who still love IPK and I respect that.)

Compared to that, MHRW is just different, and it's not just one thing that makes it different. SS has done the best thing ever by casting SaiShi as RaghVi because I don't think RaghVi were originally written with such nuances on paper. The writing of these characters might have been good but Sai and Shivangi have made Raghav and Pallavi extraordinarily remarkable. I've spent more than half my life watching ITV and I've never rewatched any of its shows as many times as I've rewatched MHRW. Like we've discussed here earlier, the problem with SS is that while he usually has better plots and some originality, he doesn't know how to follow through his own story after a point. I'm assuming that all the criticism from the fans didn't help the matter either because it might've just made him more willing to get done with the show and move on.


I'm not sure how many here have watched Geet but it was the original Gul show (angry young man and dukhiyari female) which was later literally copy pasted (in terms of a lot of things) in IPK.


Geet wasn't as popular because it was on star one while IPK was on star plus. Both shows were way too similar except for the background story of the leads. The treatment, the fall catch scenes all of them were literally the same.


I could never come to watch IPK after Geet because it was class apart but like Fria said Mhrw will remain timeless and will always have a recall value while I won't be able to watch Geet the same way I did a decade ago.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".