hamzanuha thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
I feel that once again there is favouritism in Masterchef India season 2. Last season, it was Radhika; this time it's Shipra.
In last week's Invention test, in the 1st round, Shazia had made a dish which utilized all the parts of the banana tree & which led to her being the 1st to be declared safe. It was a truly commendable achievement. Then the next round saw Shipra to safety, after a breakdown where she saw her dreams fading.
Then, after the Masterclass, we saw Shipra make her recipe & not Shazia. Why? I don't think Shazia would've wanted to keep her recipe a secret, especially when all the recipes can be found on the channel's website.
Pls these are my opinions & Shazia is not my fav nor do I dislike Shipra. Both are extremely talented ladies. If there are any fans of either, pls note hurting anyone is not my intention, deliberate or otherwise.
But I want to know the reason for Shazia's exclusion.

Created

Last reply

Replies

16

Views

3.1k

Users

8

Likes

21

Frequent Posters

GuardianDevil thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
~may be ur right! but v cant do anything!
Archie0405 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#3
I don't think that any favouritism was done in case of Radhika as well. Watching all her episodes inspired me to be perfectionist. If any favouritism had been done in case of shipra then she must not have been appreciated in hong kong by the 2 michellin star chef. There she was d last one to reach(if dolce nd shahjad hadn't forgotten that pepper & salt) but still she & her partner were quite confident. I really like has that way. And guys she's already going through lots of trouble but still she tries her best to invent new recipe. She's beauty with brain and she's my favourite. I just wonder why her husband left such a good cook. I just pray to God that she wins the title becoz she deserves it nd needs it the most
hamzanuha thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: Archie0405

I don't think that any favouritism was done in case of Radhika as well. Watching all her episodes inspired me to be perfectionist. If any favouritism had been done in case of shipra then she must not have been appreciated in hong kong by the 2 michellin star chef. There she was d last one to reach(if dolce nd shahjad hadn't forgotten that pepper & salt) but still she & her partner were quite confident. I really like has that way. And guys she's already going through lots of trouble but still she tries her best to invent new recipe. She's beauty with brain and she's my favourite. I just wonder why her husband left such a good cook. I just pray to God that she wins the title becoz she deserves it nd needs it the most

My dear, if you noticed, I'm talking about last week's episode.
Lil_Mz_Sunshine thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: hamzanuha

I feel that once again there is favouritism in Masterchef India season 2. Last season, it was Radhika; this time it's Shipra.

In last week's Invention test, in the 1st round, Shazia had made a dish which utilized all the parts of the banana tree & which led to her being the 1st to be declared safe. It was a truly commendable achievement. Then the next round saw Shipra to safety, after a breakdown where she saw her dreams fading.
Then, after the Masterclass, we saw Shipra make her recipe & not Shazia. Why? I don't think Shazia would've wanted to keep her recipe a secret, especially when all the recipes can be found on the channel's website.
Pls these are my opinions & Shazia is not my fav nor do I dislike Shipra. Both are extremely talented ladies. If there are any fans of either, pls note hurting anyone is not my intention, deliberate or otherwise.
But I want to know the reason for Shazia's exclusion.


if u notice, there are three levels,and as the level increases it goes more harder to complete the task

shipra made her dish with only Banana flower, but for shazia she used all parts of banana in her dish

so u cant compare the both dishes equally, coz unlike shazia ,shipra hadnt much ingredients and all she had is only banana flower yet she managed to bring out her best in that level.

If shazia was there in 2nd level and if she made her dish with banana flower, we can compare their dishes and judge them on that basis. u can give out ur best dishes when u have all the possible ingredients of banana but its really difficult to make dessert by using only banana flower. it was the difficult task than compared to shazia's and shipra managed it well.

so its fair if shipr's dish has been chosen as the best dish for that day



Edited by R3b3l_Pr1nc3s5 - 14 years ago
luvkasu thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 14 years ago
#6
i so agree with u! i guess shazia is the most underated cook, but in reality she is one of the BEST cook
hamzanuha thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: R3b3l_Pr1nc3s5


if u notice, there are three levels,and as the level increases it goes more harder to complete the task

shipra made her dish with only Banana flower, but for shazia she used all parts of banana in her dish

so u cant compare the both dishes equally, coz unlike shazia ,shipra hadnt much ingredients and all she had is only banana flower yet she managed to bring out her best in that level.

If shazia was there in 2nd level and if she made her dish with banana flower, we can compare their dishes and judge them on that basis. u can give out ur best dishes when u have all the possible ingredients of banana but its really difficult to make dessert by using only banana flower. it was the difficult task than compared to shazia's and shipra managed it well.

so its fair if shipr's dish has been chosen as the best dish for that day

@ Bold - That's called creativity. It's much more difficult to create a dish which has all the ingredients.
The judges had already hinted that the flower could be used to give a delicate flavour. Shipra's homework had already been done for her.
Similarly, with the last test where Puneet & Shaizad had to make a starter using only the stem. Here I felt that Puneet had scored over Shaizad who only made canapes with slivers of the ingredient to be used, whereas Puneet made a proper dish.
hamzanuha thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: luvkasu

i so agree with u! i guess shazia is the most underated cook, but in reality she is one of the BEST cook

Agreed, she is the most underrated in the show. She has come up with quite a few innovative dishes.
Lil_Mz_Sunshine thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: hamzanuha

@ Bold - That's called creativity. It's much more difficult to create a dish which has all the ingredients.

The judges had already hinted that the flower could be used to give a delicate flavour. Shipra's homework had already been done for her.
Similarly, with the last test where Puneet & Shaizad had to make a starter using only the stem. Here I felt that Puneet had scored over Shaizad who only made canapes with slivers of the ingredient to be used, whereas Puneet made a proper dish.


if it was more difficult then why wouldnt they make that rule for last round and give the difficult task for level 3 round

aint they said the difficulty increases when the level increase-




Edited by R3b3l_Pr1nc3s5 - 14 years ago
hamzanuha thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: R3b3l_Pr1nc3s5

if it was more difficult then why wouldnt they make that rule for last round and give the difficult task for level 3 round

aint they said the difficulty increases when the level increase-

Sorry, but I felt the complexity was due more to the time constraints 😊

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".