Random Musings: February 18, 2011 - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

58

Views

4.2k

Users

15

Likes

316

Frequent Posters

RadiantTreasure thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#21
@Jaya- hehe pretty much thinking same..but i really don't want the show to get compromised with another day's extension..which happened in other channel..(no offence)
@Devi:Welcome to Random Musing..🤗n loved reading u r views..as much as much as i agree that now rishab's even mere existence will not really effect uttara after knowing he just doesn't care for her..i still think that uttara has this soft corner for her as he is her husband..right now there are many other options that uttara can do n i am just thinking what would it be.?..
Well CV's u better come up some good plot..
Devi..hope to see u more!!😃
Good wishes..❤️
Sri:-)

BheegiBasanti thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#22
Sri...I think I know which channel you are talking about! 😆
RadiantTreasure thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: darlunia

Sri...I think I know which channel you are talking about! 😆


Haila😲 u caught me😃🤣
Its obvious ..isn't it?😳😆😳
Sri:-
)
BheegiBasanti thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#24
Sri...😆...if you're referring to GHSP...I used to watch the show very regularly before and post my views. Not so enamored of it anymore!
RadiantTreasure thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#25
Same here jaya..as i much as love seeing MaanEet scenes n hearing "Mahiiiiiiiiiiiiiii"😍..i am unable to connect it to it anymore..
Even though after saying that i still see it most of the times unable to control the urge!!!..🤣
Sri:-)

538783 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: darlunia

Devi...welcome. I'm Jaya! 😊

Loved reading your perspective. Good point about Uttara feeling empowered. I feel like she has always felt that way unlike Devyani for example. Like most victims of abuse, I think she "needs" to feel loved by Rishabh. The other side of abuse is the abusers ability to make the victim feel loved...during the calm period of course. Somehow compared to the previous time when Uttara sat with the knife, today's execution did not feel like the breaking point for me. Your point is very well taken though!

Hope to see you back as a regular sharing your views. Enjoyed reading what you wrote today immensely.


Thank you Jaya :)

I agree that Uttara has always been more empowered in some regards (not all though) than Devyani. But then again, Devyani's husband is a completely different animal (pun intended ;) than Uttara's.

In one point about the abuse victim mentality, I actually think a bit differently. It's very clear that Uttara loves Rishab and to a certain extent was forgiving his abusiveness as it appeared to be arising from his extreme sense of inadequacy (also, the physical abuse appears to be a problem that emerged later in their life than earlier - but do correct me if I am wrong about the facts here. I missed most of the earlier episodes).
And I think, from Uttara's perspective, there was always "hope" that this would be the last time, that things had really changed, that he will be good from now on... every time that he did go through his calm periods. I don't know that it's necessarily her 'need to be loved' as much as her need to believe that her love was strong enough to survive this and make him better. And every time he becomes good, it somehow reinforces that belief.
What is different about this time for her is not so much the fact that they were beating the living daylights out of each other (although as I noted before, that is pretty big too), but the fact that he did it after he sold her body to another man. She was trying to hold it together and move on with her life even after that, but really only at the request of her sister (who really proves yet again that 'The Nile' is not just a river in Egypt!). I can't imagine how a woman cannot reach her breaking point after her husband sells her and then tries to kill her after that.... but maybe that's just my significantly less tolerant side... :)

-Devi

538783 thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: darlunia

Sri...😆...if you're referring to GHSP...I used to watch the show very regularly before and post my views. Not so enamored of it anymore!


Lol.. I am in the same boat :) I have been trying to get some of the members that i met on the GHSP forum to give Maryada a chance, but so far with no luck (but only because they are reluctant to add yet another show to their must-watch list at the risk of spending yet more time on IF ;)

-Devi
..Naina.. thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 14 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: sridevi27


Lol.. I am in the same boat :) I have been trying to get some of the members that i met on the GHSP forum to give Maryada a chance, but so far with no luck (but only because they are reluctant to add yet another show to their must-watch list at the risk of spending yet more time on IF ;)

-Devi



Sigh I used to love GHSP, but in the past few months I've kind of lost interest completely. And Maryada has me hooked. Such a great story.

Unfortunately none of my friends prefer the serious plot, so it's a huge no from them.

I say they're missing out😆

~Naina
RadiantTreasure thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 14 years ago
#29
Haila ..😲this is becoming GHSP VS. Maryada convo?But i am still loving it.. 🤣
We all need a huge dose of marayda..🤓so here u go i made this VM yesterday on Aditya N Priya..❤️n it's kind of Not that great,,but still watch n tell me how is it as its my first attempt..😳



Good wishes guys..keep discussing whatever u want ..we are not really bothered as long as u love Marayada..!!😃🤣
Sri:-)

BheegiBasanti thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#30
Devi...very good points. 😃

About the source of Rishabh's abuse...the root cause has never been made entirely clear. Yeah...the feeling of inadequacy post the accident that crippled him is certainly a major driving factor. But the genesis of what made him become this person capable of physical abuse has to be something far more intrinsic to his personality. He has been characterized as an extremely possessive kind of person. That is a usually a trait that precedes the abuse itself. From the way the makers have executed some of the Uttara - Rishabh scenes, I have felt she was always waiting for the abuse to begin again.

Uttara fighting back today for me was less about a breaking point and more about her innate personality coming to the fore. She is the gutsy one of the protagonists. Priya stands up for herself but Uttara is more the "in-your-face" kind. Rishabh's betrayal was huge and when he treated her like crap after she returned, it definitely removed the blinders off. It is entirely likely that this was her breaking point but for me the victim side of the equation namely the ability of the victims to take back the abusers after some truly horrific occurrences is yet to be shown. 😊


Have to say that I love digging in to aspects of the show with somebody whose views are as well put as yours!
😃
Edited by darlunia - 14 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".