JYRG Thread No 16...Julun Yeti Reshimgathi

First Previous

Page

119

Next Last

Frequent Posters

ITgirl

@ITgirl

Voyager

Posted: 10 years ago

#71

@NJ,

Quite nice of you to say what you felt now after watching episode 👍🏼

And I really like and appreciate when people freely honestly comment about what they feel instead of reacting based on what majority said or reacting based on who said instead of what's said 😊

Regarding my comment on Megh's behavior in kitchen today, I was not blaming actor/character but was hoping for more convincing reason for Megh to feel sad about Mai's behavior...

If she would have acted normally with them and even if then ladies's responses were formal, then that message would have been more convincing from my POV..😊

So if she herself is shown worried, tensed (which she is actually in her mind but then she is not hiding it either in front of the entire family) same vibes are spread and echo back..

Edited by ITgirl - 10 years ago

Quote

ITgirl

@ITgirl

Voyager

Posted: 10 years ago

#72

Aditya character was shown out of his character in the past and I had objected to it then..

1>During ...Helping AN during hospitalization was kinda OK on human grounds but when AN left by himself from the hospital there wasn't any need for Aditya and Mai to become that crazy worrying about him...It was OTT

2>During... Aditya's stand to help Chitra out of way by hiding the truth from family in spite of Megh warning him..His unnecessary touchy convos with Chitra...

In fact that overall Chitra track itself was simply unbelievable and totally unconvincing ..

Right from every desai member worrying about her constantly, Meghana's MAHAN ness to treat her like a phoolpakharu in spite of knowing Chitra is all behind Aditya... Overall bakwas track and totally ruined the show...

But this time I am not finding Aditya's stand as adamant so far. 😊

I feel actually he could sense that Megh has somehow inside wish to help AN, she is in guilt pain but she is hesitant to speak about it openly with him.

Megh character is shown as a girl who thinks about family emotions more than her own wish..

(Remember her dialog from AD MD first meeting.. Mala konala dukhavun swatachya manacha karayla nahi avadat)

Aditya is not forcing her but helping her to speak her mind by assuring her that he is there to support her.

He wants to see his wife out of that hidden pain, plus his own guilt and wish to see AN happy..

And its quite believable because from day 1 he is shown as quite sensitive,caring husband who understands Megh's unsaid emotions just by hearing her voice or looking at her eyes ..

So I am really liking his current stand and finding it well within his character graph 👍🏼

Looking forward and hoping to see how this track gets handles maturely and sensibly 😊

Of course needless to say its my point of view and I don't expect everyone has to agree to it!

(This was / is and always will be applicable to all my posts )

Let's all enjoy our favorite show with our individual prospective 😊

Edited by ITgirl - 10 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

kamalsh56

@kamalsh56

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

#73

@Nachiket I disagree about Mai behaving well yesterday. No doubt she attempted to talk to MD but surely she has seen how stressed out MD is and the reason for it too. Rather than abandoning her (and saying she is not taking food now and has a headache and creating more tension for MD)if she had just put her arm around MD I think MD would have broken down and told her about her predicament. Remember that Mai who consoled MD in the angan? Where was that Mai?
@ITG, When people are under stress the family members gather together to indicate to them that they are not alone. Yesterday Mai and Vijaya just abandoned her giving vague excuses. It is but natural for MD now to feel isolated.
That's my POV.

Edited by kamalsh56 - 10 years ago

Quote

ITgirl

@ITgirl

Voyager

Posted: 10 years ago

#74

@Kamal,

What I think is, Mai is also not in good state of mind herself, she is worried and tensed too.

One can better console other disturbed person if he/she himself is calm and in complete piece of mind.

Also Mai might have expectation from MD to share her tension freely ?

Mai in self tensed mood might be hesitant to and not comfortable to initiate that conversation with Megh as its indeed delicate topic?

But its early to say about Mai's stand in all this from today's episode

Today's reaction from everyone was as expected shocked and confused, everyone is still figuring out the consequences of the news as per their own characteristics, IQ..

Nana's composed reaction and related thought process

Archu's instant spontaneous ,no second thought reaction

Vijaya's follower reaction (Either Mai or Amit)

Amit's practical reaction

Aditya's well thought reaction

Mai's confused stand after Archu's burst and yet to discuss with Nana

Aso, Done with my posts quota, exceeded today, advance compensated for my upcoming absence 😉

Enjoy and have good fun JYRG time folks 😊

Edited by ITgirl - 10 years ago

Quote

dipalimanish

@dipalimanish

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

#75

Saw the episode today. Excellent episode, emotional and full of tension, which was anyway expected.

Considering Nana was the first one who had recovered in peti prakaran, Nana supporting ADs decision is understandable.

Archus loud reaction was surprising. Is she the same Archu who had not gone to hospital during AN hospitalization, because MD should not feel that Archu has come to keep an eye on her. Recently I had thought that Archus character has mellowed down a lot.

Vijaya took a stand on her own today saying we can not ask him to move out once we have given him place. But she is worried about Babajis reaction, which is understandable.

Mai being in this state understandable. During hospitalization AN was away from house. Here though she trusts MD, she is tensed because he is in Dwadi.

Kitchen scene between MD, Mai and Vijaya was good. Considering all are in state of shock, everyones reactions were correct.

Amit still not has reacted on this but I think he will be on AD and Nanas side.

AD-MD scene and their respective reactions on this situation were excellent. MD scared and feeling awkward in this situation. AD totally composed.

MD is right in her place to have such feelings about this situation. More than herself, she is thinking about Dfamily. Her stand was same in AN hospitalization, we will not go against family.

AD in his place is correct but he also needs to understand reactions of MD and his family members.

Excellent acting by all actors today.

I liked the precap, AD without disclosing ANs real connection with AD-MD in front of Anjali, trying to make AN comfortable.

AD che kes aata Vijaya evadhe honar thodya divasat. 😆

Edited by dipalimanish - 10 years ago

Quote

kamalsh56

@kamalsh56

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

#76

Originally posted by: ITgirl
Nana's composed reaction and related thought process Archu's instant spontaneous ,no second thought reaction
Vijaya's follower reaction (Either Mai or Amit)
Amit's practical reaction
Aditya's well thought reaction
Mai's confused stand after Archu's burst and yet to discuss with Nana

Agree with your analysis. I will be waiting for early disclosure by AD/Nana their plan to everyone so that MD is not blamed for the situation.
You have not mentioned MD's reaction. I would say it was absolutely normal. Her stand has been consistent in every crisis---- I don't want to hurt the feelings of my family at any cost.
I still think Mai erred. Even if she was confused she could have shown some feelings for the upset MD. A small gesture like patting her cheek or patting her head would have been sufficient to restore MD's confidence immensely. I think Mai's motherly instincts should have overpowered her confusion or whatever (unless she doubted MD's intentions).
Aso. I rest my case.

Edited by kamalsh56 - 10 years ago

Quote

dipalimanish

@dipalimanish

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

#77

Kamal, Mai is worried only because he is in Dwadi. Also this is her initial reaction where she doesn't know what to think or say on this difficult situation. I guess she will be normal after having discussion with Nana on this.

Quote

kamalsh56

@kamalsh56

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

#78

Originally posted by: dipalimanish
Kamal, Mai is worried only because he is in Dwadi. Also this is her initial reaction where she doesn't know what to think or say on this difficult situation. I guess she will be normal after having discussion with Nana on this.

Really hope so. I don't want a protracted peti prakaran again with MD having to defend her stand on her own with AD passively looking on.

Quote

dipalimanish

@dipalimanish

Rocker

Posted: 10 years ago

#79

Originally posted by: kamalsh56

Really hope so. I don't want a protracted peti prakaran again with MD having to defend her stand on her own with AD passively looking on.

No Kamal, I dont think anything like peti prakaran will happen now except for Babaji and Archu. Babaji is going to panic for sure and if we look at him from angle that he is MDs father, then his reaction, even if its going to be loud, will be justified. No father will want his daughter to go thru such difficult situation. I dont think he will react like hospitalization time but will panic surely. Reg Archu I am surprised. Archu saying that once MD knew that Anki is AN, she should have told NM immediately, shows Archu doesn't trust MD. Archu should understand that in a situation like this the only person MD will turn to is AD.

Edited by dipalimanish - 10 years ago

Quote

Nachiketj

@Nachiketj

Trailblazer

Posted: 10 years ago

#80

Originally posted by: kamalsh56
@Nachiket I disagree about Mai behaving well yesterday. No doubt she attempted to talk to MD but surely she has seen how stressed out MD is and the reason for it too. Rather than abandoning her (and saying she is not taking food now and has a headache and creating more tension for MD)if she had just put her arm around MD I think MD would have broken down and told her about her predicament. Remember that Mai who consoled MD in the angan? Where was that Mai?
.

@Kamal, Mai didnt abandon MD...it was shown from evrybodys POV yest what evry1 is thinking...due to guilt of creating a tensed atmosphere in the family 1nce again due to her past, MD is under the impression Mai and Vijaya avoided to talk to her...

Mai tried to talk,she didnt behave with MD like khadus saasu asking her to leave the kitchen as Vijaya and she can take care of the cooking...neither did she imdtly say once MD entered to Vijaya, I am going or smethng like that..

rem guys Mais first reaction for MDs past earlier too was diff than Nanas..now also she seems to be worried for her son...

Now she and Nana will have a chat..and Nana will tell Mai u shud stand firmly with ur DIL...