Things that just make no sense.

Sugar_21 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
Okay so, there are a bunch of things that make no sense at all about this daily soap. I do enjoy watching it, but like I said, some things are so senseless that I completely have to switch off my thinking brain before watching this soap. Here they are:

If Madhurima is so jealous, possessive and overprotective, how in the world could she let Aditya live and make a baby with another woman? This despite the fact that Shikha was killed (at least in her eyes), but still he had a connection with Shikha, he did get physical with her. How can an intolerably jealous, doubting wife let that happen? She wasn't shown in those 2 years interfering at all (except one phone call, I think). That's beyond comprehension.

Another thing, how on earth is Samira getting all her financing done from? Even I'd like to know. She has a house, a car, 50 lakhs to give to her blackmailer. money, money...that's enigmatic. And, if Neeraj did something...like a robbery to assist with the finances, why isn't he being chased by the legal system?

Next, why were we kept completely and utterly oblivious to Shikha alias Samaira's singing talent? Did she just wake up one day after the tragedy with new vocal cords to assist her in taking her revenge? That makes sense. -_-

Also, why is Samaira's singing talent given so much importance when she is not even a star. We only know that most singers in India are playback singers, they are not too well known nor are they remunerated like actors. Its sad, but its the truth. And, we have plenty of singing talent in the country...so many reality shows showcasing wonderful vocals, but very few of them get a chance to make it big. Considering this reality, its a bit odd to see Samaira being so pampered despite the fact that Madhu hates her. And, we all know that Jagannath label is suppose to be huge, so why on earth would they bend down in front of an ordinary girl who isn't even a star. And, where does Samaira's fan base stem from? She is a new singer, so how can she have fans so quickly? ...that also with one song "main naa bhoolungi". The entire hoopla around Samaira being the FACE of Jagannath label, the company giving her a break and therefore garnering publicity doesn't make too much sense. I mean big celebs get replaced overnight, so how can Samaira (without any background or establishment) be so important?

How did Samaira come into being? How did an ex con (Neeraj) and Shikha (declared dead) override visa officials. Aditya called up for a check on Samaira's visa verification or something and she was declared to be NRI.

Samaira being clingy doesn't make sense. Aditya seems disinterested generally.

So ya, its big things like these that just make the soap an unconvincing one. I suppose if there was some story line to explain these things or if the soap showed us the "making" of Samaira...like her transformation from Shikha to Samaira and the actually planning plot then it would have been more convincing. Also, the singing thing doesn't make any sense, she should have gained entry into the Jagannath family or business through a more suitable domain.
Edited by Sugar_21 - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

8

Views

1.2k

Users

6

Likes

30

Frequent Posters

BinKuchKahe. thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
My answer to your questions
1. Maddy is overprotective & jealous. Yes. But she never saw Shikha as competition. Remember how she & Aditya used to make fun of Shikha as behenji. She would openly tease him about the time he had to spend with Shikha. A powerless & ugly girl. Samaira on the other hand is stylish & gorgeous as well as rich so there is competition & insecurity there.

2. Regarding the finance, even I want to know. But just because they haven't revealed anything doesn't mean its a blooper. I suspect Neeraj has some means to get the money. A few days back he was the one who arranged 50lakhs to give to the blackmailer & Shikha was unaware of that. He has some secret up his sleeve i think.

3. Hmmm well she probably never experimented her voice. You know she could have discovered in the 6 months that she can sing. After all, she couldn't come back as a writer. That would be suspicious. So during the 6 months, she could have gotten training from the music director who recommended her to Maddy. I don't see this as a blooper.

4. See they launched her & she became a star overnight. So they made her the face of Jagannath group. She's just started & if they were to replace her so soon, it will cause controversy & bad attention to their brand. Her singing talent is an added asset that they used not only to kickstart their music label but also for her to perform on occassions. The main thing is her face.

5. Regarding the documents, in india if you give money u can create fake documents. Remember the police inspector that agreed to help them because Aditya killed Inspector Naik. He helped them with the documents as well. As long as u give money & get connected with somone, your fake documents can be registered as real. Its damn easy in India.

6. I agree with you that Samaira is being clingy but I disagree that Aditya isn't interested. He is clearly enjoying this chase but he is exercising caution due to Maddy.

Having disagreed with you on most points, I do agree that Shikha's transformation to Samaira was something they should have shown. I read in Vikas's interview recently that this is a 6 months show probably that's why the pace is pretty fast.
Edited by prc_fan1 - 11 years ago
Minionite thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
These are just a long list of bloopers to be added to all the bloopers. I've never been fully satisfied with the transformation and now this revenge track just seems to be going too slowly. Why is Shikha hell bent on making Aditya fall for her? She's gotten into their house now she should try and get the property in her name. Then maybe she can play a trick and get Aditya to reveal everything. It's like they're making a long version of Khoon Bhari Maang with bloopers galore.
Sugar_21 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: KhotaSikaShreya

These are just a long list of bloopers to be added to all the bloopers. I've never been fully satisfied with the transformation and now this revenge track just seems to be going too slowly. Why is Shikha hell bent on making Aditya fall for her? She's gotten into their house now she should try and get the property in her name. Then maybe she can play a trick and get Aditya to reveal everything. It's like they're making a long version of Khoon Bhari Maang with bloopers galore.


@bold: I know! I don't understand that either. They could have introduced something innovative instead of using the overused "make the guy fall for you and then dump him" or I don't know how exactly the track is going to go, but ideally she should be more focused on evidence gathering rather than trying to lure Aditya.
BinKuchKahe. thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
^
I completely agree with you on that point. She should focus on gathering evidence against Aditya using the help of Jai & Arya rather than make him fall for her than dump him. Even though I am kind of enjoying the chase & the whole seducing game, I'd like it if they also showed her trying to find out about why they want Manav as well. Like maybe Madhu can't conceive so she can use some trick to get a medical report etc. or whatever reason there is.

Edited by prc_fan1 - 11 years ago
silvermoonlight thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
Biggest Blooper: Why does Samaira dress like someone who has no clue about fashion, makeup and accessories?
BinKuchKahe. thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 11 years ago
#7
@silvermoonlight
I like her wadrobe :)
ShiningHearts thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#8
Hmmm... n aditya gestures 2wards samaira 😕 switch button on n off on n off is he really instrested in her r not im nt getting it...
Edited by --kabira-- - 11 years ago
-Rani thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 11 years ago
#9
@TM - Finally the most sensible and logical post I have read in this forum👏👏👏

I am also bothered with those questions that you have raised in your topic. Hope CVs are reading this and making some corrections to the show or else this will be another show going down the hill with great concept, but very poor execution


Edited by -Rani - 11 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".