Queries to Mr. Utkarsh Naithini/ DT Nt pg 6

Rudrasa999 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#1

Usually when we write a report or do a presentation or held a seminar in workplace , college etc., we'd be asked to provide bibliography to show from which sources we got informations (like from which books, materials, internet web links etc.)

Similarly would it be possible for us to know which source does Mr. Utkarsh Naithini use to write his scripts ???

Would anyone like to know the same ? As audiences we have every rights to KNOW .

Because after watching this lakshmi and narkasur circus drama , I searched a lot in google. And I could nowhere find any such information on narkasur capturing Lakshmi and also about narkasur getting five boons from Lord Shiva !

So I'm very much interested to know which scared texts does Utkarsh refer for writing such unimaginable stories .

Want to know in which puran or sacred writings, the following stuffs are mentioned :

Kamadev re-incarnating as Bandasur ;

MahaKaali giving boon to Goddess Ganga of purifying sins as Ganga is already known for that ! ;

MahaKaali battling with tarakasur along with Lord Kartikeya ;

Connection between NavDurgas and Chakras ;

Asuras beating the **** out of Goddess Narsinghi Devi ;

Goddess Lakshmi and Goddess Saraswati being over-powered by asuras .

May be few of the above points are written out of pure imagination to highlight the significance of Goddess MahaKaali but most of them really need some explanantion.

As a noble and a loyal viewer of the show I think I have every right to question and demand the sources behind the story of this serial .

Anybody interested as well ???

Would Mr. Utkarsh Naithini act professional and be generous enough to provide us that ?

Or is he writing his own "bhagavatham" by having a divya drishti or so ???

Because he can't get away just like that by claiming every rubbish he writes as "creative liberty !

If he provides at least one scared and authentic texts from which he channels all his writings , then I'll try not to complain and criticize much .

If not then he has no other way except to accept that he's distorting the divinity of our puranas .

Edited by Rudrasa999 - 7 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

53

Views

2.8k

Users

14

Likes

82

Frequent Posters

Rihan05 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#2
IF Only Utkarsh Naithani would have answered these unsolved Qs which even Google can't answer 🤣
BTW DKDM was also written by him there he showed Lord Shiv helping Karthikeya battling Tarakasur whereas here he is showed Mahakali helping Karthik; šŸ˜† he is contradicting himself..
Btw when was this shown I'm not able to recall
(Connection between NavDurgas and Chakras) ??
Rudrasa999 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: Rihan05

IF Only Utkarsh Naithani would have answered these unsolved Qs which even Google can't answer 🤣
BTW DKDM was also written by him there he showed Lord Shiv helping Karthikeya battling Tarakasur whereas here he is showed Mahakali helping Karthik; šŸ˜† he is contradicting himself..
Btw when was this shown I'm not able to recall
(Connection between NavDurgas and Chakras) ??


Yes even I mentioned about the DKDM disorted version in another thread .
Here's the copy-paste of my post šŸ˜› :
" Brahma and Vishnu are not some devas .

All Shiva-Vishnu-Brahma are Mahadevas and Parvati-Lakshmi-Saraswati are Mahadevis .

Once when I went to a Lord Narasimha temple , I noticed when the temple priest was doing pooja to the Narasimha idol and singing hymns and slokas he mentioned him as Devadi Dev Mahadev .

So yes all Shiva, Brahma and Vishnu are Lords of the demi gods ( devas )

And just like Parvati , Mata Lakshmi too has the fierce Kali and Durga energy in her but she won't use her destructive powers unnecessarily as she's very much centred, well balanced and stable like Lord Vishnu .

So it was absolutely a nonsensical thing to show Mata Lakshmi as some ordinary Devi and running scared from asurs 🤢

Also in DKDM when they showed Ramayan they had made it all about Shiva . It was shown like Shiva making Vishnu to take Ram avatar and Shiva instructing, ordering and teaching Lord Ram which made Guru Vasishta totally useless in the story . In real story Mata Kausalya was a huge devotee of Lord Vishnu and she was blessed by the Lord that she would get himself as her son. But in DKDM Ramayan it was shown like Mata Kausalya was a Shiv devotee and Shiva blessing her that Narayan would incarnate as her son . And then Mata Lakshmi was shown being summoned by Parvati to incarnate as Sita and Mata Lakshmi was taking Shiv-Parvati's permission to take her avatar .

It was quiet distasteful . My mother is a staunch Shiv devotee and she herself found it awkward .

Initially when the Ramayan story started Shivji says it's Narayan's leela and he won't unnecessarily interfere in it and later it seemed weird how he was trying to control Lord RAM .

Shiva gave boon to Guru Vasishta that he will get Narayan as his student in his first human avatar . I was like why Shiva decides everything for Vishnu . Don't Vishnu has right to choose what he wants and what he wants to do in his avatar .

Then Lord Ram was hesitating to kill taraka and again Shiv-Parvati had to come and persuade Lord Ram to do so . Then what's the role of Vishwamitra here ?????????

Lord Ram hesitating to lift Shiv danush in Sita swayamwar and so Lord Shiva appears in front of him to convince him to lift the danush. My mom literally got fed up with that track .

People who are fully aware of Ramayan story must watch DKDM Ramayan. They'll get to witness the heights of distortion .

They didn't leave any single chance to make Lord Shiva look more superior in any possible ridiculous manner !!!

Now I totally regret watching DKDM as I'm not able to see Shiv-Parvati in highest state that I used to see before .

I'm hoping may be this Mahakali show at least don't go to such extremes to highlight or glorify the lead character .

Another manipulation is story of Lord Kartikeya vs tarakasur . Yes Lord Shiva and Mata Parvati guided , taught and trained Kartikeya to fight but they never interfered in the battle . The vel (weapon of Skanda ) was presented to Kartikeya by Durga but she never involved in the battle .

But DKDM which is Shiva-centric showed Kartikeya defeating tarakasur with the help of Lord Shiva where as Mahakali which is Kali-centric showed Kartikeya defeating tarakasur with the help of Ma Kali .

The funny thing is same person wrote screenplay for both shows šŸ˜†.

After seeing the tarakasur vadh in Mahakali I was imagining what would it be like if this writer writes script for show on Lord Ganesha 😃. He would have kept tarakasur alive till Ganesh was born and showed like Kartikeya killing tarakasur with the help of Lord Ganesh šŸ˜† .

I hope cvs don't showcase Ramayan otherwise they might show like Parvati or Kali dominating Lakshmi and order Sita to take the badrakali form of her . That would make half of the audiences to give up on the show . Who knows ??? They might even show like Kali instructing Lord Ram on how to fight with Ravan or she might herself kill ravan like tarakasur .

Like for example : Lord RAM shoots an arrow towards ravan and the arrow might suddenly turn into mahakaali and tears ravan apart 🤣 .

The writer must try to understand the sentiments of general viewers and stop using other characters (especially Godly figures ) to his own advantage .

Otherwise the show will just loose loyal viewers . "


HE even wrote for Siya ke Ram show. Although I like that show very much, I didn't like how he ruined the relationship of between SiyaRam and Lakshman & Lord Ram and Hanuman .


And yes in that Matsya Kanya avatar story where Lord Shiva as Ashutosh explains about NavDurgas , he relates each Durga form to a chakra ( energy centre ) .


Rudrasa999 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#4
Thank you 😊 .
I'm just working on posting my queries to UN on twitter and demand an explanation .
If anybody's interested can join me .

Edited by Rudrasa999 - 7 years ago
Quin8 thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#5
Also Ashutosh story wasn't based on any puranas ?
He altered Matsya story
Rudrasa999 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: Quin8

Also Ashutosh story wasn't based on any puranas ?
He altered Matsya story

Yup, it was very much evident .
I personally felt like that whole track was only for entertainment .
rsnarula67 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: Rudrasa999

Thank you 😊 .
I'm just working on posting my queries to UN on twitter and demand an explanation .
If anybody interested can join me .



I am not active on twitter, but I am with you.


Rudrasa999 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: rsnarula67



I am not active on twitter, but I am with you.



THANK YOU 😊
SriMaatangi thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 7 years ago
#9
I was planning to create a Twitter account anyway :) I will join you in questioning UN.
Rudrasa999 thumbnail
7th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 7 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: KrishnaPriyaa

I was planning to create a Twitter account anyway :) I will join you in questioning UN.


THANK YOU @KrishnaPriyaa 😊 I have one that I created a month ago or so which I rarely use šŸ˜†

Here's the link of my twitter account :

https://twitter.com/NiviRoudraya999


Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".