Bhim knew about Karna being his brother...!!!!!

sayee thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#1
Guys I was just reading MT Vasudevan Nair's Novel Bhimsen there it was mentioned that during the war itself bheem knew about karna being his brother...😲

could anybody just clear my confusion...by referring to other texts...

here is its extract...


"I returned to my lodge after offering prayers at the yagna shala and

found Visokan waiting for me with the kind of metal body armor I hate

to wear.

People always speak of my strength but in my own mind, it was speed

that was my greatest asset " and going to war in a bulky metal

breastplate and arm guards was not conducive to the kind of quick

movement that gave me my edge.

"What happened to my usual armor, the one of cowhide?"

"Have you heard anything of Karna's secret weapon?" Visokan asked

seemingly at a tangent. "Some say it was gifted to him by Indra, king

of the gods."

Not for the first time, I marveled internally at his ability to keep

abreast of all that was going on. There was no one in the vicinity when

Dhristadyumna had asked me to challenge Karna, and yet here was

my charioteer discreetly hinting that he knew what was in the wind.

I shrugged. They also say Arjuna had weapons gifted by Indra, by

Shiva, by Agni and Vaayu and other gods - stories that we had

carefully spread through our own balladeers and spies as part of the

tactic of demoralizing the enemy.

It was, I knew, perfectly possible that Karna had some kind of special

weapon " the best warriors always save such for special enemies, or

for those dire situations when they find themselves in trouble.

I had the iron javelins made to my specifications; Arjuna had several

special arrows that I knew of. It would have been surprising if Karna,

who had been preparing for this war for a long time, didn't have some

secrets up his sleeve as well.

"The story is it was actually created for him by a master engineer in

Anga," Visokan told me. "I haven't been able to get much detail yet,

but from what I hear I think it is a javelin, fired from some sort of

mechanical contraption anchored in his chariot. Those who speak of it

call it the Shakti."

Possibly, I thought, a version of Arjuna's Pasupathasthra " which, we

had got the balladeers to sing, was gifted to him by Shiva himself. In

actual fact, Mayan had fashioned for my brother a special arrow with a

diamond tip capable of penetrating any armor. Just below the

detachable tip, the wood was carved in the shape of a hollow bulge

into which snake venom was filled before the head was screwed back

on. The arrowhead was fashioned in such a way as to break off inside

the body " you couldn't pull it out, and the venom would do the rest.

"Very effective, but you can only prepare so many of these," Arjuna

once explained while showing off the weapons he had acquired on his

travels. "The venom loses its potency within hours, so you need to fill

it afresh each time - and you can't go around with a basket of snakes

in your chariot to draw venom from!"

Karna's weapon was likely a spear, a larger weapon built on the same

lines. In any case it was all speculation, and I didn't see much sense in

getting worked up about it.

"I was just thinking that maybe he will have to use that weapon

today," Visokan said. "I heard you are going to challenge Karna to

battle..."

Ignoring his circuitous hints, I strapped on my favorite cowhide

breastplate and arm guards and went out to supervise how my

weapons were arranged on the deck of the chariot.

Dhristadyumna's guess proved correct: Drona arrayed the Kauravas in

the ultra-defensive Kamalavyuh, with each petal of the lotus formation

led by a master warrior and comprising all three wings of the army.

Jayadratha had been secreted in the center of the formation, the bud.

The advantage was that no matter which point Arjuna attacked, the

other petals would instantly close, creating a tight defensive shield

around the target.

In the event I didn't have to challenge Karna " it was he who found

me as I drove diagonally across the field, heading towards where

Arjuna was battling mightily to break through. An arrow flecked with

peacock feathers embedded itself deep in my flagpole as a sign of his

challenge; as I turned to confront him, two crescent-headed arrows

pierced my breastplate.

To the acharyas, I did not rate as an archer on the same scale as

Arjuna and Karna, but I had one thing going for me: power. And

importantly, Visokan knew my strengths as well as I did. He needed no

prompting; swiftly, he backed up the horses and drove away at a

diagonal, putting distance between us.

"Coward," Karna's voice cut across the din. "Stand and fight!"

An instant later he was staring down at his bow, which I had cut in

two. From this greater distance, the power of my arms and shoulders

gave me the edge " I could shoot arrows further, and with greater

force, than Karna.

I had a stock of specially prepared arrows " longer and stronger than

the conventional ones, these were much harder to draw and release,

but their heft gave them additional range and power the conventional

arrows Karna was shooting at me did not have.

Realizing the danger, he kept trying to close the distance; with

effortless skill, Visokan danced our chariot out of the way, maintaining

the distance and constantly maneuvering so I had a clear view of my

target.

I wanted to tire Karna out before I closed with him. My arrows

thudded repeatedly into his breastplate and onto the wheels of his

chariot; his armor was strong, but the repeated impact of the arrows

created an additional physical hardship for him.

Thrice in succession, I cut his bow in half. As he bent to pick up a

fourth, I noticed the first signs that he was tiring, and pressed my

attack harder. A lucky shot took him dead center in the chest; he

reeled, and grabbed hastily at his flagpole for support.

My time, I realized, had come. I picked up the arrow I had been saving

" a long, extra thick one fitted with a crescent-shaped head and

flecked with pigeon feathers " and carefully fitted it to the string.

Karna fired a volley at me; I shrugged them off and, as he bent to

replenish his quiver, gave the word: "Now!"

I expected Visokan to spring the horses forward at speed to reduce the

distance; I was poised to send the arrow straight at Karna's throat. To

my surprise, Visokan did the exact opposite " he drove diagonally

away, putting even greater distance between us.

The moment was lost, and I was furious.

"You cannot kill him " it would be a huge sin," Visokan said.

"He is your brother!"

The bow fell from my suddenly nerveless fingers; my limbs felt

paralyzed. I willed myself to bend and pick up my bow again, but

collapsed instead to the deck of the chariot, reeling under a shock far

harder to absorb than the worst Karna had thrown at me.

"Karna is your mother's eldest son." Visokan's words came to me as if

from a great distance. I pulled myself back onto to my feet " and

recoiled as Karna, who seemed to have gotten a second wind, drove

his chariot close to mine and poked me in the chest with the tip of his

bow.

"Fat fool!" he sneered. "You are only fit to wrestle in the mud with

people like you " don't ever make the mistake of thinking you are an

archer."

Words were always Karna's sharpest weapons. He appeared to have

forgotten that he had been just an instant away from death " or

perhaps he hadn't realized the extent of the danger he was in.

"I promised your mother I would kill only one of her sons, and you are

not him. Get out of my sight before I change my mind." With

indescribable contempt, he flicked me in the face with the disengaged

string of his bow and drove away without a backward glance.

Around me the battle surged, but my senses refused to take any of it

in.

Visokan drove away to the edge of the field and, finding a quiet

corner, stopped the chariot.

"It was when I was coming from Kasi to join you," he said. "Since

Queen Balandhara and your son Sarvadhan were with us, our force

was travelling in slow stages and at one point, we made camp on the

banks of the Ganga.

"I never meant to eavesdrop," he said. "It was early morning and I

was heading to the river for a bath. I saw your mother by the river

bank and went towards her, meaning to pay my respects. It was when

I got closer that I saw the man who was seated, in padmasan, before

her.

I was unmarried, my child " what else could I do?', Visokan heard my

mother say.

"Karna laughed, and there was a wealth of bitterness in his laugh, a

world of hurt," Visokan told me.

I was brought up by a charioteer and his wife, and I always was, and

always will be, their son,' Karna had told my mother. I will not now

give up the identity I have lived under all these years, I will not give

up those who were my friends when your sons taunted me as an

outcast and you stood silently by, never once giving me the protection

of your name.

But for you, I will do this " I will only kill one of your sons. Whatever

happens, Queen " I wish I could call you mother but I just cannot

think of you that way " whatever happens, you will have five sons.'

My mind whirled with the possibilities. Karna the eldest Pandava "

rightful heir to the throne of Hastinapura?! How vastly different things

could have been...

Every trick, every stratagem Duryodhana had launched against us had

been with the knowledge of Karna's backing " if Karna, Arjuna and I

stood together, would our cousins ever have dared treat us the way

they did?

Would they have dared deny us our due, knowing that the three of us

in alliance could have annihilated them in an instant?

The fatal game of dice that had led to this disastrous war " would it

have happened? Karna, not Yudhishtira, would as the eldest have

received the challenge, and by no stretch of the imagination did I see

him accepting, and falling into Sakuni's trap as Yudhishtira had done.

And the Swayamvar? There was no doubt in my mind, as I recalled the

events of that day, that Karna would have hit the target " I still

recalled vividly the skill with which he had strung the bow, before

Draupadi contemptuously rejected him as a candidate for her hand. If

only my mother had spoken out, if only she had told us the truth, it

would have been Karna who won her hand...

"Not now!" Visokan said, jolting me out of my reverie. "Dusk is

approaching... Arjuna will need help..."

He raced the chariot across the field and through the massed Kaurava

forces, the swords attached to the hubs of my chariot cutting brutally

through flesh as we dashed headlong towards Arjuna. I grabbed my

mace and vaulted out of the chariot, needing the bloody immediacy of

hand to hand combat to overcome the demons of the mind.

Karna " the eldest Pandava. My brother and my king...

Ranging ahead of Arjuna's chariot, I killed mindlessly, brutally, my

mace mechanically rising and falling, breaking limbs, crushing skulls as

I fought to clear a path for my brother. And yet, I thought, it was all

going to be too late " the sky was darkening around us; any minute

now the bugle would blow to signal dusk, and the end of hostilities.

Ahead of us, buffered by a massed array of archers and swordsmen, I

could make out the chariots of Karna, Duryodhana, Sakuni, Dushasana

and Drona. Somewhere in their midst would be Jayadratha, totally

insulated from Arjuna's revenge.

My brother would lose " there was no way we could bridge the

distance in time. Arjuna would die on Abhimanyu's funeral pyre - and

with that, our hopes of winning the war would go up in flames.

The sky went dark.

A massive roar went up from the Kaurava ranks. The rank and file

threw their swords and bows and arrows up in the air; ahead of me I

saw Drona, Duryodhana and Karna join the cheering throngs.

I glanced over my shoulder at Arjuna. Krishna had let the reins drop;

on the deck of the chariot I saw Arjuna, head hanging in despair,

slowly unbuckle his quiver and throw it down.

"Get in!" Visokan's voice in my ear startled me out of my stupor.

"It is not over yet," he said as I vaulted into the chariot. "Look up " it

is the surya grahan, the eclipse..."

Realization hit me like a jolt " so that was why Krishna had spent the

night closeted with the astrologers. Krishna bringing the chariot to a

halt... Arjuna's seeming despair... it was all part of a plan, and I didn't

need anyone to tell me it had originated in Krishna's fertile brain.

I grabbed up my bow and quiver; even as I straightened, Visokan

yelled "Now!"

I fought to balance myself as the chariot jumped ahead, smashing

through the celebrating Kaurava hordes. But quick though Visokan

was, Krishna was unimaginably quicker. The white horses of my

brother's chariot passed me in a blur; Krishna manipulated the team

with extraordinary skill as he cut right across the field, towards the

celebrating generals who were crowding around the triumphant

Jayadratha.

Visokan accelerated, staying close to Arjuna's flank. I trained my bow

on the Kaurava generals " it would be cruel irony if Arjuna managed

to fulfill his vow only to be cut down by the others.

The sky cleared.

Just ahead of me and to my right, Arjuna stood tall on the deck of his

chariot, the light glinting off the diamond tip of his arrow. The twanggg

of his release sounded above the din of the as-yet unsuspecting

Kauravas; I watched the flight of the arrow as it shot across space

and, with unerring aim, smashed deep into Jayadratha's throat.

I heard the triumphant notes of Devadutt, Arjuna's conch; an instant

later, Krishna's Panchajanya joined in.

Dusk fell. The trumpets of the heralds blared out, a high note dropping

off in a diminuendo to signal the cessation of hostilities.

As the flames of Abhimanyu's pyre burnt bright against the sky, I

stood looking out across the river into the darkness beyond.

Somewhere out there, in one of the lodges reserved for the

womenfolk, sat my mother.

I wondered what she was doing, what she was thinking. She would, I

knew, be calm, tranquil even in the face of the news of death and

devastation ferried over by our messengers.

Maybe she was talking to Draupadi, or to Balandhara who she had

invited to stay with her. Or maybe she was with Uttara, consoling the

young princess even as the flames consumed her husband's body on

the other side of the river.

My mother " who, married when young to an impotent man, had

manged to produce three children.

My mother " who, even before her marriage, had managed to have a

son she had told no one about.

Who knew how many more secrets lay buried in her heart?"


PS :: for everybody's information Viskoan is Bheem's charioteer & his second best confidante after arjun...


PS :: This book is from the pov of bheem...

Edited by sayee - 11 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

5

Views

5.5k

Users

6

Likes

17

Frequent Posters

rainfire thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#2
This is a novel written by a writer who wanted to imagine Bhim's prospective of Mahabharat. But Mahabharat is not a novel. Its the a huge part of Hindu religion. There is really no comparison.
p.s. The fact that the author of that novel thought that Bhim was not a big part of the real Mahabharat shows that he never bothered to actually understand it at all.
Edited by rainfire - 11 years ago
SplashRain thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#3
it just imagination of writer I guess, thanks for sharing
Rishi_ thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 11 years ago
#4
it seems to be an imagination of the author abt the proceedings of mahabharat from bhim's perspective.
it may not be necessarily true.

only kunti vyas bheeshma and mostly krishna vasudev knew abt it.
Vr15h thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 11 years ago
#5
Rishi is right. Stories like 'Sahadev knew' or 'Bhima knew' are figments of the imagination of various authors. Goodness knows why they come out w/ this.

Think about it. If the 4 Pandavas - BANS regarded Yudisthir as a father-figure & almost worshiped him, why wouldn't they do the same to Karna, if they knew? Yudisthir himself was mortified on knowing this after the war, and was afflicted w/ self-loathing as a result. Essentially, Yudisthir reacted in the same way to knowing that he had killed his elder brother Karna that BANS would have reacted had any of them killed him (Y) and then found out later.

Elder brothers were almost worshiped @ the time, no matter what their faults. Which is why Vikarna fought & died for Duryodhan, and the Pandavas didn't take action against Yudisthir (even though Bhima wanted to). So for Yudisthir, and indeed the rest of them, knowing that they had killed Karna was almost like finding out that they had unknowingly killed Pandu.

Seriously, authors should try and apply both logic, as well as a contemporaneous perspective to any story that they come out w/
riti4u thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 11 years ago
#6
This is just an imagination by author.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".