Created

Last reply

Replies

60

Views

4.8k

Users

40

Likes

205

Frequent Posters

suniks thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#31

Originally posted by: VictoriaHot

Your POV in your place, and agreeing on what you have to say on Paddy-Madhu-Shamshoo angle, i totally disagree on the cursing MB part.


No matter what your ice bricks are with your family , cursing them a lifetime of hell and being okay with it is not 'humane'. Madhubala may not be exactly Trishna's flesh and blood, but she is her sister. A girl your mother ran from Motihari to save, a girl you saw come into the world, a girl with whom you spent your best years... a girl you were bound to emotionally. You may end up hating her for some reason or the other, but if you would have ever loved her with an ounce of your heart, your throat would clog before the curses come out.

Being hurt and angry is one thing. Being cruel and heartless is another.Just like Paddy and Madhubala are not understanding Shamshoo's side which shockingly RK did, same way Trishna is not seeing Madhubala's side or her heart that is just trying to hope after it died.

If I am unhappy, it doesn't mean I take away someone else's right to be happy., That is sort of less than being even human.

My opinion.

Yes I agree, its not possible to curse unless you are a real bad human.
It got me thinking about my family. My dad had a bunch of greedy siblings who cheated him and never bothered to show their faces even when he passed away . Although it hurt like hell, yet none of us could actually curse them.
So I simply cant empathise with Trishna's perspective from any angle.
coolgal49 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#32
Trishna is justified in her anger here according to me.

Agree with the first point - about Padmini, Balraj and Shamsher. Padmini is just being silly in my opinion of living away from Malik and Trishna.

Second point - Yes, Trishna is selfish and she does not get it that Madhu married RK to save Malik...she still believes that Madhu put herself in such a position and Malik was in the hospital because of the stand that Madhu took against RK...you see..she is being very logical about this particular issue...because deep down she could not digest that Madhu who was not at all interested in movies got married to a superstar like RK, irrespective of the circumstances.

Thirdly, Trishna, as many of you have pointed out, has only seen RK being ruthless towards Madhu and still believes or is bent on believing that Madhu's marriage is a farce and nothing good will ever come of it ! So seeing Madhu and Pads talk about Madhu and RK actually falling in love with each other irked her and hit her where it hurt her ego the most...

Lastly, Madhu does not know the circumstances in her maternal home...this is the case with many indian families isn't it? ...and poor Madhu felt very bad for her...Trishna cursing her like that - well that was out of anger, frustration and also jealousy as well - lets not forget that!

Now coming to Madhu - She took a stand and paid for it with a humiliating marriage with RK - in the process she came to know that Mukund, for whom she took this step was not man enough to trust her and support her...She accepted her fate and started her married life shakily...and slowly when things were falling into place, Malik shoots RK. She is right in one thing - she forgave Malik as a daughter but not as a wife and he understands too...The timing of it all was awful...both for Madhu and RK.

What Trishna said will affect Madhu deeply and on the other side I am sure Dips would have irked RK as well...Now we have two emotionally drained characters...confessing their love to each other..but fearful of it as well ...

Hats off to the CVs again - They have etched out all the characters so far (except Kuku and Sikki Bhatia) quite well...

Looking forward to the rest of the week!

:)

TheDragonLady thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#33
yeh she is mad at padzz... is understandable... n yeh padz is being unreasonable...

but cursing sumone is sick... disgusting...

karma of life says... be gud with another human...

cursing sumone for lifetime.. is stupid...

no person in dis world has any right to hurt anybody...

she hating madz is done ... i mean thik hai yaar...

it so happened dat jo uske sapne the .. wo sab ab madz ka ho gaye hai.. toh uska rude behaviour is sumhow justifiable..

but cursing...no not never
QuintessentialI thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#34

Originally posted by: Athena90


So what if she asked her to drop the case when she got to know its RK? She had a dream and she was practical that it's not worth fighting against a superstar. And she placed her career ahead of some random guy they had no connection with? What's wrong with that?

She's telling Madhu to care for her family. She doesn't consider RK family. The same way she asked Madhu to care for family and withdraw the case against RK.



So if we all start bringing our career forward at the expense of someone's life who might die are we even fit enough to be called "humans" regardless I know the person or not ?

Also when Trishna had dreams to become an actress and flunked in studies , she misbehaved with each and every member ... that time she claimed Paddy , Madhu , everyone is her enemy !

A girl who is so self-centered suddenly talks of Family Happiness ? sorry indigestible !

she is Jealous of Madhu for good reason but well that does not certify her to curse !
gigo thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#35

Originally posted by: punam2712

THE CURSE IS A BIT TOO MUCH

BUT TRISHNA IS RIGHT
MADHU'S ONE ZIDD TO GO AGAINST RK FOR A STRANGER RUINED THEIR LIFE
AND NOW SHE WANTS TO PLAY HOUSE HOUSE WITH RK
SHE CAN FORGIVE RK FOR WHAT HE DID TO HER AND HER FAMILY BUT CANT FORGIVE MALIK FOR TRYING TO SAVE HER FROM A LOVELESS REVENGE MARRIAGE
MADHU HAS VERY QUICKLY FORGOTTEN THE WAY RK BEHAVED INITIALLY



Every body has a right to chose what they want to do ... Now what Madhu chose to do (to go against RK ) is right . she is one principled person ... and chose not to go against her conscious .

what ever happend now every thing is going alright ... she couldn't think once that 'the devil' Rk chose to set her father free ... even with all the evidences against him ??????😡
FireSafireFiree thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 8
Posted: 12 years ago
#36
really well said completly agree
LiveLifeInBliss thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 12 years ago
#37
Totally agree with your points but still blaming Madhu for everything is totally wrong! I mean she blamed Madhu for Mallik's beating by Rk's men and when Madhu got married to RK to save Mallik, she still blames her for every problems that arises after it! Like when Mallik went to jail, without knowing anything, she was just sure that it was Madhu's fault and kept on going with her rant.😡 I don't like people who just blames everything that's gone wrong on a single person all the time. Also, I've never seen Trishna acting like a big sister and thought of protecting her little sister or her family. No matter what the situation, she always made it about her.
sitakshii thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#38
I agree with Trishna ...but cursing Madhu that badly went over board and i hate Trishna for that 😡😡
sunflower52 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#39
Except for the cursing Madhu part I agree with the rest. No matter what you do not curse your own sister. Krishna's jealousy, insecurities plus with broken dreams have made her bitter. As through her broken glass she is seeing Madhu living her dream life.

Krishna will realize one day how lucky she was that she has such loving family and that when your dreams do not come true. God has better plans for her.

Madhu should forgive Malik fully and so should Padmini. After all if not for him both would be dead. They should not forget this ever.
Katyayani_devi thumbnail
IPL 2024 Participants Thumbnail IPL 2023 Participants Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 12 years ago
#40
different ppl react n act differently for same situation.ya trishna's condition is understandable eventhough she is not completely right. becos of rk-madhu her life dream is affected n family too affected. when rk's complicated character n his condition is understandable why not trishna. all can't be unaffected n act smooth n mahan even situations are rude n affecting their dreams n life. glad almost all characters in this show act as humans. suddenly her life dream affected n her loving family too affected with out her mistake, more she is shattered n frustrated becos of her career is affected, she is simple girl with dreams of her own n loving family. if cvs not planning her evil after sometime she will know madhu n everything will be fine. no one cares trishna now for her condition, she needs support to overcome it, pads n malik must think of trishna also n provide her support to over come the affect n move on if they think trishna also their child.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".