Episode Discussion: 18th Oct 2012

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

pippa

@pippa

Rocker

Posted: 12 years ago

#61

PreetD:

Isn't it hugely ironic that an out and out filmy serial has these beautiful touches of realism?

I agree with you that some of the situations and scenes are contrived but these beautiful moments more than make up for some of these glitches.

Quote

Tvbug2011

@tvbug2011

Dazzler

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#62

Originally posted by: 0-SD-0

tvbug,

Kind words from you. Makes me feel quite proud of myself. Thank you so much for reading and commenting. A long post carries so much risk of being taken as reference for later 😆 I was so so thinking...God! its so long..

SD

P.S: Pls can you give us a better name than tvbug to call you 😉 This place is becoming a club now and we almost hang out here in free time. 😆

Good morning, SD. 😊 Please call me Sabs. I was on a bit of a roll last night and quite embarrassed to see that I had three consecutive posts on the page. I've been meaning to respond to quite a few posts from the club for a while, but never quite seem to get around to it. So decided to just do it yesterday, and kinda flooded the thread. Thanks to you and the others for your kind tolerance.

Thanks for appreciating my comments - nice for any work (hard or not) to be acknowledged.😊 The length of your post was well deserved considering the relevance of the points you made and your insights. At no point was it laboured - more like packed with information. I couldn't do justice to it last night - it was just so insightful that it really needed mulling over. I am still considering the importance of the 'unsettling question' that you mention - in my quick scroll down the pages just now I see that someone has indeed picked up on it. I hope to comment on it at leisure.

And yes I am quite enjoying hanging out on this forum in the company of such good friends. 😊

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Shruti, Shru, shutu, frooti, DiDa

@HopelessLove

Explorer

Posted: 12 years ago

#63

Originally posted by: DovesView

SD: Loved your take today. Due to lack of time I have to keep it short and cannot dwell on detailed commenting on areas of your take I loved but then I just want to say that I loved the way you put things in perspective. Looks like episode quite moved you😉. I liked the episode more for RK yesterday (not for the drama with the knife and all), his expressions, hooded eyes when gauging at Dips for her bold claims, the obscure dialogs that were indirectly directed to his BIWI, throwing those important gazes at his wife at those right times during the dialogs giving an insight into his mind...awww... I just loved him. And Madhu, my darling, she was so cute. She portrayed her sense of displeasure at what she witnessed between the two of them was awesome. Her eyes speak a lot. DD kept her facial muscles so plain and unmoving and just let her eyes and slightly ajar mouth do the entire act. FABULOUS!!! Love VD and DD! Great actors.

dittoo!!! Just loved RK even more... and mainly loving the whole progress of the serial... yesterday was a very pivotal part of the serial ... I don't want them to be separated!!!!!!!!! :D

I got a heart-attack when rishu was mumbling in sleep and madhu was consoling him and when se calls him RK and he wakes up and sees madhu... how he just pushes her away... and then fainting again... thank god!! :D :D I did not want him to hurt madhu there... :(

Quote

Shruti, Shru, shutu, frooti, DiDa

@HopelessLove

Explorer

Posted: 12 years ago

#64

Hiii everyone!! last night I did not introduce myself here... I am SHRUTI... and totally crazy for this show.. especially RK... he is my fav character here.. I mean his character is superbly-well written!!! He have not changed him suddenly.. they keep his elemental things with him no matter what the situations.. and HATS OFF 👏👏to both Vivian and Drashtii... they are very talented artists!! They have portrayed the character as if they are real.. I have to remind myself this is fictional and not real.. :)

This is the 1st time I have commented on the discussion forum and I have completely loveddd it... Everyone one of you have given beautiful takes and analysis about the epi and it just feels great to be a part of it... amazing work... I just loved being in this thread!! I will be regular now... :D since I like to discuss abt the epi and want to know more about it too...

is it true Mukund is going to be back in this show again??? 😲

and was that shamsher who is trying stab rk??!!!

ok. he has point. he must be wondering what rk has done to HIS madhu that she is ready to sacrifice for him. he has always been her most impt person and now suddenly he is being faced by a competitor 😆

Quote

dramago

@dramago

Inactive

Posted: 12 years ago

#65

SD,

Read your post 3 times to clearly able to understand all that you were saying...

I am speechless...You went to the to the deepest basic emotions which drives

RK back and forth into becoming RK and Rishab...You were so right when you say

Rishabh wants everything in its entire honesty and when he doesn't get it he dons the

mask of RK to deal with the people around...Hats off to you👏👏 for nailing this

character trait of RK from the writers...Helps us a lot ...

PIppa,Preet,Sabs and Shruti...Loved to read all your posts...Great thoughts from everyone😊

Zoya,Sads...Thanks for your comments😊

Edited by himbin - 12 years ago

Quote

Shridevi Gaddam

@0-SD-0

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#66

@Peach: Tumhaari SD us waqt episode ke repeats dekh rahi thee; besides the night-walk over the forum to find if any new good posts came up outside the club.

no SS no TS. Only SD will do. But then some liberties can be taken by buddies. So tumhaari marzi. Upto you my friend.

@Preet : I like to understand what makes us what we are today. Helps in bettering ourselves. Hence the need to understand is there in me. in our lives, the patterns give us a meaning to our fatal inclinations and the outliers become signs of change. All we need to do is have a belief and take the sign and challenge the fate. And then comes the outcome...fate trying to become a destiny. I like to add this adventure to our otherwise everyday mundane life.

And your comment

>>>It's got so many layers and possibilities and the potential for an epic love story. I feel like while there are definitely errors and some contrived situations and pointless and useless moments, the love story, or rather the progression of it is lovely for the time being.

True. Pippa, I agree with you there.

And that's why I keep saying...it is not love yet and I ended my note yesterday on them being adversaries still. Whether people agree or not ...over here on this forum...but I have to say...until a man and woman actually start feeling something for each other in a mutual way that attracts them physically as well, we cannot say they are on the path of love.

Love is multi-layered. God is Love. Love is God. Isi pe Duniya tiki hai, Duniya kayam hai. But that is that...the broader definition. But when it comes to man and woman's love for each other in the sense of mating kind of love...other than being friends in deepest sense, team players in deepest sense, desire and longing on that plane should also be there. Coz those are the primal feelings, that need to be felt and quenched before they explore the higher planes of love. Sacrifice does not make sense until one truly knows what you are parting with. And love should remain love even at the point of sacrifice.

@Manonids

Thank you very much. 😊

@Pippa

Loved how you said...let's see what he decides to do today. 😆 When I was writing my line "Its time for them to set aside vulnerability..." I was 90 to 10 % sure that RK will be okay with MB asked him. But then the guy is so much of a control freak, that that much stubborness is also there for him to deny his better judgement to prevail. I deal with that kind of boss here at my work-place. It has taken 5 years of standing up against him that mellowed him down not to come to me with stubborn approach to my case facts and the way forward approach. Because he knows I am gonna say as you wish, but you know that what you say is not right or not going to work ...I won't give any pleasure to him for getting what he wants and will not be pained for him getting away his way.😆

@Doves

Me too. Was moved by the episode. Watched the screentime. RK-VD took 13 minutes of screentime. His acting was brilliant. I was just worried why I kept getting Real life Superstar RK (Rajesh Khanna) facial twitches in between. But then VD like he was saying on Rangmunch interview... a non-actor like him is now picking up acting and he is happy for himself, his fans and loves the fact that his mom now approves his acting. Coincidentally, both VD and DD's mothers seem to be the benchmark audience and critic for them.

The acting by all of the actors was brilliant yesterday. I watched 17th and 18th episodes. Now I get it, it was back-to-back done and if it had been telecasted same day, the impact would have been superlative. Because everything was continuous if we watched both the episodes together.

@tvbug - Sabs

So Sabs it is from now onwards. 😃 Thank you.

@Hopelesslove - Shruti

Welcome to the forum. Most of here are for RK and DD is icing on the cake when DVD scenes happen. 😆 and Loved your Shammu take ...the competitor element 😉

@hima

Sorry for troubling you that way...😛 😆 But won't you agree? A complex character deserves a deeper analysis. Your opening post on the thread had already set the path of complexity. And then there was no return from there. At first we all get entertained at RK act like how he made knife the hero yesterday, but then the way he threw the knife away with disgust, it gives us such an insight into that man, that we just go quiet to give him the respect that he deserves. That is THE RK for us. 😃

Edited by 0-SD-0 - 12 years ago

Quote

Shridevi Gaddam

@0-SD-0

Rocker

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#67

Friday the 20th Oct - Episode discussion link

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/madhubala-ek-ishq-ek-junoon/3248385/episode-discussion-19th-oct-2012

*****I am opening the thread quite early today. I have to attend back to back meetings and I will not be available to open the thread at the regular time...so that explains the absence of the LU link.

Quote

tanu07

@tanu07

Explorer

+ 2

Posted: 12 years ago

#68

Thanks SD and Sonu for recommending this post.. had loads of fun going through this thread... will come back during the weekend.

Quote

PreetD

@PreetD

Voyager

Posted: 12 years ago

#69

Originally posted by: pippa
PreetD:

Isn't it hugely ironic that an out and out filmy serial has these beautiful touches of realism?

I agree with you that some of the situations and scenes are contrived but these beautiful moments more than make up for some of these glitches.

@bold - perhaps this is what keeps me coming back every day to this show. Apart from all the filmy drama and the contrived and completely illogical scnarios, there are gems to be discovered when you least expect them.

Originally posted by: 0-SD-0
@Preet : I like to understand what makes us what we are today. Helps in bettering ourselves. Hence the need to understand is there in me. in our lives, the patterns give us a meaning to our fatal inclinations and the outliers become signs of change. All we need to do is have a belief and take the sign and challenge the fate. And then comes the outcome...fate trying to become a destiny. I like to add this adventure to our otherwise everyday mundane life.

And your comment
>>>It's got so many layers and possibilities and the potential for an epic love story. I feel like while there are definitely errors and some contrived situations and pointless and useless moments, the love story, or rather the progression of it is lovely for the time being.

True. Pippa, I agree with you there.
And that's why I keep saying...it is not love yet and I ended my note yesterday on them being adversaries still. Whether people agree or not ...over here on this forum...but I have to say...until a man and woman actually start feeling something for each other in a mutual way that attracts them physically as well, we cannot say they are on the path of love.

Love is multi-layered. God is Love. Love is God. Isi pe Duniya tiki hai, Duniya kayam hai. But that is that...the broader definition. But when it comes to man and woman's love for each other in the sense of mating kind of love...other than being friends in deepest sense, team players in deepest sense, desire and longing on that plane should also be there. Coz those are the primal feelings, that need to be felt and quenched before they explore the higher planes of love. Sacrifice does not make sense until one truly knows what you are parting with. And love should remain love even at the point of sacrifice.

👏 about love..

As much as I sometimes complain and am annoyed at the slow progression of this, I know that this is how I want it. I would hate them if they rushed them into love without the contemplation and the time it needs to move from where they are to where they will be. Like I said before, there was a moment when this first started that I was like, they're going to ruin this, and rushing it was what I meant. I'm going to try and enjoy the ride.

Edited by PreetD - 12 years ago

Quote

Shruti, Shru, shutu, frooti, DiDa

@HopelessLove

Explorer

Posted: 12 years ago

#70

thanks SD!!! :)

I said competitor cuz I know how a over-protective father feels for his daughter... I am living with one... so I can say Shammu was feeling threatened that HIS daughter's love has to be shared and to THAT man whom he hates now... well. rishu has not given him any chance to like him. He has always pushed his buttons.. well. rishu pushes everyone's buttons... stilll.. loved your take more..

Quote

1 ... 3 4 5 6 7

Episode Discussion: 18th Oct 2012 - Page 7

Related Topics

Explore Topics