Originally posted by: Gurtiluv
Well it depends if it was his first DUI offence if he had a history there is mandotory jail time. Mukand was not fine he was seriously injured. I dont know about India but in the US if you seriously injure someone well drunk driving here you have spend jail time. RK's body guards almost killed Shamsher they didn't just eliminate his threat. A person using force in self-defense should use only so much force as is required to repel the attack. According to law here if you would like to claim self defense in the US you have to be in danger of being seriously injured and IF Shamsher as you said didnt even reach RK even though he was about to that didn't require beating Shamsher the way they did until he was almost finsihed. RK didnt attack shamsher because he body guards to do it for him.
Yes, its the same in the UK. And since India is a common law country, I would assume the same applies there.
The parts highlighted are the two important components.
I think the main reason for so much disagreement on this thread is because two crowds are approaching it from two different perspectives. Me and Gurtiluv here 😃, are approaching it from a strictly legal perspective. And others from a moralistic one (depending on which level a person places trespassing😆).
Either way, all I can say is, you don't have to crush on his character to watch the show. Can't we just take his character for what it is (at this point) and watch regardless, just to see where they go with him?
Why does every action and reaction have to be justified and boxed up? As we all agree, he is a grey character. So his actions will also be grey. This is was NOT self-defence. Neither was it a fully intended and thought out attack. Simple as that.
Regardless though, under the law, he would be responsible.
PS: Am I the only one that wanted to see RK and Shamsher go one on one? If only the guards hadn't been there. I wanted to see them go at it, and just go crazy 😆. Shamsher would have kicked his ass I think. He's more tough and street fighter like, RK's too personal trainer and fitness smooth-ied out.
Cricket
CID
Hindi TV Shows
