Shabana Azmi just up and left - Page 2

Originally posted by: critique

Shabana got up and left, if you see the video again and very carefully, you would have noticed that Shabana left as she had been completely wrong. She had told TP that "the public got you back and now the public doesn't want you here" which was followed by the voting rate where the public didn't want them to go but wanted Chetan and Sanyogita to go. I have always had very high regards for Shabana and never thought that she would behave so much prejudice. If she was fair, she should have :

1/ Asked Naman as to why did he abuse just for being voted out, it is game.

2/ Asked Naman , why did he forget the steps and should have judged him the same way as she judges all the other contestants.

3/ Just becos Zeenat gv 5 to Naman for non-performance, she revenged by vng 1 mark to her zone.

What it looked like :

Shabana and Naman had played together the game of getting the non-contestant against Naman so that all the contestants can vote out Non-celeb and vote in Naman.....................I did not know shaban would get into these games.

Poor Baby forgot the steps , so what ?, the mother will take care and lead the controversy.........don't worry...........

She was saving the Poor Baby throughout, even when it was the mentors duty to put the contestant on track.Noooooo, it was this Poor Baby.

HOW FAKE CAN YOU BE SHABANA?????????????

well...i dont think u r right completely. It happenned with Reshmi and Sayantan also many times..public wanted them out but the participants saved them...so all that matters is that the teams are in the bottom two. Which means the public may be want them a little more than Chetan and Sanyogita...but they they wanted the other 5 teams more than these two teams...which is something highly contrasting to the so called public called them back story.

Did u see what Punnet said last week in the VT...he said he has public behind him...so what ever the mentors say...it doesn't matter. THis is the main reason he was given a 1 mark.

Coming to Naman, it was so evident that both Twinkle and the other team voted him out not based on the talent..but on personal grounds..which was proved also. Thats the reason Naman pointed it out and he even proved his point. Remember ..this is the first time he ever opened his mouth.

He cant risk his votings from public and marks fromt he mentors by wantedly forgetting his steps. No public is so stupid...we vote only of they perform. So whatever Shabana did was soemthing which any mentor would do. Remember how Zeenath Aman was encouraging and nice with Twinkel and Puneeth when they broke all rules of the show and created a scene and walked away...and she was so nice when they came back. I dont blame her...she is their mentor..and it is her duty. Now Naman and Bindu are the only tema left out in Shabana's zone...so what she did was 100% fair and the right thing.

She did not give 1 mark to the two teams as Zeenaht gave only 5 for Naman. All she wanted to proove is that participants should give value to the judges.

[quote]Shabana got up and left, if you see the video again and very carefully, you would have noticed that Shabana left as she had been completely wrong. She had told TP that "the public got you back and now the public doesn't want you here" which was followed by the voting rate where the public didn't want them to go but wanted Chetan and Sanyogita to go. [/quote]

twinkle is so so fake