Dutta's journey of love - Heart Vs Brain - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

79

Views

4.6k

Users

27

Likes

226

Frequent Posters

lizdarcy thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#21
DD, lovely post! 👏

But I do not completely agree with you.

Naku's been part of Dutta's life ever since she entered PN. She pushed him out of his darkness, kept pestering him unceasingly so that he'd see the light. This is where I agree with you. Dutta's always loved Naku, unknowingly. He's been protective of her from the very beginning, saving her from More, the goons, defending her in front of his sisters, opening up to her...and most of all acknowledging the fact that he likes talking to her, listening to her bak bak. I suppose he always thought of her as a little girl. I remember Adi posting this quote in one of the threads: I love you for what I am when I am with you. It's one of my favorite quotes. And in Dutta's case, this is the truth. Everytime he's been with Naku, he's learnt to love himself a little more. Which is why her conversations always leave him happy, and at peace. And the idiot never realized that this was indeed true love. For when a person makes you want to be a better person, that is someone worth fighting for. And for our Dutta, this realization is gonna come a little late.

I agree with you, Naku's touched his soul in a way neither Supriya nor Seema could. While they grazed the surface and left him with wounds that pushed him into that pool of darkness, Naku came as a ray of light. He fell in love with her not because she was ugly or dark, but because she believed in the person hidden in him. She was able to see kindness where others saw brutality. THat way, he's always loved Naku. And maybe everything bad that happened to him was so that he find this beautiful person with an even more beautiful heart. And learn to appreciate life. For that's what Naku's been teaching him slowly. I agree with you when you say that his hatred stemmed from the fact that deep in his heart he cared for her. And hence the betrayal hurt. Most of his dialogues during the forced shaadi time are so powerful It;s like he's branded her with his name. And it almost seemed like all that hatred was because he believed she was his, maybe as a friend. And finally when he realized that she was innocent....there's one scene which stands out in my mind! Boy, an absolute brilliant dialogue. This dialogue alone convinced me that Dutta loves Naku but hasn't realized it yet: Kamina waqt tha, ya tu andha tha....na samjha ye dil...Bahut huroor tha na, logon ki pehchan thi na tumhe...saara huroor tod gayi woh!!!! I LOVE this monologue. Somewhere in these lines, Dutta told us that she's defeated him.

His time in the jungle with her just reinforced the feelings. Jagtap brought them to the surface by asking Dutta to look into himself. And that's when Dutta realized that Naku was in him all along. While he'd been running away from everything, his peace and love had always been in him.

There is something that I see
In the way you look at me
There's a smile, there's a truth in your eyes

But an unexpected way
On this unexpected day
Could it mean this is where I belong
It is you I have loved all along

It's no more mystery
It is finally clear to me
You're the home my heart searched for so long
And it is you I have loved all along

There were times I ran to hide
Afraid to show the other side
Alone in the night without you

But now I know just who you are
And I know you hold my heart
Finally this is where I belong
It is you I have loved all along

It's no more mystery
It is finally clear to me
You're the home my heart searched for so long
And it is you I have loved all along

Over and over
I'm filled with emotion
Your love, it rushes through my veins

And I am filled
With the sweetest devotion
As I, I look into your perfect face

It's no more mystery
It is finally clear to me
You're the home my heart searched for so long
And it is you I have loved
It is you I have loved
It is you I have loved all along

And so, once he' realized that Naku was his future, and his destiny there was no turning back for him.This is where I have to disagree, for I believe he loves, has always loved her for being "the home his heart searched for so long". Not because she was dark or ugly.

Now, he still needs to shed his prejudices. Her being beautiful is gonna shatter all his misconceptions about beauty and betrayal.Yes, he's gonna call her a betrayer too, at first, but then he HAS to look beyond all that and see what is clear! That this is one person whose beauty shines in her eyes even when she's hidden under a layer of soot. He has to realize that she is true. His truth.

SORRY, for the LONG post.😳
Hopeless TaSha addict,
Liz
Edited by lizdarcy - 14 years ago
sikkaisha thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#22
Hey Liz
Absolutely loved your reply.Beautiful lines.He has always loved her for being "the home his heart searched for so long" How well you have described what Nakku means in Dutta's life.
He has to realize that she is true. His truth.❤️
Truth is the ultimate .....everything else holds no meaning in front of it.After so much pain,life and God has given him the most priceless gift any human can possibly receive..TRUE SELFLESS LOVE......he just has to remove all veils of prejudice and darkness of his mind to see this grace of God.



mussy.jamshed thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#23

Originally posted by: sikkaisha

Hey Liz
Absolutely loved your reply.Beautiful lines.He has always loved her for being "the home his heart searched for so long" How well you have described what Nakku means in Dutta's life.
He has to realize that she is true. His truth.❤️
Truth is the ultimate .....everything else holds no meaning in front of it.After so much pain,life and God has given him the most priceless gift any human can possibly receive..TRUE SELFLESS LOVE......he just has to remove all veils of prejudice and darkness of his mind to see this grace of God.



agree sikkaisha...........but its a fiction show........dutta gonna think she has betrayed him too....knowing the fact she is the most beautiful of them all gonna raise more doubts in his heart.......but he has to think " who wants to cover up such a beautiful face and that for too long'......one can cover the face but not heart"........she could have used her face to seduce him......anna made her scare crow........who would want to be humiliated this way despite being beautiful..........I just hope this time he does not listen to kala at all.

Nakusha is pure selfless being and I wish dutta forgives her ..and don't punish or call her betrayer.

When you need support I'll become your crutches,
When you're cut I'll become your stitches,
When you cry I'll become your tissues, and when you fall I'll become your wings 😊

Edited by mussy.jamshed - 14 years ago
sikkaisha thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#24
@ Mussy.jamshed: I agree this is fiction show
This is precisely the reason I love this forum Through the brilliant posts and view points ,I am able to experience LTL in a way I wanna see it ( an ideal way) and I wish were shown on TV but is not due to number of factors.😊
jessica10 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#25
a truly brilliant post DD
u have captured the essence of dutta so well
prettywoman thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#26
DD.. amazing write up.. I think you are actually Dutta masquerading as Baaji on the forum!! seriously, i felt as if this was Dutta's monologue.. i think all the anger , pain after naku not doing FR has been poured out into this post.. hopefully now that the anger/pain has subsided a bit u can start to enjoy the show from tomorrow.. i am also feeling a bit calm now :-P.. cant wait to see what D does tomorrow.. he will not disappoint us and will make us proud of our faith in him!
Dancingdoll thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#27

Originally posted by: sub_rosa

This is the closest one can get to Dutta's psyche! Very well-analysed...I agree completely with it! His prejudice against beauty is something that resides in his mind/brain....and not his heart! And in moments of emotional crises he tends to listen to his head, and not heart...when it is the opposite that he should be doing! Like Baji had advised him sometime back to listen to his heart when it came to Naku! But obviously he wouldn't do that for the time being...until again his heart takes precedence!


I thank you for posting this....because, from now on our forum will be flooded with anti-Dutta posts...and your argument can counter them all!

I think I'd refrain from reading any post from now onwards....since I'm very protective about Dutta....and cannot tolerate people bashing him!

Hey Rosa, V good point...I forgot Baaji advise....Great, Amy alter ego also realized that Dutta has this habit of finiding logic in everything, i.e. using his brains...and hence, we find him excited at the nuance of feeling different and great about himself, when Naku is around....The feeling is unexplicable for him and yet he enjoys it...Thats when he realizes that since he cant find a logic to this feeling but he still likes to live in it, why not go ahead....His heart just takes him towards it because it had a feel good factor about it....and thats when Baaji switches on his bulb, Bhaao, Use heart, not brains, and u wuld be able to decipher this strange alien feeling!
Rosa, We love to love Dutta so much that we realy cant stand a negative post against him,....My post on the promo was also about the "structure of the dialogue" not on Dutta...I know Dutta will speak about his prejudice and in a fit of anger, we know he doesnt have control over himself!!!.....
Dont worry Rosa...everyone has a right to present their point of view and what their taker was from a scene. Unfortunately or fortunately, u cant change the feeling a viewer takes from a scene.... Inspite of multiple post on the "logic" that supposedly resides in Tasha wedding and Naku's FR post the wedding, I cant change my taker and feeling from the episode or track or scene....Similarly for everyone else.....if we can show them our POV, fine, if not, we move to greener pastures!!....😃😛...what say? 😉😆
Dancingdoll thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: mozart66

Hats off DD!!

Lovely post and great analysis!!!!! You summerized it so well. Dutta is one complex character and yet you got into his psyche so well!!!!😊
Loved your post!!

oh Thanks Mozart!!.....This is one character, I have postmortemed, analyized and kept his mind bare in front of me, after numerous discussion on this forum!!
This forum and members here really help u see things from diff perspective that you would never have seen before!!!
Dancingdoll thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#29

Originally posted by: msthula


wow DD....again a beautiful post...must have taken ages to write.....😊 and gosh what to reply because you have said everything.....👏
i said that in another post also....that it is not the liking of the colour black but his OBLIVIOUSNESS to the colour that we adore...but the moment I heard that he was going to say that it was because of her black colour and that was her acchai....it made me mad....although in my heart i knew this was going to be one of the aspect of his angry ranting....like he had done when nakku rejected his proposal....but at that point of time i thought it was more of his ego than his actual feelings.....but if he says this time i would be a bit disappointed....
And yes you are bang on that he had fallen in love with nakku long back....the things he never shared with sups he did with nakku....and it was her dream that he was trying to live with sups....
but the 'beauty notion'....i think that it did not spring from sups betrayal....because ....(i dont know how well i am able to explain this because it just occured to me and have not thought through).....how do you just say that this is beauty....it is when you compare it with something not beautiful....it is a case of sups vs nakku.... so in fact he saw love in nakku and thought that this is the face of love....and the opposite a face of deceit....so it was the other way round....it was because nakku was ugly that he thought that beauty betrayed....because if beauty notion is to be seen his three sisters are as beautiful as ever ... he does not abhore them (although he should ...gadha kahi ka😡)
and he will understand ....i have no doubt....he will need time ...but he will come around....
but the way he will has to be treated delicately.....like the ones they showed when he realized his love for her after they got out of jungle...i really want him to fall in love with her all over again....it would be such good time😊
dont know...havent made much sense...just ranting...but could not resist your post😃

His prejudice for color or non-color is not his actual feeling...It was his support system to justify his brain....and that has been rooted so strong in his brains that he needs to now remove this layer of prejudice and follow his heart unconditionally.....
Right now, Its this prejudice and anger speaking...I too didnt like the structure of the dialogue...I specially had an issue with the word "toh", kinda gave the feeling of "that was the ONLY thing" in Naku because even that doesnt go well with his prejudice...Other than that, we always knew he would speak about that notion...After all, that was the reason why Naku was scared to reveal in the first place...
The notion on Beauty started germinating and growing when the idea of having naku associated to him with the bond of love started coming into his mind,either by his heart or by others....and that can happen only if he had compared Seema,Sups and Naku.....that what was the diff between these 3 cases...why shld he make the same mistake of falling in love the 3rd time...Till then he was trying to hold himself from "realizing" his love for Naku....The "amber" song was a beautiful picturization of what was gng on in his mind and heart....He draws the differences between these three LSs in that song....Like, He imagines Naku saying, "Mein bilkool khoobsurat nahi, par mein aapse bahut pyaar karti hai"....the "bilkool khubsurata nahi" was a fabrication of his mind, one difference that he drew instantly....and HE THOUGHT that "this has to be the reason" why Naku's love could be true!
His sisters are beautiful too but he doesnt look at them in that light...and well, on the matters of love, the sisters havent had great history either....that can only make his point stronger!
This I think would be his 1st test, to remove this notion from his mind because he would eventually get around to reason, that the idea is not that "NAKU is beautiful, and hence she has to betray"...she has only proved that "Naku has never betrayed him and hence, a human being can be beautiful"....Naku's love and the numerous tests that she has passed with unbated eyes are so strong that it should compel him to reverse his psychology!!
Dancingdoll thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#30

Originally posted by: Bushy_92


I am confused on wat to say after reading this post..........
Excellent............DD.......... gr8 post.......👏....👏.......... u hav left me speechless...............
It must have taken ages for u to jot it down so well........👏..👏...I am speechless..............
U hav presented Dutta so beautifully..................⭐️.
U have presented such a beautiful relation of his heart and mind...................👏👏
Thank u so much....for giving us such a beautiful and outstanding...and exceptional post..............⭐️
This really is helping me to understand Dutta after the line he said..in the promo of course.......
Thanx a lot.....DD...............love u........*hugz* muaaah.........😳

I dont know if it took me ages...Once I hit upon the right nerve that made sense to me, I kept on writing....😉😛
Thanks Bushy....Are u new here? i havent seen u around before?

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".