How genuine is Madhu? !!!| VB Note Pg. 17 - Page 5

Created

Last reply

Replies

149

Views

8.6k

Users

37

Likes

610

Frequent Posters

TheRager thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#41

Originally posted by: yoyo2

I think her entry has been done in a very abrupt and quick manner, WHY? only cv's know, i haven't seen the epi yet, but by reading the post, i seem's baap ke marne ka utna kham nahi hai, BUT another thing ,, could it be posible that DP spoke to his daughter when he first encounterd kala on the road and told his daughter to watch out for dutta because he is GHADAH😆,,, It could also be that cv's have made a mega style blooper😆

I agree..her entry was abrupt and they got over with it quickly. Frankly speaking I am glad they did it. I dont care for anyone else's angst except Dutta's. If they wud have spent epis just on her we wud be bored. I'd rather they focus on tasha pre-FR.
Btw coming to her behavior believe it or not I found it real. I have seen another family closely. The father was suffering from cancer for 3 years before he passed away. He went thru a lot and the family also suffered. When he passed away there wasnt much grief...only relief that everyone was rid of their pain. Madhu was prolly prepared for her father's death who only wanted her to meet Dutta and be accepted by him...prolly that is what he taught her from a young age...so thats in her mind more than her father's death.
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#42

Originally posted by: kshreya2002

I agree..her entry was abrupt and they got over with it quickly. Frankly speaking I am glad they did it. I dont care for anyone else's angst except Dutta's. If they wud have spent epis just on her we wud be bored. I'd rather they focus on tasha pre-FR.




LOL Ksh....but she's an important character....if they don't flesh her out properly it's going to be SUCH a chore watching all her scenes with Dutta-Baaji-Nakku....she's going to be bonding with all of them ultimately....aur abhi se yeh haal hai.....matlab abhi se pucca ho gaya that I'll be forwarding so much stuff??😆.... Isn't it important that they work on her better if they want us to FEEL for this character? If her angst doesn't matter to her or us, why will it matter to Dutta? The guy she's ultimately supposed to bond with oh so much and be a "good sister" to?😛
yoyo2 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#43

Originally posted by: kshreya2002

I agree..her entry was abrupt and they got over with it quickly. Frankly speaking I am glad they did it. I dont care for anyone else's angst except Dutta's. If they wud have spent epis just on her we wud be bored. I'd rather they focus on tasha pre-FR.

Btw coming to her behavior believe it or not I found it real. I have seen another family closely. The father was suffering from cancer for 3 years before he passed away. He went thru a lot and the family also suffered. When he passed away there wasnt much grief...only relief that everyone was rid of their pain. Madhu was prolly prepared for her father's death who only wanted her to meet Dutta and be accepted by him...prolly that is what he taught her from a young age...so thats in her mind more than her father's death.

agree with u there shreya, DP must have told madhu about bhao from a very early age, because she seemed very eager to meet that bother that she had heard for all this time but never seen.
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#44

Originally posted by: Dancingdoll

Just like in Roops case, I am being extremely optimistic again and hoping Madhu would be a permanent Dutta's camper!!!....although she is the youngest of the sisters, I am hoping she is shown forward and bold enough to stand for her rights......London ka kuch to asar ho!!!....



LOL but she doesn't even REMOTELY look like the youngest😆.....She could as easily play Kala....they look similar in age😆

And there isn't much need to HOPE....she obviously IS in Dutta's camp....aate hi toh us par hi jump kiya, hai ki nahin?😛
Anu-Reddy thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#45

Originally posted by: nureat01

THIS....exactly what is bothering me more....the fact that we all KNOW that this is a very important character who will in many ways shape the future of the dynamics within the family....her bond with Dutta, the love track with Baaji, allying with Naku and standing against the evil trio....these are all very crucial things in the coming future....toh itne important character ko properly kyun nahin introduce kiya? Why out of nowhere and kinda forced her "positivity" down our throats in a non-credible manner? And honestly I don't think the actress is right for this part.....yeah she's a modern, educated NRI types supposedly but why couldn't they have picked a softer faced actress with a better voice?? She's not suiting Dutta or Baaji in my opinion.

Anu : She is a major character in the show just like, Dutta, Nakku and Baaji. So I really wished her entry was well thought off. I heard its just a blopper as of now and she can be rid of suspicion for now. So lets see how she goes. Abt the choice of the actress, I guess they wanted someone strong enuf to handle Kala in her own way and thats why they went with this actress. A soft spoken girl would pale off infront of Kala's evilish looks and thats gonna turn us all of. So we need someone who can be portrayed as strong as kala is if not better.
If u see the scene where AS points to the PN wasis and introduces to Madhu, u can see she is seing on direction and AS is seeing in another direction. What the hell. Seriously, how can someone direct so bad. One of them sure has squint eyes 😆, only that can explain that discrepency 😆.LMAO seriously?? I didn't even catch that bit....I should go look at it again😆
Anu : Nothing can escape my eyes 😆. Its only that I get tired typing so leave it for someone else to dissect 😆.
I guess its the direction to be blamed today. I'd say direction as well as writing....both were rushed....and somehow I'm starting to subscribe to the Roops being a double agent theory more too....was watching her expressions more closely today😆.....chalo even if her and Baaji aren't meant to be, her being a double agent would deffo make for a very interesting storyline on the side.

Anu : I heard its a blooper. So lets wait and watch.

yoyo2 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#46

Originally posted by: nureat01



LOL but she doesn't even REMOTELY look like the youngest😆.....She could as easily play Kala....they look similar in age😆

And there isn't much need to HOPE....she obviously IS in Dutta's camp....aate hi toh us par hi jump kiya, hai ki nahin?😛

lagta hai bhai mai bachpan se hi fida hai, jitni rakhiya ab tak nahi bandi bhao to woh ek din mai band degi madhu madam😆,

Anu-Reddy thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#47

Originally posted by: bfunofbb123

ohh anu interesting topic but here i would like to give her the benefit of the doubt q ki it is too early to judge her she just landed in she is not going to break down on the ppl she hardly knows and also she might b in shock of it all when the reality hits her u'll c she will break down and cry 4 her father. i am very optimistic about her besides i am sure she knows her dad's illness it is not like her dad was healthy & bang accident. anu what i want to say is she had like few min on screen we should give her chance to c how her relation ship was with her dad and so on and then we will know i am so hoping this is not another AS or any ones game against dutta i really hope 4 dutta's sake she is genuine and the real thing no more heart ache for dutta. i have a feeling anu when u update on friday it will b clear by then madhu's character and will b diff. story then.😊

Ya got a confirmation that right now its a blooper. We might see a better act from Madhu in couple of episodes so I guess I wll wait and watch. I saw the actress in aise, loved her work there. So no complains in that front. She can easily pull of a loving sister act. I only wished the writers were a bit careful with her intro as its a major pt in this story going forward, She will be one of the twisters in the D-N and Baajis lives and she should be etched out properly. Otherwise there are high chances of we not following her act and thats gonna turn out to be a bigger blunder for the show. So had to highlight today's blopper , thats all 😳
Anu-Reddy thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#48

Originally posted by: Dancingdoll

nahiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii!!!
*holds her ears in desperation*
yeh sunne se pehle mere kaan kyun nahi band ho gaye!! 🤣🤣
Yaar Anu, u have summarized my feelings exactly.....I guess I too was carried away by the fact tht sme1 new and positive has come in Dutta's life who seemed to want to hug Dutta without any inhibitions....I so badly wanted a pure camper on Dutta's side and I guess tht blinded me....i didnt think of AS at all...+ tht brainwave tht AS has about "Oh! this might be the Madhu, DP was talkign about" was enough to not produce tht thought in me...AS need not think in that manner if she was the one who got her there in the first place!!!
haina??? 😆😆
I feel the CVs did a last minute switch from Dutta's bro to Dutta's sis....from Roops to madhu being Baaji's Love interest and hence, they might have slipped in these places

Hoofff...............chalo ek tension kam hogayi aaj keliye 😆, ab teek hai 😳 . I was scared for a min that u fell for ASs chalu acts and forgot our motto 😆.
AreYaar thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#49

Originally posted by: Anu-Reddy

Abt the choice of the actress, I guess they wanted someone strong enuf to handle Kala in her own way and thats why they went with this actress. A soft spoken girl would pale off infront of Kala's evilish looks and thats gonna turn us all of. So we need someone who can be portrayed as strong as kala is if not better.



I didn't say I preferred a soft SPOKEN girl....I said a softer LOOKING girl would have been better....there is something to be said for quiet/dignified strength as well.....this actress has a harsh/rough sounding voice even though I can see she's tried to soften it for this role but it isn't fully working in my opinion.

What this part required in my opinion was softer faced girl with a spine of steel underneath.....who may LOOK soft and innocent but is still sharp and intelligent enough to give it as good as she gets.....that satisfies the "handling Kala" requirement, nahin?

Technically even Nakku is a "soft spoken" girl.....lekin time aane pe kya solid sunaati hai....especially Dutta ko......too bad she doesn't open her mouth in front of the evil trio.
Anu-Reddy thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#50

Originally posted by: make-believe

Like I said in another thread, she is either really so inhumanely gracious, accepting and forgiving, or just being treated as a one-dimensional robot to accommodate the story of the writers. It's amazing how we see her experiencing absolutely zero conflict keeping in mind the kind of things that have happened to her...she not only had to bring up 3 of her own girls, but also the son of her husband's murderer, and now traipsing in comes another child that she is supposed to 'nurture' and take care of in her own house on her wrongdoer's behalf. She is not even a little distressed about the idea, and expects that all the other people in the house act similarly and accept Madhu...but should it really be expected of Dutta, Kala, Leela and Roops that they smile and open their arms to her, when there's so much turmoil and hatred in their hearts related to this issue?


So either this is all a huge facade that AS has been keeping up and there will be a big reveal someday or it's just lazy characterization. I'm inclining to the latter.

On the bolded part, but that isnt consistent with what she did with Dutta at Seema's episode. How can such a forgiving , mahaan lady let her only son (as she claims Dutta to be her son) , enter Don business and kill innocent ppl in the name of revenge?. How can she feed on the money that Dutta earns by killing ppl and spreading bloodshed?. How can she pray to God when she herself is nurturing a Human who kills ppl?. (The ppl might be bad but bloodshed is bloodshed and whatever Dutta does is illegal. He is also into smugling , his intro had such a scene). I cant simply take it as a lazy characterrization. She seems way too cunning for me to neglect the inconsistency in her behavior.

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".