Is this even possible... - Page 2

Originally posted by: kshreya2002

Actually Naku can claim her rights as Dutta's wife since there were many witnesses to their marriage. But Naku wont do it. Plus the idea of sending Naku to a new place is to ensure she can start life with a clean slate as Naku and her family can get lost in the anonymity a city provides. The arrangement wud be perfect for naku to erase any gossip abt her past. But Dutta continues to live in a small town among the same set of friends and family...so he cannot really erase his past. but since he's feared i am sure no one will question him.

Exactly Shreya! That's what I was wondering yaar. Nakku has full rights to claim as Dutta's wife and just like you mentioned there were many people who were witnessing their marriage since Dutta himself told them that nobody moves and they can't leave until their marriage is completely finish, if I am not mistaken. Yea, I doubt that she'll give him divorce and even if Dutta does kick her out of his life...we know that Nakku will always remember him and will still love as much as she used too. That's so nice of him for arranging everything for her family, but we know that she'll not gonna take all this. You think that it would be easier for her to erase all those memories? I doubt that dear, she'll never forget all those in fact she'll start her new life with those memories. Yea, if she moves to new city, nobody will know anything about her past, but since Dutta lives in a meer so it would be harder for him to forget those as well. You are correct dear that since everyone fears him, they'll never question anything, but for how long?

Originally posted by: kshreya2002

A marriage can be annulled on grounds of lack of consummation. but lets not forget naku has never refused to consummate. so again the weaker party here wud be dutta and not naku. 😉

Yea, she never refused to consummate and you are so right that Dutta has a weaker party not Nakku.

Originally posted by: kshreya2002

A marriage can be annulled on grounds of lack of consummation. but lets not forget naku has never refused to consummate. so again the weaker party here wud be dutta and not naku. 😉

Originally posted by: kaly07

<font size="2">Exactly Shreya! That's what I was wondering yaar. Nakku has full rights to claim as Dutta's wife and just like you mentioned there were many people who were witnessing their marriage since Dutta himself told them that nobody moves and they can't leave until their marriage is completely finish, if I am not mistaken. Yea, I doubt that she'll give him divorce and even if Dutta does kick her out of his life...we know that Nakku will always remember him and will still love as much as she used too. That's so nice of him for arranging everything for her family, but we know that she'll not gonna take all this. You think that it would be easier for her to erase all those memories? I doubt that dear, she'll never forget all those in fact she'll start her new life with those memories. Yea, if she moves to new city, nobody will know anything about her past, but since Dutta lives in a meer so it would be harder for him to forget those as well. You are correct dear that since everyone fears him, they'll never question anything, but for how long? </font>

I agree with you on this one -- Dutta is THE LOVE of Naku's life, and she will never get past him. And, Dutta, will not allow himself to move on when it comes to love...and as we are seeing, Naku ne Bhao ka dil me uska ghar banaya hai.

Words like divorce have meaning for rich and middle class where people are educated and property is involved. but for people of naku's and dutta's background it doesnt matter. dutta being a powerful man of his area can coolly remarry if he choses. it happens all the time in reality. no one can question him except naku or her family who wont do so.
I guess the same remarriage option applies to Naku too since she will move to a new place which is outside dutta's sphere of influence. no one wud know abt DSP or his dramatic wedding. so naku can also remarry unless dutta (or his family) put up legal claims on her.
then there is a question of the past catching up with either of them. i guess if dutta had to settle down with another girl she and her family wud know of his first marriage and ignore it as he is richie rich.
as for naku and her family they can hide abt her first marriage(again it happens in reality) as there wud be no way the groom or his family wud know abt it. or maybe they can get naku married to a paragon(if they find one) who will accept naku's past. but i suppose since naku wud be moving a new place no one...not even dutta expects naku will find such a paragon.

Originally posted by: kaly07

Yea, she never refused to consummate and you are so right that Dutta has a weaker party not Nakku.

In the eyes of the law dutta has been completely unjust to naku...first a forced marriage at gunpoint...refusal to consummate...mental torture and now abandonment. and naku can easily prove all of this in a court of law. so given the situation she can ask for a divorce and get atleast half of his property if not more. so dutta be careful...chedna nahin sherni ko!

Originally posted by: gp00

No, it doesn't matter if the marriage was consummated or not. Here's the gray area. We have Dutta, who essentially lives under his own rules. The laws of society may not necessarily apply to him as with others. Yes, the marriage counts though. But as far as he is considered and his family, it was never VALID for a couple of reasons: it was forced upon Naku, Dutta did "not know" what he was doing, the pandit was forced with physical violence...it's not the stuff Hindu or any marriages are made of. But it counts, and I'm surprised he did not mention divorce per se...maybe it can be inferred, I don't know. I'm so confused on this one, personally. Marriage to me is as much based on intention as the act itself--both have to be there on both sides. Like if someone holds a gun to someone's head and forces them to do the pheras, is it a marriage? Or is it an act of violence? Dutta causes so much confusion...but he's worth it!

Yea, I don't think that either yaar whether it is or not. I know that his family never consider their marriage, but I don't think that Dutta didn't either. I mean, he knew what he was doing even though it was by forcefully and violence but he knew, right? What I know from my knowledge and I asked my bro too since he studies law...he said that if people do get married even by forcefully...they do get divorce. He told me other things too, but I don't understand law stuff....but one thing is for sure that they do get divorce and then they can move on. You cannot hide the truth for a long time. Eventually, it comes out soon or later even if you are denying it. If a marriage still done by violence then I think it is still consider marriage. He does causes so much confusion and it all wroth it, right?

Originally posted by: Anu-Reddy

Dutta in his defence (since I love him so much have to defend his gadhapan 😆) will say in the court .......... "Ur honor ......... I am a sharmila chote shahar ka mamuli sa don, it was my Nakku's duty to do the needed but she never fulfilled her duties " 😆.

Naku wud then say "Ur honor...give us 24 hrs...I'll fulfill all my duties". 😆

Originally posted by: Anu-Reddy

]Dutta in his defence (since I love him so much have to defend his gadhapan 😆) will say in the court .......... "Ur honor ......... I am a sharmila chote shahar ka mamuli sa don, it was my Nakku's duty to do the needed but she never fulfilled her duties " 😆. [/DIV]

🤣 Awwww.......look at you defending your lover girl!! So cute! I loved your bold line sweetie! Too good yaar! And, what would be Ur honor's decision?

Originally posted by: kaly07

Yea, I don't think that either yaar whether it is or not. I know that his family never consider their marriage, but I don't think that Dutta didn't either. I mean, he knew what he was doing even though it was by forcefully and violence but he knew, right? What I know from my knowledge and I asked my bro too since he studies law...he said that if people do get married even by forcefully...they do get divorce. He told me other things too, but I don't understand law stuff....but one thing is for sure that they do get divorce and then they can move on. You cannot hide the truth for a long time. Eventually, it comes out soon or later even if you are denying it. If a marriage still done by violence then I think it is still consider marriage. He does causes so much confusion and it all wroth it, right?

I feel dutta did consider the marriage valid. but he decided to end the relationship as his motive for marrying naku was punishment but not having a marriage in the true sense. from today's last scene it was obvious he hasnt really forgotten the marriage or moved on. i am sure if the question arises he wud say he considers himself married to naku and viceversa.