The return of the Mythology (ARTICAL) - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

34

Views

2.7k

Users

11

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

Ranbirrocks thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 17 years ago
#21

I think Tanya is perfect for Gandharis role as her character in kyunki was same as of Gandhari and all her fans has accepted that role very much..They have said she is doing blinds role very good.Here also she is acting as blind and there also she has to act blind.

Mr Shoaib Ali.....get one thing very very clear.........since you are not a hindu and your knowledge of Mahabharat and Hinduism is not expected to be great............so before commenting on any character of Mahabharat...positive or Negative.......respect the fact that you are in "India" forum ........if you want to do hinduism bashing...Orkut provides you excellent facility...

For your Kind information...Gandhari was not blind and she is not to be ridiculed and compared to "Tanya" for your pouring your hatered out....Gandhari is as sacred as Sita or any other goddess...

I HOPE THE MESSEGE IS LOUD AND CLEAR.

glamritz thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#22
Is ekta actually serious abt this? 😲😕
Edited by glamourous - 17 years ago
Mrignaini thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 17 years ago
#23
Sohab_ali wrote: I think Tanya is perfect for Gandharis role as her character in kyunki was same as of Gandhari and all her fans has accepted that role very much..They have said she is doing blinds role very good.Here also she is acting as blind and there also she has to act blind.



Could you please refrain from saying things like that? You may not have all the knowledge about Mahabharat, the thing in bold clearly proves that.

Tanya's character in Kyunki bears no resemblance to Gandhari. Gandhari did NOT pretend to be blind, she voluntarily blindfolded herself as she didn't want to see the world her husbamd could not see(cos he was actually blind). So there was nothing about faking blindness for purely selfish reasons unlike Tanya.

Edited by sandali_ - 17 years ago
muscleprotein thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#24

Mr Fraud: I don't think you are Nasir as that was too long for him to comment at such lenght.😉 and also Newbie with a new user id automatically points to him . BTW I like your user id too, very hatke 😆

Now here is my POV on the issue you raised:
The reason I brought up the other 2 characters was in context. Why does everything have to be percieved with jaundiced eyes and ulterior motives .
It was not to start a Mahabharat here. I beg to differ that I was a spoiler of this topic.
I now associate Gauri only as Nandini and, this being a KSKBT forum ,and commented on her role being unsuitable as Draupadi.
I really believe she would have made a very good Rukmini and Rakshanda has all the punch for enacting Satyabhama.

And SohabAli: FYI: Gandhari was not blinded she chose to be blind being a very dutiful wife. And yes I agree with you 100%Rakshanda does have tremenedous potential to play such a role with great sensitivity.

Mrignaini thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 17 years ago
#25
About the article and the casting, in my opinion it would've been great to see Gauri portraying Draupadi because Gauri as an actress has the ability to do a lot more and enacting Draupadi would've been a challenge she would've overcome with flying colours. But I kinda figured it was too good to be true.

About Hiten enacting Karna, I feel somehow there's an uncanny resemblance between Karna and the initial Karan(KSBKBT)when he made his entry, which Hiten has already played. So I wouldn't have minded if he played another character. Having said that, there are many shades to Karna that Hiten hasn't yet portrayed in his career, so I'm sure he would do great justice to the role anyway.

Ranbirrocks thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 17 years ago
#26

Originally posted by: sandali_

Sohab_ali wrote: I think Tanya is perfect for Gandharis role as her character in kyunki was same as of Gandhari and all her fans has accepted that role very much..They have said she is doing blinds role very good.Here also she is acting as blind and there also she has to act blind.





Could you please refrain from saying things like that? You may not have all the knowledge about Mahabharat, the thing in bold clearly proves that.

Thanks Sandali.......atleast you don't support someone just coz he is a KN fan......thanks for correcting Mr Ali ......hopefully he has migrated to Orkut....

darkness_123 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 17 years ago
#27
Moderator's Note:
Members are requested not to discuss religion here, as it is quite a delicate topic and no one likes it when brash (and often incorrect) statements are made about one's faith. Please refrain from making comments about the topic if you do not have sufficient knowledge.

Please discuss only the performance aspects of the characters.
sohab_ali thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#28

Originally posted by: Mr. Fraud

sorry to say buddy but what's the use of starting all this? The discussion was going in a nice way until u made that remark on Hiten gauri and Rakshanda. I don't know why u have to drag the poor 3 in every topic.If u wanted to say that Hiten would not suit into the shoes of a mythological character u shud have said this in simple words. But again u dragged Gauri and Rakshanda with Hiten in this topic and that too using such invoking words. Sorry to say but u r the spoiler of this topic.

Plus i want to correct that on the comment gauri lacks fire. If u want to see the fire in Gauri's acting just watch Kutumb 1 where she played the role of an aggresive wife where sometimes she sometimes became stornger than Pratham. It's ok if u don't like Gauri , but the fact is that she would not be able to stay for such a long time if she wasn't able to act.

@ Sujata, i am too a great fan of HGT but i think Gauri is not gonna part of Mahabharat as there is no announcement. So just be happy watching Hiten playing a challenging role as i am fed up of his goody goody roles and want him in something diffrent and exciting and Karan is such a role that have both positive as well as negative sides. But please don't use words that affects the emotions of fans of other actors. U r here for Hiten and Gauri , just talk about them and don't offend the fan of other actors.

Sorry if i had been rude to any of u but just feel that this beautiful topic shu not be spoiled dueto personal diffrences

i agree wid fraud.

sohab_ali thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#29
Hey Sandali i was just replying to muscle protein everywhere they drags hiten gauri first but everytime we r only blamed why u r not telling him to stop dragging everywhere hiten and gauri i didnt mean to hurt any1s religion sorry to sandali if i have hurt any1s religion and tvfan i will not run away anywhere since 5 years i am on this forum and not going to leave also thats final.
Mr. Fraud thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#30
@Musclepotein that's what iam saying. Why are u associating Gauri with nandini. For god's sake Nandini is a character and Gauri is a real person. How do u associate both of them. Plus u said earlier u were unable to digest HT in a mythological role, after that u said he shud have played Krishna. Can u justify that??
Was Krishna not a mythological character?? plus Gauri is not limited upto Nandini, she had played Gauri Agrawal, Priyanka Kapoor, Deepika Ghosh and Kanan Agrawal other than Nandini. And i think in three of her roles like Gauri, Kanan and Priyanka she played totally diffrent roles plus she was agrresive. It's only the role of Nandini in which she playes a soft and emotional woman. Plus what was the reason for choosing Rakshanda as Satyabhama and Gauri for Rukmini?? I am saying that because it was after your comment that the fight started. And i am not blaming u only. I have said that Sujata is also wrong. She has not right to say bad words against other actors. Plus i am also saying that user Sohab_ali is also wrong by comparing the great character of Gandhari to Tanya. That's the biggest mistake. Gandhari is such a sacrificing woman and she cannot be compared to Tanya as well as my favorite nandini because she is above all of these imaginary characters.

Plus, i agree that it is Ksbkbt forum but the discussion going on here is anbout Mahabharat so i think we are discussing actors here and the actor is Gauri not Nandini.

And i think now u understand i am not nasir.By the way my name is Sunny Thanks a lot for my user id, it's definitely jara hatke that's why i have chosen it. 😉 Goodbye and tak care
Edited by Mr. Fraud - 17 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".