Tanya/Rakshanda Discussion Thread - Page 5

Originally posted by: Lil Ms.Sunshine

Please no discussion about KN at all!!

We're going to have to stop it. This topic has no discussion about KN, and the KN topic has no discussion about Tanya. =)

Agreed Sweta.....we are not going to discuss anything about KN....there are hardly 1-2 posts that mentioned them and as soon as people come online and see my comment, they will surely edit it. Since it is new thread, please give us some time to get used to the new rule. We fully understand this thread is not meant to increase moderator's headache...from our side, we will not do anything that is against the decorum of this thread.

And people on this thread...mods have created this thread to give us space for discussion on Tanya and others ...their side of story..etc etc. We should not make this thread another headache for mods 😆....this was meant to reduce their problems...not increase them 😆.

So please discuss the stopic without rocking the boat !!

cheers

Ritu

I feel very sorry 4 Taya too.... 😭
She has the right to join Trupti coz she did a looooooooooooot BUT got nothing 😭

I think anyone wud have done the same thing when they r feeling sooooooooo vulnerable emotionally.....

Actually , it's not so suprising if Tanya join hands with Tripti to ruin Nandini and her relationship with Karan . But being a die-hard KN fan I still feel sorry 4 Tanya because in the coming episodes she is going to be simply used by Tripti in order to teach Tulsi a lesson and throw Nandini out of Karan's life . I don't actually know if Tanya is going to be successful in her aim or not but I can surely conclude that it is totally pointless in showing that tanya is still blind . If she is really going to be made the next vamp , then she must be shown acting to be blind just to snatch away Karan and satisfy her own benefits.Because I believe that by the time Tripti track ends Tanya must have turned to a vampstar . Moreover , I can't help saying that Tanya is a character protrayed in a biased way. If she is going to be made the next vamp after Mandira ,Meera and Tripti then it was absolutely rubbish to have shown her in such a positive way uptil now . !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1

^ There's no need to get so agressive, Labib. Remember how it felt when people talked to you like that for not sharing their opinion? I don't think you want to turn into one of those people. So please, milder replies. Or if you dont agree with something, report it and we will check it out. But such hurtful posts will not be entertained in the future.

DEAR BHOOMI_FAN


IF I WAS NUTS TO POST REPLY 4 THIS TOPIC THEN IT WAS EQUALLY SILLY ON UR PART TO THE WAY U HAVE REPLIED TO MY POST . ACTUALLY , U CAN'T UNDERSTAND WHAT I WANTED TO SAY . TANYA JOINED HANDS WITH TRIPTI AS A RESULT OF EMOTIONAL BLACKMILL BUY TRIPTI . FORGET , THAT I AM A KN FAN 4 THE TIME BEING AND I AM NOW A TANYA FAN . IMAGINE THAT I POSTED THE REPLY AS A FALSE KN FAN AND IF U COULD IMAGINE SO , MY REPLY WOULD BE STILL THE SAME . I AGREE THAT TANYA HAVE BEEN SHOWN BLIND TO LOFT OUR SYMPATHY 4 HER BUT HOW CAN SHE NOW JOIN HANDS WITH TRIPTI TO FULFILL HER AIM OF GETTING KARAN.I MEAN IT IS TOTALLY RUBBISH THAT A CHARACTER BEING SHOWN BLIND IS GOING TO GET A SLIGHT NEGATIVE TOUCH IN HER CHARACTER . WELL , SHE CAN AT MOST ACT IN SUCH A WAY OR PLAN IN SUCH A WAY SO THAT
SHE CAN GET KARAN BUT ISN'T SHE GOING TO BE TOTALLY DRIVEN BY TRIPTI AND AFTER TRIPTI FINSHES WHAT SHE WANT A , SHE WILL THROW AWAY TANYA. WELL , IF U R REALLY OBEDIENT TO THE MODERATOR THEN IT'S OK.
BUT , AT LAST IF I'VE BEEN RUDE OR IF I HAVE POSTED WRONG REPLIES ,I'M SORRY . PLZZZZZZZZZ DON'T FEEL UPSET . LET'S END THIS ARGUMENT RIGHT HERE !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

^ Please dont post in all caps, as it is taken as shouting and considered very rude.

Originally posted by: Bhoomi_fan

UNGRATEFUL BHOOMI

Hello friends,

Now it's time for us to discuss something new in this discussion Thread.

According to me, i think Bhoomi is being very, very much ungrateful--> yes i'm saying that, being the GREATEST bhoomi fan, i'm saying that Bhoomi is being ungrateful. Now there are reasons for me to think this....

We all know that it is tanya who grew Bhoomi up, it is Tanya who took care of Bhoomi, it is tanya who made bhoomi learn "ABCDEF...", it is tanya who made Bhoomi eat, it is Tanya who taught things to bhoomi, it is tanya who made mothered bhoomi, it is tanya who looked after bhoomi when she becomes ill, it is Tanya who loved bhoomi with her entire life, it is Tanya who worried about her, it is Tanya who spend twenty years of her life for bhooooooooomi.........BUT BHOOMI ???

But bhoomi??? Tanya has done so much for her, but in exchange, what is Bhoomi giving tanya? Yes, i agree that Bhoomi's real mother is nandini, therefore Bhoomi has got right to love nandini more than she loves tanya, Bhoomi has got the right to make her mother-father (Karan and nandini...) marry each other. BUT! BUT SHE however, don't have any right to do behave like this with tanya....

I agree that Nandini s her real mother, and tanya her step mother. But just because she doesnt have Tanya's blood in her body, does that mean that she'll have to hate tanya? Just because She have Nandini's blood in her, does that mean that she'll have to care for only and only Nandini, and not for Tanya???

Look what Bhoomi did with Tanya. Bhoomi knows this very well, that Tanya must be sad about her mother and father's (karan and nandini's) engagement. Couldn't she just go to tanya and CONSOLE her? Couldn't bhoomi just go to tanya and say her things like, "Tanya mom...u are my real mother, after all. I will never-ever forget what u did for me..I love u the most. But u will have to understand that my biological mom and dad love each other a lot, and that is the reason of making them married. Please understand that, and believe me mom, i love u the most....u are my real mom...and i will never ever forget u...." Couldn't bhoomi have said these thing to Tanya yesterday??? But no, she was to busy!!!!

I understand that Nandini is bhoomi's biological mother, but TANYA IS HER MOTHER TOO! After all, who suffered more, Nandini or Tanya??

It is Tanay who suffered more, who troubled more to raise up bhoomi. What did Nandini do?? (no offence to nandini fans) but nandini only gave birth to Bhoomi and put her in her belly for nine months. But Tanya??? she looked for Bhoomi for 20 WHOLE YEARS!!!! So which is more painful, giving birth to a child and being pregnant for 9 months, or looking after someone for 20 WHOLE YEARS????

Yes, definitely nandini had suffered a lot, because giving birth to a child isnt a easy thing. But looking after a child for 20 years is a more hard/difficult thing to do!!! Suffering 20 years is definitely more difficult than suffering 9 months!!!

Tanya had to suffer for 20 whole years. She had to think about whether Bhoomi is doing her studies, whether bhoomi is alright, whether anything have happened to bhoomi.....blah blah....All the time Tanya have to worry about about Bhoomi being alright or not...Looking after a child properly, isnt an easyu thing tooo doooooo......She has suffered so much just for raising Bhoomi...BUT NOW WHAT IS TANYA GETTING IN RETURN???

Couldn't Bhoomi just go to Tanya and console tanya so that Tanya wouldn't have become sad??? But instead when Archita told Bhoomi to see Tanya since Tanya has got hurt in her hands, Bhoomi crumpled her face. What's here to be so much annoyed? Didn't tanya looked after u when u also burned ur hands???? Yes, tanya did and in return she is giving this to Tanya...

Anyway...finally i will say that if Tanya becomes evil, a great percentage of fault will be bhoomi's....NO OFFENCE TO BHOOMI FANS, i'm myself a bhoomi fan....i just wanna express my views that what Bhoomi is giving Tanya in return.

Tanya's becoming evil has got to do a lot with bhoomi not loving her...yes, she took Tripti's hands because she wanted Karan...but the main reason is that Tanya is actually sad that why bhoomi don't love her...

Anyway...i have written enough...all i want to say is that Bhoomi is being too much ungrateful to the woman...who's responsible for her being alive...

THANK U....

LABIB

I personally think that u r quite right Labib. Tanya burned her hand and Bhoomi didn't even console her!!!😡 After all she was telling K&N that i m very happy that u two r getting married.....BUT she didn't even feel once for Tanya who brought her up and loved her soooooooooooo much...😭How could she forget Tanya who loved her as though she is her own daughter??? I really feel sorry for Tanya first of all her husband didn't love her now even Bhoomi whom she loved soooooo much has forgotten her and left her in such a condition😭POOR Tanya..... Bhoomi should go and console her...

KEEP THIS DISCUSSION GOING GUYS......😳

Meera 😳

Look, I am a HG fan and a KN fan. But I am not here to fight with anyone. I just think that there are some things that she's done wrong but some members don't want to acknowledge it.

She married a man she was in love with, despite knowing he may not ever love her. When she went into this marriage, she was happy because she was getting married to him. Him, on the other hand, was depressed about losing the woman he loves because she slipped into a coma.

She taught him to love Bhoomi and then when she got him (on Tulsi's insistence). Then Nandani came back, she was crying because Nandani was back. She didn't bother to care that her friend fought death and was alive. All she truly cared about was that her happiness will get ruined.

When Karan was told that Nandani cannot receive any shocking news, his decision was to stick to Nandani because he couldn't lose her again. But Tanya didn't care about that. When he told her his decision of sticking by the woman he loves and cannot give her any relationship, she still hung onto him, telling him: "What matters for me is that I love you." And she cried to him all the time about her fate, didn't she choose this path?

Even when she stayed away, she kept on calling Karan asking him to come meet her, etc.

This is why I cannot ever feel pity/sympathy for her. Because she did know what she was getting herself into.

She didn't even do that great of a job of raising Bhoomi or Manthan. She really spoiled them to a point where they supported relationships based on the status of that wealth. They didn't respect Baa, for God's sake.

She always scolded them when they were doing the right thing. She never scolded Manthan for trying to frame KT (early after the leap), for being rude to Baa, and she never scolded Bhoomi for being in a bathtub with Abhir.

More, she spoiled their minds against Nandani. She told them Nandani's using fake tears to lure Karan, when did Nandani do that? Rather, the viewers were always shown Nandani encouraging Karan to give his marriage a try. He tried but Tanya had become so jealous and hateful against him, Nandani, and Tulsi, she didn't even see what was truly going on.

More, she never told Bhoomi the truth about Nandani's rape. If she was really a true friend and good mother, she would have told Bhoomi that Nandani was raped by Ansh instead of letting Bhoomi think that Nandani was a slut. Which is why Bhoomi turned against Tanya because Tanya never told her the truth she deserved to know about her mother and biological father. On the other side of Bhoomi, there is Nandani who is always encouraging her to be good to Tanya, etc.

*Viewers didn't see that from Tanya's side, did they?*

More, she supported Karan-Nandani's enagagement and initiated it herself, why is she upset now? She was the one who forced Nandani to stay when Nandani wanted to leave? She told Karan she wants a divorce. And then, hasn't Nandani been there for her during the time she's blind, more than Karan, hasn't she?

So why can't she be happy that Nandani is finally getting happiness.

Other than that, she was justified when she got upset with Tulsi for blaming Manthan because Tulsi was wrong when she was falsely pointing fingers at everyone, being mislead by Damini. And she didn't even get upset with Damini for trying to trap her son!

To me, her only positive attributes are this: she taught Karan to love Bhoomi and supports her kids when they are wrong (but she doesn't correct them either).

*PS: Mods & members I know I am not supposed to use KN's names, but I am using the names only to explain the context of why I cannot sympathisize with her.*

Humaira

Originally posted by: desiflavour101

Look, I am a HG fan and a KN fan. But I am not here to fight with anyone. I just think that there are some things that she's done wrong but some members don't want to acknowledge it.

She married a man she was in love with, despite knowing he may not ever love her. When she went into this marriage, she was happy because she was getting married to him. Him, on the other hand, was depressed about losing the woman he loves because she slipped into a coma.

She taught him to love Bhoomi and then when she got him (on Tulsi's insistence). Then Nandani came back, she was crying because Nandani was back. She didn't bother to care that her friend fought death and was alive. All she truly cared about was that her happiness will get ruined.

When Karan was told that Nandani cannot receive any shocking news, his decision was to stick to Nandani because he couldn't lose her again. But Tanya didn't care about that. When he told her his decision of sticking by the woman he loves and cannot give her any relationship, she still hung onto him, telling him: "What matters for me is that I love you." And she cried to him all the time about her fate, didn't she choose this path?

Even when she stayed away, she kept on calling Karan asking him to come meet her, etc.

This is why I cannot ever feel pity/sympathy for her. Because she did know what she was getting herself into.

She didn't even do that great of a job of raising Bhoomi or Manthan. She really spoiled them to a point where they supported relationships based on the status of that wealth. They didn't respect Baa, for God's sake.

She always scolded them when they were doing the right thing. She never scolded Manthan for trying to frame KT (early after the leap), for being rude to Baa, and she never scolded Bhoomi for being in a bathtub with Abhir.

More, she spoiled their minds against Nandani. She told them Nandani's using fake tears to lure Karan, when did Nandani do that? Rather, the viewers were always shown Nandani encouraging Karan to give his marriage a try. He tried but Tanya had become so jealous and hateful against him, Nandani, and Tulsi, she didn't even see what was truly going on.

More, she never told Bhoomi the truth about Nandani's rape. If she was really a true friend and good mother, she would have told Bhoomi that Nandani was raped by Ansh instead of letting Bhoomi think that Nandani was a slut. Which is why Bhoomi turned against Tanya because Tanya never told her the truth she deserved to know about her mother and biological father. On the other side of Bhoomi, there is Nandani who is always encouraging her to be good to Tanya, etc.

*Viewers didn't see that from Tanya's side, did they?*

More, she supported Karan-Nandani's enagagement and initiated it herself, why is she upset now? She was the one who forced Nandani to stay when Nandani wanted to leave? She told Karan she wants a divorce. And then, hasn't Nandani been there for her during the time she's blind, more than Karan, hasn't she?

So why can't she be happy that Nandani is finally getting happiness.

Other than that, she was justified when she got upset with Tulsi for blaming Manthan because Tulsi was wrong when she was falsely pointing fingers at everyone, being mislead by Damini. And she didn't even get upset with Damini for trying to trap her son!

To me, her only positive attributes are this: she taught Karan to love Bhoomi and supports her kids when they are wrong (but she doesn't correct them either).

*PS: Mods & members I know I am not supposed to use KN's names, but I am using the names only to explain the context of why I cannot sympathisize with her.*

Humaira

EXCUSE ME!!!😡

Why do u GHT(desiflavour) fans come here????Huh???😡

If u can't sympathasize for Tanya then FOR GOD'S SAKE!!!! DO NOT come to tanya's sticky....😡

The moderators made this topic only for praising Tanya not for GHT fans to babble out why they think Tany is EVIL!!!😡

If u have problems with Tanya then keep it to urself!😡

What u r doing is strictly against the FORUM RULES coz the moderators have mentioned that this sticky is only and only for discussing TANYA....😡

How will u feel if we go to ur K&N/GHT world sticky and ruin that saying why WE Hate K&N....😡

Moderators: Please do not let GHT fans to post/participate in this sticky!!!!😛

Meera😳

Look here Tanya fans. Agreed that yes this is Tanya sticky. But please do remember that Tanya is a character with grey shades. This topic isnt just for glorifying Tanya and to keep praising her - it is to discuss all facets of the character whether negative or positive.

I said there isn't supposed to be unwarranted BASHING of the character in this thread. No calling her names, no remarking on her looks, no calling her witch or chudail and things like that. But the truth is that Tanya has been a negative character who has done quite some questionable deeds in the past, and discussion of those events are allowed.

Tanya fans - I have read through desiflavour's post and he/she is not bashing Tanya. The character has done these things, so you cannot say that desiflavour is bashing Tanya.

Labib and Mit - please stop being so aggressive. This is a free forum and everyone is free to enter and read through any post they have, and post their opinions. as long as they are not BASHING. You are free to enter the KN topic too and post there as long as you are not bashing KN/GHT. So please please please, stop being so agressive and rude, or I will have to raise your WL for such posts, targetting members.