poor manthan i pity him - Page 3

Originally posted by: Bhoomi_fan

Ok, ok, now u answer one question of mine: IF karan really cares for manthan, then why didnt karan believe Manthan when he was falsely accused of raping KT?have you not seen after knew manthan's truth karan stood against tulsi. And why doesnt Karan ever come to manthan and adore him? If manthan makes any mistake Karan comes to manthan and slaps him. But this is not the way!!! If manthan have a mistake, karan shud teach him, not slap. But karan can only slap.how can he teach him when he slap him every time tanya came b/w them and supported to manthan and stand against karan..

I know that u people (karan fan) will now starts bashing me up, esp u, rad_rose, but I DO NOT CARE AT ALL. I am telling the truth so why shud i feel ashamed or afraid? If karan love manthan then he shud understand manthan's feelings toward nandini.because of tanya manthan always misnderstood karan's feelings .hje always said nandsini dusri aurat and sais bad things to karan becauae tanya portrayed infront of him and bhoomi her one sided love story.then why karan understand his feelings .

Manthan loves his own mother very very much. And that's only his fault??? Loving his own mother? What manthan wanted was nothing but to see his father karan and mother tanya together. He really loved his mom and dad, and he wanted to see them toogether. And this is so naturall. Every child will want his mother and father to be together.after knowing tany's truth(i mean she used bhoomi and manthan against nandini) have you not seen manthan was feeling guilty towards nandini and thought bad abt tanya.plus karan himself handle that situation very well because his mother and father never lived together and that time karan thought mihir was wrong but after some time he realised mhir only loves with tulsi.

and But still, manthan hide his feelings. He didnt shout at nandini for coming between Tanya. He even didnt cry , though he was feeling very sad. why he shout and and why he blamed to nandini because she never wana come b/w tanya and karan infact she was ready to leave its tanya herself stopped her .

So, now as a father WHATS KARAN'S DUTY? to go to his son, and make him understand, isnt it? But did karan ever went to manthan and said "oh manthan, you poor manthan, pliz understand, i and nandini love each other, pliz understand." Did karan ever say this things to comfort Manthan? No he didnt. He didnt even care whats going on inside manthan's heart. yeah i here agree with your they didn't show karan said anything to manthan but i am sure after karan nandini's marriage karan and manthan's relationship should be better.

Think urself in manthan's place. Wouldnt u feel bad? Yes u wud. And manthan felt bad for her mother. And karan! He didnt even look at manthan nor did he ever try to comfort him. yeah if i am in manthan's place then i am very happy to see finally my mother took a right decicion because of her my dad and his first wife sacrificed their love but my mom never satisfied plus she did bad things with them because of one sided thats why its much better they got divorced and spending their lives with their own wishes.

I know u all are angry reading this, but i dont care. CAZ THIS IS THE TRUTH AND NO1 CAN CHANGE THIS.

Originally posted by: Bhoomi_fan

Whatever it is, it is true that Karan doesnt care for manthan. Whatever u say, truth willn't change.

Absolutely. How does a child meant to understand another women's sacrifice if he is seeing his mum crying all the time because of her (karen treating her badly because of her). How he is meant to love and understand his dad, if his dad doesn't do that for him. As a parent is his duty to teach and give love to your child. If someone else instead of Hiten played Karen everyone would have dislike this character. Only thing he is good at is going along with Tulsi. He is not a good father😡

Ya Manthan's poor. I do pity him becoz he's got a vamp as a mother who never taught him how to behave properly with family members or to respect elders. Manthan has been spoilt excessively by his mom.

Anyways there's still hope for him. Now that Nandini is in SN, I'm sure she'll give him all the love & affection that he deserves, along with good sanskaar too. Just wait till his & Nandini's relationship improves, then watch.

Oh so well-put Afra. Seriously I never thought abt Karan & Lakshya's relationship earlier. Indeed they share a very comprehensible bond between them.

Originally posted by: prerna15

Ya Manthan's poor. I do pity him becoz he's got a vamp as a mother who never taught him how to behave properly with family members or to respect elders. Manthan has been spoilt excessively by his mom.

Anyways there's still hope for him. Now that Nandini is in SN, I'm sure she'll give him all the love & affection that he deserves, along with good sanskaar too. Just wait till his & Nandini's relationship improves, then watch.

Originally posted by: Bhoomi_fan

Oh!!!!! Just because Karan didnt want a child, he will not love the child who has got his blood??????????????????

Just becaz Tanya ios evil (acording 2 karan) Karan will hate Manthan? And wont give a damn about hiM?

And if karan didnt want any child from tanya, then why did Karan sleeep with Tanya? If karan dont want a child, he shud not sleep with Tanya. When he needed to fulfil his desire, he slep with tanya. But when he have to look after manthan, he didnt do it!!!! When he needed Tanya to fulfil his desire, he used her. And after that a baby boy named manthan was born, but he didnt care about him?

Originally posted by: gaurihiten fan

haan yaars,tanya is the one who spoiled both bhoomi and manthan,bt i'm glad nw NANDINI is there,i'm sure kuch din baad manthan and Nandini will share a relataionship like tulsi and Karan does,pure ma-beta rishta😳

i agree with u all,,,,

Please rmr no personal attacks and keep this a CALM and peaceful discussion.

I do feel bad for Manthan at times as well. I wouldn't blame Tanya for "spoiling" him. Tanya didn't want to believe her son was wrong in any way. And Karan .. well I wouldn't say Karan was the best influence on Manthan. No one really cared about him which is why he turned out the way he did. Or atleast thats what I believe.