Discussion: Shobha Virani - Page 2

Originally posted by: rajendra

* Shobha is a bit stubborn character.
She does or believe whatever she wants to
example: her marrying Vishaal against the wish
of Tulsi and the people of shantiniketan

* I would not go to Payal.
I would go to Shantiniketan as I would know
that my momma knows the truth
and everyone in Shantiniketan will believe me

* Nope, no cahnce of me forgiving Abhisek
Directly or indirectly he was invloved and
he has no self-concious to accept and speak the truth

* Oh god Neha, I cant think like Ekta

But I sure do hope the truth is revealed
without any twist and drag
all
Kiran

LOLZZZZZZ😆

thats my thoughts, you just copy/ pasted it.

Nice thoughts everyone... Well here it goes:

• What do you feel about Shobha's character? I know many of us aren't big fans of her because she didn't listen to Tulsi when she should have etc etc.. but was there a time when u did like her?

Like vinny_rams I also liked her when she nursed Payal when Payal's own daughter didn't even pay attention to her.... very selfless and sweet girl then. I liked her much eariler but ever since she married Abhishek despite what Tulsi told her and in return blaming Tulsi for accusing Abhishek, I haven't been too fond of her.

• If you were Shobha, would you go to Payal and tell her about Abhi's truth or take off to Shantiniketan like she did? If Payal isn't worth telling, should Shobha confide in Gautam at least (as he was asking her earlier) or someone else about what she found out or is it not worth it at all?

Well knowing Payal's nature, she's bound to support Abhishek. Perhaps it's best not to tell because there's not much she can do. Tulsi is the best to support her in this as well as Karan... I'm not sure how much Gautam can do.. he might think it's Karan's planning based on what he's seen. I think what Shobha needs to do besides cry is get up and out and find some solid proof. Rathe's word isn't going to cut it in front of everyone.

• Do you think Shobha will forgive Abhishek since it may be proved that he was indirectly involved but not the one who wanted to kill Vishal... and whether she will or not do you think she should?

I think Shobha may ending forgiving Abhishek. Although Abhi did have a hand indirectly he really didn't pull the trigger nor did he want Vishal dead so Shobha may eventually (and this may be a longgg eventually😆) forgive him. But that all depends on Ekta ~~ I honestly don't think she should. He isn't worthy of forgiveness... being a mute spectator to a murder and knowing of the plan is a crime itself. He could have forcefully tried to stop Ansh or warned Karan that VIshal's life was in danger, but he did nothing.... on top of that he was yelling at Tulsi and blaming her for accusing him when she in fact was right... so all in all i don't think he deserves forgiveness.

• With Karan meeting Rathe and Gautam on his tail, do you think Shobha will be convinced (again) that it was supposedly Karan's planning and Abhishek is "telling the truth" or some other weird twist like that? And if so, do you think Shobha will buy into it as usual or this time will she take a stand?

nice topic.....
i think she's very stubborn...but she looked good with vishal...i used to like when she was nice to tulsi and she was more in shantiniketan....
she believes everybody then her own mother....i mean used to be she was so emotional, caring towards her mother and all the sudden payal was everything to her.....
i think she will not forgive abhishek....even after the whole turth out, he hide the truth and he's been lieing....and he's been speaking against tulsi and karan all along....so he shouldnt be forgiven.....
and i think she should have told the truth to payal and then leave his house and come back to shantiniketan......

Great discussion Neha

Shobha is a normal girl, making mistakes and learning from them. She is good cause she acknowledges her mistakes and is not afraid of apologising. She knows whats right and sticks to it. She loved Vishal and convinced her family that her choice was right. She is a great dil, nursing her mom-in-law during sickness and even now so attached and caring for the family. I have liked her in the past for sure.

Shobha should have told Payal the truth. She has built good relationships with Payal over the years. She should have told Gautam too. But probably she is scared. Thulsi did not react very positively in the first instance to Abhi. Now with the truth coming out, she is taking slightly longer to digest the fact. But she needs to discuss with one of her bros / parents / mom in law and dig in deeper. Though its difficult she will have to accept the truth

Shobha might forgive Abhishek. Though its not easy at all. He has been a good friend for long. But will things be the same ?? It might take too long for wounds to heal. Whats worse is, he has been mute for so long. Didn't he ever feel like speaking the truth when he saw his beloved wife suffer ?

If Shobha is convinced again, thats the dumbest track and I will hate Shobha. I think she should help reduce the misunderstandings between Gautam and Karan, by saying the truth.

Sorry for the delayed response Neha, Its a great discussion that you have initiated

yeah.great topic neha.

like deepthi said,shobha is a normal girl and there is no wonder in her makin mistakes.we cannot expect all to be a tulsi.there was a time when i liked her.she was not a person who invited only hatred towards herself.she used to be and is(i believe)one of the best of tulsi's children.u r right.i am no big fan of her bcoz she failed to understand her mother but i think just bcoz we have seen tulsi understanding everyone and stuff, we expect shobha to do the same.but shobha is a different individual who is not as experianced as tulsi right?now that she is repenting wht she did i think she can be forgiven.but i too think she is a bit stubborn.

well......payal is shobha's saas and her relashionship with payal is quiet strong.also if payal comes to know about the truth,she too will get a chance to recognise her mistake and take some......say.......ACTIONS(she is the mp 😆)but i would prefer not going to payal n staying with her coz its her mother she should apologise to on the first hand.also shobha and tulsi too share a good relationship.afterall even if she calls payal mamiji she is not her saas any longer though one must agree that relationships of the heart r valued more.

if i were shobha,i would definitely not forgive abhishek.he really is not worth it.agreed that he was a good friend,but does a very truthful fried have enough courage to kill his pal?afterall, one must have a heart which is as merciless as lord voldemort 😉to kill such a good person like vishal.also after all this he created a rift between shobha and tulsi.he almost bROKE THE good relationship of shoba and tulsi.and he in no way is seen repenting or feeling shameful.

misunderstanding again huh?????possible becoz the track ekta adores the most is misunderstanding and marrying thrice of more times.it would be very idiotic if the same track is brought in again and again.if something like that happens god noes whether some1 can ever change ekta!😡

sorry from me too for replying soo late!hope more and more ppl answer and make this discussion great.

Very nice topic Neha...and everyone has put up their views very nicely.Neha first i would like to tell u sommething that its not Shobha Virani😉..she is not Virani anymore..she must have Abhi's surname😆..ok Jokes apart.

• What do you feel about Shobha's character? I know many of us aren't big fans of her because she didn't listen to Tulsi when she should have etc etc.. but was there a time when u did like her?

Shobha is very sweet girl and in a way she is matured too. As Deepthi said she did right decision in marrying Vishal. We see many people even after love marraige they end up in fightings..but Shobha did maintain their relationship very nicely and thats also due to Vishal no doubt. I used to love Shobha's character initially...she always cared about Payal eventhough she never cared Shobha. Also Shobha was more of like Mamma's girl...and she has many of Tulsi's Sanskar.Her marrying to Abhishek was wrong decision inspite of being warned by Tulsi.

• If you were Shobha, would you go to Payal and tell her about Abhi's truth or take off to Shantiniketan like she did? If Payal isn't worth telling, should Shobha confide in Gautam at least (as he was asking her earlier) or someone else about what she found out or is it not worth it at all?

Payal and shobha have a very good relation ship now. If i was in place of Shobha i would have told Payal because the issue revolves around Vishal. But before telling payal I would have gathered some proof so that Payal can believe. Anyone cant believe suddenly if they tell that he was involved in murder.She can confide in Gautam as he did ask her...let him believe it or not she can tell what had happened. Karan is always there to help her she can go and tell him that is the best...but since she had a feeling that Karan was involved in Vishal murder case then she would not tell him so.She must wait for her mom and tell her...and they must dig up the truth instead of believing Abhishek. Whenver they want proof why do they tell everyone that they will do this do that.....havent they got some brains😡

• Do you think Shobha will forgive Abhishek since it may be proved that he was indirectly involved but not the one who wanted to kill Vishal... and whether she will or not do you think she should?

I am sure Shobha will forgive Abhishek...may be it takes long time but she will surely forgive him😆 and moreover Abhishek though was involved with Ansh he never wanted to Kill Ansh....But i think he must have told the truth when Shobha came to know from Rathi. Abhi had a chance to accept his mistake but instead he kept saying no to it. As far as I think...he must be put up in Jail for sometime and later he can be forgived. He is a criminal as he used ot do drug business and tried to trap Vishal in it. He is a culprit and he must get imprisoned.

• With Karan meeting Rathe and Gautam on his tail, do you think Shobha will be convinced (again) that it was supposedly Karan's planning and Abhishek is "telling the truth" or some other weird twist like that? And if so, do you think Shobha will buy into it as usual or this time will she take a stand?

Originally posted by: DeepAnBH

Shobha might forgive Abhishek. Though its not easy at all. He has been a good friend for long. But will things be the same ?? It might take too long for wounds to heal. Whats worse is, he has been mute for so long. Didn't he ever feel like speaking the truth when he saw his beloved wife suffer ?

I was thinking same... what kind of love does he have for her if he keeps hiding truth.. not just that but on top of truth he tells lies! Before he tried to convince that Tulsi was wrong when he knew that he was indeed correct.... and today he instigates Gautam against Karan when he knows very well that it wasn't Karan's fault rather Rathe had told Shobha. Abhi's character annoys me to no end and he gets no pity from my side... I don't think things will be the same even if Shobha ever forgives him... being a mute spectator is itself a crime.

Originally posted by: lakshmi ram

misunderstanding again huh?????possible becoz the track ekta adores the most is misunderstanding and marrying thrice of more times.it would be very idiotic if the same track is brought in again and again.if something like that happens god noes whether some1 can ever change ekta!😡

Agree lakshmi.. this track is bogus and overdone🤢... Ekta needs to put in a dose of originality into Kyunki... Multiple marriages is her favorite topic😉 but this repeated misunderstandings definately comes close... If Shobha forgives Abhi again like Deepthi said that'll be the dumbest track🤢... Maybe u and I need to go and fix up Ekta, what say?😉

• What do you feel about Shobha's character? I know many of us aren't big fans of her because she didn't listen to Tulsi when she should have etc etc.. but was there a time when u did like her?

hmmm...i kinda liked her character in the starting of the show...all sweet and nice but now she has definetly chenged..and i tottlay did'nt like the way she was treating tulsi- her OWN mother!!!

• If you were Shobha, would you go to Payal and tell her about Abhi's truth or take off to Shantiniketan like she did? If Payal isn'tworth telling, should Shobha confide in Gautam at least (as he was asking her earlier) or someone else about what she found out or is it not worth it at all?

I think that she shud have told payal firts..since she would have kicked abhishek outta the house😆....and it would have gave him lesser time to think of an explanation to this!😉>>which he probably is doin rite now! lolx

• Do you think Shobha will forgive Abhishek since it may be proved that he was indirectly involved but not the one who wanted to kill Vishal... and whether she will or not do you think she should?

I dun think that she will eva forgive him..cuz she REALLY loved vishal!!!😃😳

• With Karan meeting Rathe and Gautam on his tail, do you think Shobha will be convinced (again) that it was supposedly Karan's planning and Abhishek is "telling the truth" or some other weird twist like that? And if so, do you think Shobha will buy into it as usual or this time will she take a stand?

ya...u neva noe...ekta alwayz does that to dragggg the story... and i think that gautam will start balming karan fur the whole thing!!!😉 but i liked the way he told off mohini the other day! lolz..that was pretty gud of him to admit that karan was rite😡i guess we'll find out!😉

Those r my thoughts on this!!😉

Neha~

I think Shoba is very daft and will go for the 3rd poimt . As in beleive Gautams' story and go back to her husband . And hate Karan as usual .
Shoba should have first spoken to Payal , after all she adores her so much and even takes permission to go out and even gives her more importance than her mom.