Karan Resposibe for Tanya's death? - Page 3

Originally posted by: DeSiPride05

Ahaaaaaa look who is back! Why it is Coolkitty 😉😆

Welcome back sis 🤗. Mez all rested and ready to roll mah sleeves at ya. 😉

Ok missie I know you keep asking the same question again and again that why Karan did not stand up for his love? And I keep saying he did 😊. He did tell the family and protested the marriage. He had no problem waiting for three years or I would say his entire life but the family forced him. Now I dunno if you as mah friend have been in the situation ever and I ask you very frankly not directly but if you have for wotever reason then you would know it is extremely difficult to resist the whole family when the insist on sumthing altogether. Yeh I dun blame Tanya for the marriage but I blame Tulsi. I hope this is clear.

And I mean everything respectfully no offense at all sweetie.

Originally posted by: coolkitty_23

Lol...no probs hun...no offense atall..i know i keep repeating my question, bcoz i keep getting very vague answer to it from hardcore KN fans, who would not look at it from any other point..that apart..i think, he could have still walked out on that marriage, or otherwise, if the pressure was so much , that he complied..he didnt have to consumate..tulsi said, give tanya your wife's right..in which dictionary, does giving a wife right, mean consumating with her?
the point is i have too issues only, for which i blame karan..
1. he souldnt have married tanya atall, what so ever!whynot tanya refused to married with him infact nobody forced to her plus karan told her clearly he only and only loves with nandini .if karan didn't clear infront of her fee;lings then we should blame karan for thjis marriage.
2. even if he did, he shouldnt have consumated the marriage!yeah its his fault.but have yoy not seen he was trying to moved on with her.

karan asked her tumhe mujhe chor ke jane main meri khushi hai then tanya said tumhari kushi ke liye main tumhe chordongi but i cant live without you .then karan said to her tum mujhe kabhi chor kar najana and hugged her.but when mandira called to tanya she told her abt karan nandini then why tanya went to nandini's house whnot he believed karan after all tanya sped 20 yers with him and she knew it very well karan never lie to her .plus when she saw karan nandini hugged with each other and thought now nandini wanna come back in karan's life then why not tanya left karan as she said

to karan so many times when nandini will retuen i will leave you but she never fulfil her promise ,she said to karan i always respect your and nandini's love oh thats why she kicked out nandini from sn that means she is a biggest lier.plus when she knew abt nandini's marriage she said so many bad things to nandini then why not she was happy in that time and if she was sincerely thinking abt karan thats why she said so many bad things to her then why not she is happy right now and reunite karan nandini.no she was showing jelousy that means she is a double standard woman.

plus when karan came back from parvati's party and tanya said to him apni thakan guest room main jakar mitalon karan said to her ye sahi hai ke maine nandini ko kabhi nahin bholsakta magar ye sachi hai ke tu mera aaj ho.

first shge herself kickout nandini from sn but still taunting.

tanya said to karan i said you were not here because you were deep in your thought and obviously you were thinking abt nandini.

shameless woman if you thinks karan still loves nandini and she is still living in his herat then why not you left him.that means you have no selfrespect.

plus she said to him i gave you and your family 20 yares of my life.

oh thats why karan ko zabardsssasti tanya se pyar karna parega.

she said to karan i always respest your and nandini's love.

oh thats why you kicked out nandini from sn.

plus

I dont know why, but most Kn fans think, i am anti KN..the joke is, if i was anti KN, i wouldn't be writing a Fanfic on them! but, i dont care ,i know my stand..and i believe to his, his own...right neha?😳😳😉

Originally posted by: coolkitty_23

Lol...no probs hun...no offense atall..i know i keep repeating my question, bcoz i keep getting very vague answer to it from hardcore KN fans, who would not look at it from any other point..that apart..i think, he could have still walked out on that marriage, or otherwise, if the pressure was so much , that he complied..he didnt have to consumate..tulsi said, give tanya your wife's right..in which dictionary, does giving a wife right, mean consumating with her?
the point is i have too issues only, for which i blame karan..
1. he souldnt have married tanya atall, what so ever!
2. even if he did, he shouldnt have consumated the marriage!
I dont know why, but most Kn fans think, i am anti KN..the joke is, if i was anti KN, i wouldn't be writing a Fanfic on them! but, i dont care ,i know my stand..and i believe to his, his own...right neha?😳😳😉

Awww I dun think your anti KN. I think you are just expressing your own tohughts which you have every right to do and I appreciate it. That is wot this forum is for. You are always welcome to express ur opinion in mah posts with full freedom.

To come back to the point I can adress the two issues you have

1. He married tanya because of the family that was very keen on this marriage. As I said and sorry to reiterate but it indeed is difficult to fight the whole family and especially when you are weak. I agree he was weak at one point but he has grown a lot dont you think?

2. He consumated this marriage because of a guilty feeling that he had in his mind as he married this woman who was very patient from her end and waited for Karan to make that advance. So greatly appreciated Tanya and started developing some feelings for her. Therfore he started a marital relationship with her.

Originally posted by: Ansh/Eku_lover

hatts off to u love 👏 and ya what ever u do k&n fans whould always blame u thats what i rly hate 😡 but im not going to be a looser kid and sit there and not say anything 😡 just becasue there is more k&n fans 😡😡 no no never 😡 ppl dont mess with me or im going to make u cry 😡 u guys dont know what kind of b**** i can be 😡 as for my account i dont care casue i can make a new one any time get it u looser 😡😡

What is the matter Wahida? You are more than welcome to post your thoughts in mah topic but why this way huh? This topic is going very nice and v r having a healthy debate why are you being yourself here? If you are gonna be this way please refrain from postin here hun. My humble request to u. 😊

Originally posted by: Ansh/Eku_lover

will i dont care anymore i cant take u guys anymore 😡 why do ppl aways balme a girl for uhh why not karan 😡

Ok thanks for your input. Now watch your language. 😊

Originally posted by: Ansh/Eku_lover

ok 😉 but the fight is not over yet 😆 lolzz

love wahida 😛

Whose fighting? I certainly ain 😕 R u ok?

I don't argue with you here. You have a point and this is something I will hold against Karan until he realizes what mistake he made.

There is no answer to your question. Because the answer is simple:

He was weak and depressed at that time (not justifying him but justifying his circumstances at that time). Whatever his reasons were, he betrayed Nandani.

About Taya not provoking Bhoomi, I disagree with you here:

Why was Tanya quiet when Bhoomi would call Nandani a sautan, a slut? Why was Tanya quiet when Bhoomi constantly raised fingers at Nandani's character, when Tanya was a witness to Nandani's misery and somewhat a cause of it as well?

At that time Tanya was positive. Wasn't Tanya wrong here? Both Tanya-Karan are wrong in my books and always will be. But Tanya more so because she blames Nandani-Tulsi for her miseries when they have always encouraged Karan to give his life with Tanya a try.

I don't want Nandani to go back to Karan because simply put:

He doesn't deserve her love because he betrayed her. In a coma or not, he betrayed her. No justification to that!

Originally posted by: coolkitty_23

See..all this problem, as you have all pointed out, Tanya too be, so selfish, etc, which is also true, wouldnt have happened, if Karan hasnt married tanya atall..let alone consumate..my question is only one thing...why wasnt karan man enough to stand up for his love for nandini, and tell his family, that bhoomi's mom, nandini would be back..why did he give up on nandini so soon? couldnt he have waited for more than three years?? even if tanya accepted to marry, where was karan's self esteem, to marry someone, just for the sake of his kids..if tht is how it was, it should have stayed tht way.manthan shoudlnt have happened at all!! since manthan happened..tht proved,tht when karan consumated his marriage, again as you all proclaim, under pressure, really isnt he a weakling? Na nandini ki saccha pyaar diya, na Tanya ki mann rakh paya!
what ever tanya did, she was wrong, but i dont understand one, thing, she never told bhoomi abt nandini's truth, tht does not mean, she poisoned her mind either..instead, when bhoomi found out abt nandini being her mom, she outrightly insulted tanya, without even considering tht tanya had brought her up...and she didnt say anything to that...i am just not sure, how you say, she used bhoomi to get to karan..when she actually got bhoomi, only bcoz of karan, and karan should be glad about the fact that tanya brought his(not even his!!)daughter up, more than her own son?? yes, later on in the showm she did provocate manthan, and went against tulsi etc, she was wrong, and i am not defending tht ever...just that i dont think, tanya is the only one to completely blame..karan shares equal..and more of it as well!