Karan Resposibe for Tanya's death?

DeSiPride05 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#1

You know what I dont think so......

I know people have been saying that Tanya gave good whatever years of her life to Karan and his kids.

Hummm, yeh right!!!!! She did did she? Soooooo.....

AS KARAN SAID ANY WOMAN IN HER PLACE WOULD HAVE DONE WHAT SHE DID.

OK I will tell you from begining; this woman came with an evil intention to breakup Karan and Nandini as she was Ansh's friend and hired by him. Now Karan clicked with Tanya as a friend and she started develping feelings for Karan knowing very well that Karan loved only Nandini to death. After Nandini went into Coma Karan was forced to mary Tanya for Bhumi' sake. Karan was completely against this marriage and had to mary Tanya but told Tanya he loved Nandini and Nandini only. Tanya accepted it. Karan did not even cosumate this marriage until again Tulsi forced him. Anyway, now Tanya got pregnant and Nandini came back to senses. Sooo..Tanya left Karan without any notice or did not bother telling him she was gonna have his baby. Wow like he did not have any right to know huh.

Then she carried the baby for some two years and finally delivered the baby after Nandini went to jail and Tanya settled in SN. Now after serving the sentense Nandini came back saw the usual SN life and left cuz she did not want to disturb it. Uopn seeing Nandini back after 20 yrs if Tanya took everyting the way she did before she would not have lost respect and eventually love from Karan's heart Would she?

I belive Tanya decided her fate long time ago when she started overreacting on everything the way she did. Karan put up with her for long enough and tried to keep her happy by leaving Nandini at one point. Tanya's insecurity pushed to the edge. Karan did every thing in his power to make the marriage work to he extent he gave her everything he owned so that she would leave his mom alone. She never did.

These are only a few points from many that I see Tanya did wrong.

If you stll blame Karan, well........................

YOU ARE WRONG 😊

Created

Last reply

Replies

28

Views

5.4k

Users

14

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

coolkitty_23 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#2
No Not really..see..in sab problem ka jaad to yehi hai na..ki karan married Tanya under pressure...if he loved Nandini soo much..why did he not fight for his love? why did he not stand up for his love to his family? was he a weakling? yes he was..he was weak in his heart...he did not think twice before marrying tanya..only bcoz he selfishly thought about the daughter, whom he once hated..if you remmeber, nandini wanted to abort the child...tanya saved bhoomi, tanya told karan tht nandini was gonna abort...mebbe aborting the child would have been the best..na hoti bhoomi, na hota yeh shaadi...if any one is wrong, karan is..to tanya, for marrying her under pressure and then having a son...
DeSiPride05 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#3

Nah mah friend Karan did fight for his love indeed.

He did not want to mary Tanya. He is not wek at all. He is the only one in the family with strong beliefs and true senses.

aborting Bhumi? I am a pro life so no matter wot I dun promote it. Ok now I mma gonna go to bed as I gotta to work tomorrow. So i will reply to u tomorrow sis.

Love

Neha

coolkitty_23 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: DeSiPride05

Nah mah friend Karan did fight for his love indeed.

He did not want to mary Tanya. He is not wek at all. He is the only one in the family with strong beliefs and true senses.

aborting Bhumi? I am a pro life so no matter wot I dun promote it. Ok now I mma gonna go to bed as I gotta to work tomorrow. So i will reply to u tomorrow sis.

Love

Neha



Lol, no probs Neha...sleep tight 😃...and i am all for not aborting if its for the right reason...and if he did not want to marry, why did he then? he gave in didnt he..tht means, he is weak...😳😳
desiflavour101 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#5
Actually Karan did fight all.

Karan told Ganga-Damini (who were pressuring him to marry Tanya) that he cannot marry Tanya (Tanya overheard this!).

Then Tulsi told him that someone needs to take care of Bhoomi.

During the saath pheras with Tanya, Karan stopped in the middle, realizing what he was doing. He said "No, I cannot do this."

But Bhoomi started crying, so he continued with the pheras, with Nandani on his mind and in his memories.

Karan WAS a weak character. He did do things for his family's happiness. He accepts he lived for others and got no happiness of his own.

After 23 years, he is being selfish and wants to be with Nandani, but has accepted his fate with a bitter smile. The only time he smiles is when he comes face to face with Nandani.

When he comes home from somewhere, he has to hear taunts by Tanya about him being with Nandani?! What man will put up with that?

He told her that he's tired of trying to talk to her and now he won't bother to.
neela226 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#6
you have to look at it from tanya's point of view. sure she came with ansh and married karan. but she truly loved him. now it really hurts when you love a person and they dont love you back.she was tired of him always thinking of nandini.her insecurity is justified. even her feelings towards tulsi as being a thorn in her relationship with karan. she took care of bhoomi like her own daughter and even was against tulsi because she made bhoomi marry joydeep. sure she hates too much and made man than try to kill nandini but love makes people do weird things.she has sufferred all these years because she hoped karan would love her but love is something that just happens in your heart which you have no control over.its not karans fault he doesnt love tanya because you cant fall in love so many times in life. his first love was damini then nandini.nandini has sufferred from being in love with karan but couldnt be with him because of circumstances. and karan is not weak.when you love someone you also have to think about your family as well.
desiflavour101 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#7
but isn't it Tanya's fault for marrying Karan despite knowing that he's in love with Nandani?

Tanya knew why Karan married her, so why complain about it now?

There is no cure for her insecurities because no matter what, it won't change that Karan loves Nandani and he always will.

I wouldn't call Damini his first love because once he saw her happy with Gautam, he moved on.

Nandani came into his life, and he was hit hard! He couldn't forget about her, not even 23 years later.

All in all, its only Karan-Tanya's fault for their miseries in life.
deepi_911 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#8
all karan faultits

read carefully
ok karan first dont want to marry.....agree.....but he married her.......it was tanya who saved bhumi...who bought karan near bhumi/.......and tulsi dint force karan to consume marriage......she just made him reaklize.....and they consume marriage.....karan started loving tanya......he is use to do so much 4 her.......and on their anniversary,.......wen tanya was abt to say.....nandini came.....karan was happy......but sad to .....he was not ableeee to adjust with nandini.......he use to go secretly to meet tanya.......and thta rubbish he wrote in his diary........tanya gav 20 yrs pf life......and moment nandini came aftr 20 yr he gav divorce paper.......tanya never wanted money....she always wasnted karan........wen she was ready to sacrifice......nandini told not to do so......&wen she was happy andini returned.......tanya took money so just karan wont leave her.........still time bought karan nandini in such situation that tanya felt insecure......and karan dint clarify........sh e loved bhumi like her daugter......wat more she has to do now........to be good???????????

its all karan fault.......
deepi_911 thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#9
all karan faultits

read carefully
ok karan first dont want to marry.....agree.....but he married her.......it was tanya who saved bhumi...who bought karan near bhumi/.......and tulsi dint force karan to consume marriage......she just made him reaklize.....and they consume marriage.....karan started loving tanya......he is use to do so much 4 her.......and on their anniversary,.......wen tanya was abt to say.....nandini came.....karan was happy......but sad to .....he was not ableeee to adjust with nandini.......he use to go secretly to meet tanya.......and thta rubbish he wrote in his diary........tanya gav 20 yrs of life......and moment nandini came aftr 20 yr he gav divorce paper.......tanya never wanted money....she always wasnted karan........wen she was ready to sacrifice......nandini told not to do so......&wen she was happy andini returned.......tanya took money so just karan wont leave her.........still time bought karan nandini in such situation that tanya felt insecure......and karan dint clarify........sh e loved bhumi like her daugter......wat more she has to do now........to be good???????????

its all karan fault.......
miss_parvy thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 17 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: deepi_911

all karan faultits

read carefully
ok karan first dont want to marry.....agree.....but he married her.......it was tanya who saved bhumi...who bought karan near bhumi/.......and tulsi dint force karan to consume marriage......she just made him reaklize.....and they consume marriage.....karan started loving tanya......he is use to do so much 4 her.......and on their anniversary,.......wen tanya was abt to say.....nandini came.....karan was happy......but sad to .....he was not ableeee to adjust with nandini.......he use to go secretly to meet tanya.......and thta rubbish he wrote in his diary........tanya gav 20 yrs pf life......and moment nandini came aftr 20 yr he gav divorce paper.......tanya never wanted money....she always wasnted karan........wen she was ready to sacrifice......nandini told not to do so......&wen she was happy andini returned.......tanya took money so just karan wont leave her.........still time bought karan nandini in such situation that tanya felt insecure......and karan dint clarify........sh e loved bhumi like her daugter......wat more she has to do now........to be good???????????

its all karan fault.......



I agree totally 😊😊😊

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".