CAMPAIGN FOR SMRITI'S BACK - Page 5

Originally posted by: Guronge

Kal El wrote:
You guys need to move on. It's over. Smriti is gone and Gautami is settled in very well as Tulsi. It'd be ridiculous to bring Smriti back now. Besides what's the point? It's better to concentrate on the other characters anyway. Plus Gautami's restrained portrayal is far better than the over-the-top Tulsi of Smriti. She may have played the character from the start but somewhere along the line (before the 3 year leap) she lost it. She was playing Tulsi as if she were playing some sort of goddess in a mythological serial.

lmao no offence but u CANNOT compare the 2. smriti has been in kyunki for 7 years and gautami for what 3 months? u cannot compare them. and as for her being settled in she said in a article she will take leave if smriti returns. GOOOOOOOO SMRITI!!! WE WANT SMRITI!!

You need to read my post again. And read it calmly. I said Smriti lost hold of the character sometime around the 3 year leap (I'd say a little before). She went over-the-top and never returned. She was especially ridiculous after she returned to SN last year. She is supposed to be playing a nearly 70 year old woman. Instead she plays it like some cartoon. Very irritating. 😆

Please note: Smriti is an excellent actress but she lost hold of the character after 7 years. It's normal. That kind of time spent on one show tends to do that to you. Compare her clownish portrayal of Tulsi to her excellent acting in Virrudh for instance or the recently ended Thodi si Zameen..... Long ago Ekta had also cast her in another show where she fought against her in-laws over a rape case. I can't remember the name of the serial now but she was very good there. Kyunki just went on for too long and Smriti got lost in there. She was nothing like what she was back in Kyunki's early days. She had become a caricature of herself. Sad for such a brilliant actress. I still remember the scene when she broke down on realizing Mihir was dead and went into labour. Powerful scene. Alas that Smriti-Tulsi is no more. 😔

Gautami does not have the burden of 7 years on her shoulder. This is why it is so much better to have her fresh take on the character. She doesn't go over-the top, she is mostly restrained. This is because she started off playing a 70 year old and not a cartoon Goddess who started off in her 20's.

If Smriti does come back I hope she looks at Gautami's portrayal and looks back on what she did during the last couple of years and realizes her mistakes. Maybe she can do it again. 😊 I wouldn't hold my breath though. 🤔

im sorry kal el but i dont agree with you. your right at some context but i dont agree. i dont liek seeing tulsi as gautami cus i find it dull and boring. she doesnt have stand. Smriti portrayed a good trong 60 year old who can prove that she is not weak even tho shes old. that shows that she has power and she will always stand up for her family no matter how old she is, cus her family means everything to her SMRITI-tulsi is always 😃

- guronge 😳

Originally posted by: Guronge

im sorry kal el but i dont agree with you. your right at some context but i dont agree. i dont liek seeing tulsi as gautami cus i find it dull and boring. she doesnt have stand. Smriti portrayed a good trong 60 year old who can prove that she is not weak even tho shes old. that shows that she has power and she will always stand up for her family no matter how old she is, cus her family means everything to her SMRITI-tulsi is always 😃

- guronge 😳

You don't have to be over-the-top/clownish to appear strong. She can remain calm yet dignified and strong. Instead she goes all out like a cartoon. Smriti played an excellent Tulsi back when she (Tulsi) was in her 20s and for some time in the 40s. Then it was over. 🤔

u people think u cna force ur opinion on others, let ppl speak, i dotn want smrit back ...hitler means not literally the over control freak ghamandi typoe character, show inner strength, dont boss around or buly okay.
i am gad that smrit isnt thr and she wont come back, who wanna bet?

I like smriti irani...Plz bring her back ekta....

Kal-el wrote: You don't have to be over-the-top/clownish to appear strong. She can remain calm yet dignified and strong. Instead she goes all out like a cartoon. Smriti played an excellent Tulsi back when she (Tulsi) was in her 20s and for some time in the 40s. Then it was over.


im not agruing anymore. smriti never acted like a cartoon. thats just insane. she always did a good job in kyunki and a majority of us want her back. there might be a few of u who dont and well thats ur opinion. if you think smritis a cartoon. then u shud think all the oldies are. look at daksha chachee for instance and her husband at 80 years old there jumping around? and when they showed gaythri dadi. it was never over for me and never will be 😃 gurongee.

AryanDipikaFan wrote:
u people think u cna force ur opinion on others, let ppl speak, i dotn want smrit back ...hitler means not literally the over control freak ghamandi typoe character, show inner strength, dont boss around or buly okay. i am gad that smrit isnt thr and she wont come back, who wanna bet?

no body wants to bet. it is only our opnions. Smriti never bullyed people, she only did what the directors told her to do. and her character never bossed around anyone. it stood up for people,and always gave truth's side. she was always right but no one ever believed her. it was NOT her choice how to act as tulsi the but it was the directors she is and always be be outstanding in the role of tulsi. now no more arguing please. 😳 😃

my dear her manner was ruthless and totaly suffocating, the same char is played by gautami with inner silent strength.

"She can remain calm yet dignified and strong. "

exactly my point.
you dont have to show dadagiri, be loud, overbearing to show strength.

and she wont come back, its clear, and majority or minority , if ekta and smriti dont wnat it it wont hapen, and i am happy, the newere tulsi is beter and she si tulsi now, the other is ex-tulsi.