I am on Manthan and Tanya's side - Page 2

im on both sides and i think karan is a good person and if he n nandani get togather n she comes back to sn i dont think karan will kick tanya out like watz wrong with keeping them both ..i mean they r all friends first n then lovers ...

i am only and only karan and bhoomi's side and i want karan nandini will be reunite and cheapest womenon on this earth tanya will kick out.and tulsi,damin iand gautam all are sick.

Originally posted by: fat1234

am on neither side!!! all of dem r at fault!

i agree 2 dis

i will support tanya here...
she deserves some credit for what she has done for the family and moreso supported karan even after knowing the fact that he loves nands..
she has never complained to anybody and has always hidden her tears and wept alone.

tanya didn't want to marry karan,but she was asked to do so coz she was like a mother to bhumi and people would have called her by names otherwise... from day-one
she has always supported bhumi more than her own son-manthan.

she also left karan when nandini came back from hospital without making a fuss and not informing anyone..

nandini herself had thanked tanya for looking after her family and that's why she left karan..

on other hand tripti married saahil for his money and not for anything else..

meera seperated tulsi and mihir and killed savita and who not just for obsession of mihir..

u cannot compare meera/tripti with tanya,its an insult to humanity...

tanya did want to marry karan.yah she left karan but after that she came bak n she used to meet karan secretly n tried to gain his sympathy by crying all the time.i didnt like karan at that time. but see nandani left karan n she never came bak in the xcuse of seeing bhumi.so tell me who has sacrificed truly? wat angers me is the reaction of her. she all the times tells that if nandani cums bak she will leave but she is a hypocrite because she doesnt want to leave.

THUS IT MAKE ANY DIFFERENCE WHETHER WE SUPPORT TANYA OR NANDANI HO GA TU WO HEE JOO WRITER NAY LIKHA HAI.SO CHILL AND ENJOY. 😉

you are mistaken here. because after nandani went to jail for killing gujral, tanya came to SN, and karan told her he cannot give her nandani's spot in his life nor in his heart. she agreed with his conditions!!!

Originally posted by: maragathm

This thing all about TRUE LOVE AND SOUL MATE is just too filmy. 😕 In real life love is based on friendship and compromises.

I totally blame Karan. He married Tanya for Bhumi's sake, what I don't get is why couldn't Karan stay at home take care of his daughter if he loved her so much. You don't need a woman to take care of a child, Dad can be just as loving. Tanya too married him, but she is a woman and she was attached to Bhumi and she thought Nandini would never come out of the coma. Tanya had her dreams too. Are you telling me all women are devis.

Ok Nandini comes back, Tanya leaves. Karan should have left it at that. Which numb skull idiot goes running behind his wife's back, to meet his second wife. He admits to the fact that he loves Tanya. He is the one who grew feelings in Tanya's heart.

Nandini goes to prison. Tanya and Karan live together for 20 yrs. If he knew from the start he didn't love Tanya he should have made it clear 20 yrs ago, instead he needed a wife who is a maid to take care of his children.

No woman in this world, including me and many on this forum would want to hear from their husband's mouth that after more than 20 yrs of marraige, that your husband considers you as a friend and he doesn't love you. That is the biggest insult. 🤢 Manthan is right to protect his mother. Nandini is also right to not come back. She knew the tension it would create. Tulsi, Damini and Gautam are also right to want to keep peace in the house.

ONE MAN CAN HAVE ONLY ONE WIFE. Karan should have faced reality and learnt to be happy with Tanya, and he should have focused his energy on raising Manthan and Boomi properly. OTHERWISE If all he ever wanted was Nandini, then as soon as Nandini came out of the coma he should have divorced Tanya or separated from her. He should have waited for Nandini for his love, instead of making Tanya his wife and confusing the poor woman, treating her like dirt and his children.

Jeez no wonder Manthan and Boomi are messed up.

Originally posted by: srk_lover

no wayyyyyyyy!!!!

tanya shud just leave the house without even having to tell her to go....she shud understand herself she's not meant for karan....she shuda left long long time back....she shuda never even came back!!!

if u find out ur hubby is married to ur best fwen....wud u go back to him?? nandini didnt come back...i dont think ne women wud...so nandini is right on her part...

but the thing is she doesnt noe why this happened...she doesnt noe karan isnt all at fault...he was pressurized...den later he just went along with it cuz he felt tanya shud get her share of love...but that was his biggest mistake....tanya shud've just left...

nandini shud come back...!!!!

\

tanya did the leave the house before the leap with out telling anyone but karan is the reason she came back. and nandani did give karan permission to be with tanbkya, of everyone i think karan is at fault because he led on tanya when nandini was in coma and when tanya left all he wanted to do was look for tanya but yet he still wanted to be with nandini. i'm all for tanya and manthan