gain thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#1

ok After reading so many posts on what Karan Said to Tanya on Karvachauth, i just can't stop myself from writing all this

My analysis

In my opinion what Karan said to tanya should be taken as follows

We all know that Tanya is Karan wife but Karan has taken all her rights for the sake of Nandini. But he is guily and realising that he has been not good to Tanya because she had done so much for him and bhoomi and in return he has given her only pain. Now he is realising that he is going through his last days so it is his guilt which forced him to say all this. We all know Karan ho good he is. he just don't want to be unfair to anyone and that's the root cause of his problem. Remember when Tanya came to celebrate Karvachauth with him he was upset and he was thinking of Nandini that she also has kept fast for him but he is unable to break her fast. But when he saw Tanya upset, he forgot about is own pains and siad to tanya to perform all the rituals. What proof do u all guys require that he loves Nandini more than Tanya when he is thinking of Nandiini even when Tanya is in front of him. He is in his last days so he just don't want to hurt Tanya's feelings by refusing to break her fast. He said all that stuff to Tanya to less her pain and to respect Tanya's emotions. But to Nandini his love is unconditional. I want to clear that after Nandini came out of coma, Karan has not maintained any relations with Tanya. It is just because he ust wants to take care of Tanya and respects her a lot.

And why u guys are saying that he loves tanya and not Nandini if he said to Tanya that he loves her a lot. It dosn't mean that he does not loves nandini. He loves Nandini too much and that's what he said that to give love to Tanya, he can not turn unloyal to Nandini. But when Nandini cames out of coma he does't think for a minute to take all rights from Tanya for her sake and he has said thousand times in front of Tanya that he loves nandini a lot and cannot live without her.

And if u all are talking of present episodes, i think it's not Karan but th stupid director who is confused. he just forgets what he has shown in previous episode. We all know that that there are many stupid thing happening in the show and the confusion of Karan is also one of these stupd issues. But don't worry guys, Karan just loves nandini and no one else.😊

Created

Last reply

Replies

12

Views

961

Users

8

Frequent Posters

gauri_hiten thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#2
Actually we have gone through this for longtime so it may be better not to discuss fo many times...He loves his both wives but just loves Nandini more..
raj_kapur thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#3
I SUPPORT GAIN !

thats the main difference love some one crazily unconditionally . thats nandini 😛 😳 😳

may feel guilty for not giving some 1 full writes and like them for being a big support thats tanya 😆

and damaini haha that ove is past
😛
but karan loves every single person in family but nandini happens to be a crazy love 😉
Eijoo''s_Angel thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#4
i dont noe gain wat u said was rite in a way but srsly if he was jus sayin dat to tanya to nake her feel better then they shud've shown atleast one scene of him thinkin bout dat!all i noe is he loves tanya and he loves nandini!which is impossible in da real world i mean loving 2 ppl?but dis is kekta's world and we jus watch it!😆
Devils Mistress thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#5

I'm wid gauri_hiten. Its true we've discussed tat loads of times. No need to re-start a new disc...

Karan love both Tanya n Nandini. Its gona b unfair to say tat Nandini is his love. Wat abt Tanya then??? She has always supported him in his tough time hadn't she??? N no1 is forcing Karan to say these stuff..he says it becoz he thought tat his death is near n wana to clear all misundersanding wid Tanya n not bcoz he sees Tanya as a pale copy of Nad as Gain is supposing!!!

Many people on zis board r gr8 fans of Nan but b cautious that while being fair to Nan u aren't being unfair to Tanya!!!

By the way, aren't u feeling fed up of the mysteries about the murderer of Gujral??? Isn't it beating too much around the bush??

Edited by Devils Mistress - 19 years ago
g_cute thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: gain

ok After reading so many posts on what Karan Said to Tanya on Karvachauth, i just can't stop myself from writing all this

My analysis

In my opinion what Karan said to tanya should be taken as follows

We all know that Tanya is Karan wife but Karan has taken all her rights for the sake of Nandini. But he is guily and realising that he has been not good to Tanya because she had done so much for him and bhoomi and in return he has given her only pain. Now he is realising that he is going through his last days so it is his guilt which forced him to say all this. We all know Karan ho good he is. he just don't want to be unfair to anyone and that's the root cause of his problem. Remember when Tanya came to celebrate Karvachauth with him he was upset and he was thinking of Nandini that she also has kept fast for him but he is unable to break her fast. But when he saw Tanya upset, he forgot about is own pains and siad to tanya to perform all the rituals. What proof do u all guys require that he loves Nandini more than Tanya when he is thinking of Nandiini even when Tanya is in front of him. He is in his last days so he just don't want to hurt Tanya's feelings by refusing to break her fast. He said all that stuff to Tanya to less her pain and to respect Tanya's emotions. But to Nandini his love is unconditional. I want to clear that after Nandini came out of coma, Karan has not maintained any relations with Tanya. It is just because he ust wants to take care of Tanya and respects her a lot.

And why u guys are saying that he loves tanya and not Nandini if he said to Tanya that he loves her a lot. It dosn't mean that he does not loves nandini. He loves Nandini too much and that's what he said that to give love to Tanya, he can not turn unloyal to Nandini. But when Nandini cames out of coma he does't think for a minute to take all rights from Tanya for her sake and he has said thousand times in front of Tanya that he loves nandini a lot and cannot live without her.

And if u all are talking of present episodes, i think it's not Karan but th stupid director who is confused. he just forgets what he has shown in previous episode. We all know that that there are many stupid thing happening in the show and the confusion of Karan is also one of these stupd issues. But don't worry guys, Karan just loves nandini and no one else.😊

You are absolutely right. I totally agree with you.😊

arsh1910 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#7
😊 😊 I agree with gain and raj 👏 .... there is no doubt about karan's love for nandu she is one person who is his life and as raj 👏 said unconditional love whereas, tanya he does like her , he admires her for supporting him but again a person like karan would never break all his relaions with tanya if he loved her , his love for nandini is way above them all his obligations his reasons to break relaions with tanya was because of his love for nandini and the fear of loosing her , like in gujral mess karan went bonkers when nandini distanced herself from him.... karan went crying to tanya nd tulsi for nandini lolzzzzz. i completely agree with gain , damini was karan's past nandini is karans life and future tanya is an obligation . 😊 😊
Adorable_Ankita thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#8
sorry gaurav may be u r true.but i don't think dat karan is thinking abt nands when tanya come to him.do they showed it?i don't think so.main prob is not dat whom does karan loves more.answer is really clear dat he loves nands more.but true luv is dat if u luv a person till death n their must be no place in ur life for anybody else even if the person is dead n karan start loving tanya inspite of knowing dat nands is not dead she is in the coma only.karan can't luv anybody he is such mahaan dat he want to give everything to everybody.he really don't love nands.he have sympathy for her too.
Eijoo''s_Angel thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#9
ya i agree wid u ankita!karan is realli confusin me nowadays!
raj_kapur thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#10
its all this confusion but as karan is going to tell tanya to go away that would make her go to mansingh who would love her in return will clear it up 😆 keep in tuned.as for nk they are and willbe together 4ever 😳

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".