My take on remake after today's episode - Page 4

Created

Last reply

Replies

49

Views

4.4k

Users

14

Likes

192

Frequent Posters

TomNJerry... thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#31
I agree to most that if makers have shown the level of harshness from Amala that FG showed audience might have switched their channels...that's why they can't take it to extreme...fine decision...I think Amala's harshness or changed scenes in show are not a big issue...

Our show is doing great but one thing where makers need to work is Amala's character details right now...We know she is going through a traumatic phase...denial,anger,acceptance she is stuck between these...
All these needs to be shown in some continuous smooth pattern...so that audience could relate to it...but this process is so haphazard lately...execution of such scenes is really really bad...besides this show is amazing...

Btw Pankhuri read my review on yesterday's epi and also gave a like...hopeful she will convey it to her seniors...and we might get to see the improvemnt.😆
shalluuu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#32
There is one word self hatred n fear from others when u pass thru trauma like rape ...amla is not raped by one boy bt four boys so even to trust any boy in this condition is very difficult n jab se mene sunny wala scene dekha h ...i m like amla is inviting problem herself...hum kuch bhi kahe bt country we are living it is difficult to open door at morning for sm1 n amla was doing everything in mid night here cvs are stupid not chrctr...it is not difficult to judge boys intentions...

Dts y i said in one of my post cvs are forgetting tagline of show kyaa kasoor hai amla ka?
-abz- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#33
It's just a remake, all remake need not be a copy. In that case,we can just expect what will come here after and watch knowing everything that would happen in future.

I'm not going to support on any side, neither FG nor Amla.

But if I were Amla, it would have been horrible and painful for me to accept change. The pace with which she's moving on is commendable. I appreciate that. No one will ever stay calm watching the criminals live happily after destroying their life. Amla's stigma is at the point. Abeer is going through a lot, I get it. Amla is behaving weird, I get it too. But all characters can't be flawless. Their development will take some time, it will turn beautiful. But we can't expect it be flawless. No one's a saint. All we need to have is patience ..it's an Indian show. Dramas are the very soul of Indian TV Shows. Accepting it is the better way out.
Edited by -abz- - 8 years ago
-abz- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#34

Originally posted by: -DrunkenMonk-

Let's be happy, guys! It is obvious that the story will different a bit. The makers are just trying to improve the things.

Trust me, I love fatmagul. But I have to accept that, fatmagul was way too harsh on Kerim, and if it were to be done by Amala as well, most of the fans would've already turned against her or even the show. Amala's behaviour towards Abeer is far more better that fatmagul's behaviour towards Kerim. I was hooked to fatmagul till the very end only because of Kerim's character, and not because of fatmagul. Fatmagul struggled a lot, but then I say that it was Kerim who struggled more. And the same thing is happening here.

We have to accept the show as it is. We cannot do anything.

I definitely have issues with the editing stuff and unnecessary bollywood songs being played, but rest of the story is fine for me.

Yes exactly!
Abeer is facing a subtle wrath in comparison to Kerim.

We need to accept the show, the writers know better. We can't jump into conclusions!


-abz- thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#35

Originally posted by: -DrunkenMonk-

Sometimes, all that you want is to forget everything and move on and behave as if nothing happened to you, or nothing has happened with you. But when you try to move ahead of it, you are not able to, as you are pulled back into the darkness with all that force that you could gather to move on. You can do nothing, but hang in between, until you find out the real way.


Sometimes, Amala smiles, and sometimes, she feels all dark and unworthy of everything. These are not mood swings of Amala, but her confusion towards her life. She sees a trustworthy Abeer in front of her, yearning for her to believe his truth, and at the same time she dies a thousand deaths when she finds herself melting for the person, whom, she thought was her rapist. She wants to trust him, and still she cannot.

She lets him hold her hand, but then wants to run away from him. She wants to give him a chance, but things pull her back. Nothing's being rushed between them. It is just Amala's confusion that is being depicted. She thinks that she is unworthy of the love that she is getting from her family, from Abeer. She tries to dream of a new life, but then her dreams get clouded. Every person's reaction differs to a situation.

This was definitely meant to be a official remake of fatmagul, but then we are seeing the differences here. The basic plot definitely hasn't been changed, but the characters have been modulated, especially, of Amala and Abeer. Things had to be like this, because in an era, where people are busy watching pedophile shows and supporting them, our show would've never been able to get the glory that it deserved for its wonderful story and characters. Yes, it differs from fatmagul now, but I don't think that is an issue. They cannot copy each and every thing, right?

Also, things will start changing, when Amala and Abeer will understand that what she needs is not a "Temporary peace of mind" but "Justice". Amala is not able to think beyond her pain now, and Abeer is not able to think beyond her safety. Not their relationship, but this has to develop gradually, and along with it, their relationship will strengthen and Amala will understand what Abeer actually means to her.

Amala's behaviour towards Abeer is not because of the fact that she has started melting for him, but her confusion towards his character. She has seen him contradict the image that she has made of him in her mind. She realized that Abeer is a good person, and thinks that maybe, what Abeer said, was true. She wants to believe him. She took a step towards him. Even I thought that the things were fast paced between them, but then, I realized that this was necessary. :)

We should be happy that Amala took a step towards her life, but then unfortunately, she was pulled back by her past.

Another harsh truth, people wanted the love story to start when there was not even the scope of it, but then they are questioning the makers when the love story has started!

Exactly! 👏

It's Abeer's fault here too. He should have boosted her to fight back. But I'm happy that he tried to make her move on.

You said it all!
Every single word is at the point.
@Bold - Exactly! It's the current track. Amla's running away and softening towards him was just to show that Abeer was no more the wrong one in her eyes. But that can't change the fact that she was raped. Justice needs to be given. It's the only way for her to move on.
Edited by -abz- - 8 years ago
Klaustrophillic thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 8 years ago
#36

Originally posted by: -abz-

Exactly! 👏

It's Abeer's fault here too. He should have boosted her to fight back. But I'm happy that he tried to make her move on.

You said it all!
Every single word is at the point.
@Bold - Exactly! It's the current track. Amla's running away and softening towards him was just to show that Abeer was no more the wrong one in her eyes. But that can't change the fact that she was raped. Justice needs to be given. It's the only way for her to move on.


Maybe now, they are trying to develop things between Amala and Abeer. You need to be close to someone to understand them properly. Maybe, by developing the bond between them now, they might show how Abeer, being close to her, realizes that all that she needs right now is "Justice", and maybe then, they will show the things moving towards it. They might have changed how the things will move on, but the basic plot remains the same. :)
TomNJerry... thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#37

Originally posted by: -abz-

Yes exactly!
Abeer is facing a subtle wrath in comparison to Kerim.
We need to accept the show, the writers know better. We can't jump into conclusions!

No doubt we are already loving the show dear and agree writers know better but their execution of most important scenes these days needs much improvement, and I guess suggesting them about it will only bring positive changes in the show 😳...so dont think I am having negativity about our beautiful show...its just a sort of constructive criticism...😊
wow123 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#38

Originally posted by: meerab...

AmBeer scenes were a big surprise today😊...they look so perfect together😳...their smiles😃...their comfort😉...their naughtiness was all to die for...

But now coming to the other side of story🥱...

As far as we all know its a remake and sadly its no more looking like that...makers are dragging every track,creating lots of tamasha but when its comes to AmBeer they are rushing their emotional progress😡...are they confuse or what that how Amala's character should behave...how she should act in certain situations😔...Amala was almost broken after knowing Dev's truth...Abeer gave him gyaan about being happy...she get it right and was trying to be happy...the little morning staring session between AmBeer was cute and ok...even lunch plan was good too but what about Amala doing all khekhekhekhe as manu said😆...I know she was trying to be happy but that way like she and Abeer had just a small fight or misunderstanding and now they are ok with everything😕...

I know most will not agree but many times Amala's character is out of flow...one moment she cries like hell next moment she is like she is the happiest girl ever😲...one moment she is showing her deep hatred towards Abeer and next moment she is like chalo its ok he is my sweetest hubby now😳...

Yes we all want AmBeer scenes😛...love to see them together and happy but with such rush of Amala's feelings or emotions I couldn't connect to her🥱 ...I dont feel she is playing a victim anymore🤢...

I feel Abeer is somewhere close to Kerim but Amala's character is nowhere close to FG😒...FG had shown such a power packed version of a victim that one could feel her trauma...her emotions...her fears...her struggles...her efforts...regarding Kerim despite all the good what he kept on doing😵...

It was Kerim's character who won FG by his utmost patience😳...Abeer is doing the same😛...But I couldn't see Amala's struggles as FG...today was one example of this...she was in lala land then Suveer news suddenly remind her where she stands in her life...then at home she cried a bit and then when Evaan knocked the door she was coming like she never cried and is very much ok...and on monday suddenly she will be back to her divorce mission...so unpredictable...

Pankhuri and Rajveer are perfectly portraying whatever script is given to them infact all actors are but writers and makers should keep all details in mind that they are working on a worldwide popular project⭐️⭐️⭐️...their little mistakes of showing unnecessary twists and bipolar disorder of Amala is gonna ruin it at some point
...despite their all hardwork and efforts...




Well u said everything that I want to say. The gradual process of main character from vulnerable raped victim to independent girl was shown beautifully in fatmagul series. Here I am not able to understand her state of mind.

Her(fatmagul) initial facial expression before the trials start shown her daily struggle to overcome the nightmare. Her frustration, irritation, struggle, sorrow and helplessness shown in trying get hold of her life from drawn into depression. Until she find hope of justice when Kerim surrender himself and confessed that crime happened with her.

Yeah I feel the main essence that is journey of rape victim is missing.


wow123 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#39

Originally posted by: 1Rockstar1

The only complaint is hv from this show is the process between AmBeer should slow down;
I don't want Amla to be spiteful towards Abeer anymore like in FG fatmagul was way too much spiteful towards Kerim; I want Amla to start believing Abeer and behave cordially with him



Well yes Fatmagul was more spiteful towards Kerim as he fall pray to all her hatred and frustration but I also believe that it help her in beautiful way as he took away all the poison gathered in her from that night, silently and patiently with his love and care.

I love that from where they started and where they end up. Simply these words are true for them

"they have impossible Love"
Edited by wow123 - 8 years ago
TomNJerry... thumbnail
12th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 8 years ago
#40

Originally posted by: wow123



Well yes Fatmagul was more spiteful towards Kerim as he fall pray to all her hatred and frustration but I also believe that it help her in beautiful way as he took away all the poison gathered in her from that night, silently and patiently with his love and care.

I love that from where they started and where they end up. Simply these words are true for them

"they have impossible Love"

yes that was the most beautiful thing about FG...she was harsh to the extremes with no hope of loving someone again...but it was Kerim's unconditional love,support and faith in their relationship that melted FG...their journey was simply perfect...

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".