Amala-Abeer...what the hell?? - Page 9

Created

Last reply

Replies

144

Views

22.1k

Users

28

Likes

385

Frequent Posters

risha_krp thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#81

Originally posted by: jey3ram

I watched Fatamgul loved the character of fatmagul...

But i never ever imagined that they gonna remake this story...the actress portrayed fatmagul lived in that character...

Is it a remake...then why they do remake of this story when the same story has been telecast ed in hindi in zindagi channel...

whether they gonna change it according our indian law???

Cox fatmagul got justice after three years something...even she became pregnant or mother of a child that time...But finally she got justice...

I really wanna watch this story according to Indian Law...If it was a mere Remake then they will copy the exact storyline of fatmagul...

So someone clarify me...whether they gonna change it accordingly to Indian law...Since In our country there are many such incidents happening and recently India Became third place in the world in crimes against women especially Rape and physical abuse...

And someone who watched fatmagul please throw some light on this...how this show so far...Amla's acting sense...Thank you in advance..



@Bold: I didn't understand this law part..
How does the storyline depend on the Turkish's law system?
JaZzs thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 90 Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#82

Originally posted by: rsharan



@Bold: I didn't understand this law part..
How does the storyline depend on the Turkish's law system?


check the thread kerim and fatmagul marriage happened how? swenna10's comment...he/she has written about the law system...
Edited by -JaZ- - 8 years ago
sujairohit thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#83

Originally posted by: jey3ram

I watched Fatamgul loved the character of fatmagul...

But i never ever imagined that they gonna remake this story...the actress portrayed fatmagul lived in that character...

Is it a remake...then why they do remake of this story when the same story has been telecast ed in hindi in zindagi channel...

whether they gonna change it according our indian law???

Cox fatmagul got justice after three years something...even she became pregnant or mother of a child that time...But finally she got justice...

I really wanna watch this story according to Indian Law...If it was a mere Remake then they will copy the exact storyline of fatmagul...

So someone clarify me...whether they gonna change it accordingly to Indian law...Since In our country there are many such incidents happening and recently India Became third place in the world in crimes against women especially Rape and physical abuse...

And someone who watched fatmagul please throw some light on this...how this show so far...Amla's acting sense...Thank you in advance..

Even I have watched the show fatmagul on Zindagi.Even now whenever I have time I also watch the repeat being shown at 12pm and 7 pm.The actress Beren saat who played Fatmagul was excellent and I also became fan of Engin akyurek the actor who plays Kerim.
So out of curiousity started to watch this remake and to my surprise I am really enjoying it even though its scene to scene copy from the original.The best part is all the actors selected suit the role to T.Even Pankhury as Amala is very good and now i even like rajveer singh the actor who plays Abeer.
SStephy thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 8 years ago
#84
I get that Abeer didn't rape Amala. But wouldn't Amala get married to Abeer thinking that he is a rapist? So wouldn't it be the typical 'marry your rapist' punishment for her? She possibly wouldn't have come out of her trauma and would be compelled to get into a marriage she wouldn't be ready for and that too with the person who is 'supposed' to be her rapist. And it is this point that makes me question the show's concept... considering the sensitive nature of the issue.

Other than that I don't mind Abeer and Amala marrying and becoming end-game if it was shown to happen after Amala gets to know the truth and after she gets to mentally heal from this tragedy, move on in her life and then gradually falling in love with Abeer.

Disclaimer: The above is purely my personal opinion as a viewer and is not intended to hurt anyone's sentiments.
pallavi25 thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Trailblazer Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 8 years ago
#85

Originally posted by: WaitForIt-

Yes, I get your point- you don't think Abeer is a culprit because he didn't physically rape Amala- good for you. But I'm not convinced- I still don't think he's not at fault here- FOR ME, he is at fault too. And him refusing to surrender himself now makes it worse for me. And no, I don't take the excuse of him being under the influence of drugs and alcohol- he ain't no gullible 10 year old kid who has no idea what he's doing, he's a grown up man with some sense and responsibilities- if he can't handle drugs and alcohol then don't bloody consume them.

Btw, thank you for the unasked for advice- "if you don't like it, don't watch it"- don't you think I know that already? I will watch and stop as I please, but I still hold the right to express my opinion so let me. I could very well ask you to stop posting in this topic as well if you don't like it, but I won't because I respect everyone's freedom of speech and opinion. I was not here to mock people, I was here to express my opinion and have a healthy discussion about the show- am I allowed to do that even if our opinions might vary?


Abeer is very much at fault, he literally threw Amla to the wolves, he drew the attention of his scoundrel friends towards Amla in the first place, he grabbed her when she was trying to run away from them that night. Hes responsible for starting the ghastly gang rape, and he knows very well that hes guilty though he cannot remember that he didnt actually rape her but his friends only did.

He doesnt listen to the enraged, impassioned pleas of Maaso who brought him up, who is the maternal figure in his life, he completely resists her attempts to drag him to the police station, he even disconnects the phone when she tries to call the police yet when Viren Mama comes and calls him he follows him like an obedient puppy. 🤢
I hate how hes going on sniffling and crying...what a loser!

He readily allowed himself to be brainwashed and manipulated by the disgusting Maliks and Viren, he agreed to whatever they say, he didnt oppose his scoundrel friends when they lied and blatantly denied they were even out with him that night, but not a word of protest from Abeer.
Seems like Abeer cant even speak, most of the time hes silent and crying, Hes a despicable guy!

Hes actually protecting his rapist friends, and ignoring his Maaso who is really trying to make him do the right thing. Hes just a puppet in the hands of his rich friends and their families.
AladdinKaChirag thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#86
I don't agree with the fact that if abeer's friends weren't drunk, they wouldn't have raped amala.. They were absolute bas***ds and judging by what i saw, they all knew what they were doing. As for abeer, it was evident that he took drugs for the first time or he rarely takes drugs as he looked the most lost, even mentally unstable. So yea i won't take him as a culprit of rape coz he wouldn't have imagined that his friends would stoop so low.
But yea now abeer is definitely at fault, he is protecting his friends! Maybe in the future he might redeem himself coz i heard in fatmagul kerim himself lodged a complaint in the future and helps her get justice.
shinesss thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#87

Originally posted by: pallavi25


Abeer is very much at fault, he literally threw Amla to the wolves, he drew the attention of his scoundrel friends towards Amla in the first place, he grabbed her when she was trying to run away from them that night. Hes responsible for starting the ghastly gang rape, and he knows very well that hes guilty though he cannot remember that he didnt actually rape her but his friends only did.

He doesnt listen to the enraged, impassioned pleas of Maaso who brought him up, who is the maternal figure in his life, he completely resists her attempts to drag him to the police station, he even disconnects the phone when she tries to call the police yet when Viren Mama comes and calls him he follows him like an obedient puppy. 🤢
I hate how hes going on sniffling and crying...what a loser!

He readily allowed himself to be brainwashed and manipulated by the disgusting Maliks and Viren, he agreed to whatever they say, he didnt oppose his scoundrel friends when they lied and blatantly denied they were even out with him that night, but not a word of protest from Abeer.
Seems like Abeer cant even speak, most of the time hes silent and crying, Hes a despicable guy!

Hes actually protecting his rapist friends, and ignoring his Maaso who is really trying to make him do the right thing. Hes just a puppet in the hands of his rich friends and their families.


Completely agree with this.
I have not watched FG...but know the story...I watched KQHAK, 1st or 2nd episode... I found only Amla interesting... Did nt like Dev or Abeer... and I decided not to go on with this show...after few days...while surfing channels I saw Abeer crying and then i started watching...i dont know, but i liked this crying Abeer...I am watching from that point... I must say... Abeer did not rape her, but he is the reason the whole incident happened...

As the above TM mentioned, he is not doing anything that you can say is "Right" thing to do. He is not going to Police, he is not allowing his Masso to do anything... he knows his friends are at fault ...Still he is getting manipulated by Viren...

For all this only one explanation I get... Abeer is in real mess in his mind and heart...
He got attracted towards a girl romantically... he liked that girl...he did not fall in love or something...but it was very much in the initial stage... And suddenly this horrific thing happened with her...and because of whom? its him and he knows that its because of him...he feels guilty, he feels terrible... he does not know what to do...he never would have thought his friends will stoop so low...leave about his friends...he could not believe that he can stoop to this level... he is fighting a battle within himself...he is not in a sane state of mind... he is weak now...he is confused...and that is not helping him at all to come out of this situation...

If he would have stayed some days alone or with his Masso...I think, he should have made peace with himself and decided something...or may be he would have gone to police...But here, Viren is there to manipulate the situation... he is pushing thoughts to Abeer's mind...like what will happen to Amla...who ll maary her...what society will call her etc etc... And I guess he will marry her in this state of mind... I am not justifying his actions...but just trying to go into this character's mind...

He is in the lowest phase now...he has to get over this phase... and he will rise after that...I think Amla's state, her anger, her grief...all these going to push him towards becoming a good man, who is not a coward. First step for all this has to be Abeer fully confident that he did not rape... he has to be in his right mind to think and decide that he and his friends are at fault and they should be punished. I do not know how and when he will fall in love with her... leave about Amla loving him... But I guess thats what we should wait for and watch...

Its not about whether we should ship Amla and Abeer or not...we absolutely should not love Abeer with Amla right now...Its the responsibility of Abeer to make us ship him with Amla...He has to gain confidence of not only Amla but we viewers as well to love Ambeer... 😊

And friends whoever liking Ambeer from now, I am sure they have seen Karim's journey and they love him...here Karim is Abeer. So they are loving Abeer.

Rest of us who have not seen Karim, we should and we should hate Abeer right now...


shalluuu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#88
shinesss
Very good explanation about abeer chrctr...i m also loving chrctr of abeer and ofcourse rajveer singh too ...infact he is turning point of this story ...he is the main wheel of this story ...Everyone do blunderss but how many actually accept ...he has accepted what he did ...even he is worried for girl with whom he did wrong ...he is worried for his friend with whom he spent wonderful days ...he is the only one who saw amla in hospital...there are so many points regarding this character...when it comes to maso parents always scold their children and that too maso did with abeer n now abeer is even guilt of all his mistake ...i want abeer to marry amla n i want him to b reason of amla justice ...its not amla i feel pity on abeer due to his friend behaviour...so i want justice with both chrctr n malik sons behind bars...
shalluuu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#89
When it comes to JUSTICE...i dont have any trust on starplus after naamkaran

Aaj tak avni ko justice nahi mila how n when amla will get justice

This time main attraction for me in show is rajveer singh n if the show will have lots of drama ...definitly i will leave at mid
Edited by shalluuu - 8 years ago
avifan123 thumbnail
Posted: 8 years ago
#90
hi i am new here...read the whole debate...but this statement is the best by princess200...we love the pair of abeer and amala ...to helll with the story...they make a hot couple ...we watch tv for entertainment...and this couple provides it...awareness shavrness we teach our girls to stay out of danger, avoid late nights , avoid skin showing clothes at inappropriate places and the usual no no's our society has chalked out...😊

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".