This may seem like I am bashing Karan, but I am not!

TheM5393 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#1

Okay, so I don't know how many of u have actually watched today's episode but I am finding the whole Karan taunting and blaming and mansplaining Preeta about everything getting on my nerves a little bit. He blamed Preeta for joining hands with Prithvi to kidnap Rishabh. How lower are the makers going to make him stoop? I know Karan is right in his judgement of Prithvi but that doesn't mean he has the right to blame Preeta for everything that is wrong in his life! It is especially irritating because he hasn't even apologised once for any of the humiliation he has bestowed on her!


sorry for the ranting....😆

Created

Last reply

Replies

71

Views

3.4k

Users

7

Likes

143

Frequent Posters

_Runa_ thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#2

Karan has a verbal diarrhea😆

And, yes, it irritates.

I think that Karan talks bad about Preeta out of helplessness and anger. He desperately wants to "unsee" all bad things that had stolen his "good" Preeta from him. And now he should deal with this "bad" Preeta what he doesn't want to believe but have to. I don't know if I explain it well. It's hard to write correct words. Karan is very complicated character))

It's like insulting Preeta he is trying to convince himself that his judgment is correct and he didn't make a mistake. While deep inside he badly wants her to give him back and prove him wrong. And then he can get his "good" Preeta back.

He has that bad logic😆

Dil dimag ki nahin sunta, dimag dil ki nahin sunta.

TheM5393 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: _Runa_

Karan has a verbal diarrhea😆

And, yes, it irritates.

I think that Karan talks bad about Preeta out of helplessness and anger. He desperately wants to "unsee" all bad things that had stolen his "good" Preeta from him. And now he should deal with this "bad" Preeta what he doesn't want to believe but have to. I don't know if I explain it well. It's hard to write correct words. Karan is very complicated character))

It's like insulting Preeta he is trying to convince himself that his judgment is correct and he didn't make a mistake. While deep inside he badly wants her to give him back and prove him wrong. And then he can get his "good" Preeta back.

He has that bad logic😆

Dil dimag ki nahin sunta, dimag dil ki nahin sunta.

I think I understand, so u r trying to say it is his 'feelings' towards Preeta and his 'egotistic maniac' side who are fighting together, internally. I get it, he is DEFINITELY a very, very complex and complicated character. But SOMETIMES I have these feelings and mind you those 'sometimes' are occuring more 'often'. I just feel like doing some oddly violent things to him. 🤬

Apologies for the rant I just needed somewhere to blow off steam. 😃

Edited by TheM5393 - 5 years ago
anandhi007 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#4

Karan is a complex character and not straightforward like Rishab or preeta or anyone else in the show. He is a temperamental egomaniac. His anger and ego are his Achilles heels. His redemption track will prolly focus on that. And as far as preeta goes, it's like she respects Rishab and is attracted to or maybe actually started to like Karan as more than a friend because of everything he did for her. But I completely get where you are coming and yeah,the way he is been behaving since about rishab's wedding is pretty toxic. Like initially it was understandable because he failed to save Rishab from sherlyn so he was taking his anger out on preeta. After that it was out right absurd and obnoxious. So he believes that preeta wouldn't have harmed mahira who she has absolutely no relationship with and is actually her rival but he doesn't believe that she had nothing to do with Mahesh's condition whom she considers as her own father? Then again Karan isn't essentially a bad person, he wanted to expose prithvi more badly than sherlyn and he was actually doing it because be cared for her. And the difference between Karan and Rishab is that Karan is always willing to go over the edge to help people close to him. He lets his temper get over him most times and the fact that he is an egomaniac doesn't help either and it's terrible combo.

Again back to preeta, she is a little innocent in the romance and relationship stuff. Besides the reason why I think there's possibility of Rishab and preeta at some point is because at the end of the day preeta isn't someone's who marries just for love or something. All she wants is someone who respects her and someone she can trust. And Rishab ticks both these boxes and both of them value family and responsibilities. Like Rishab fulfills his responsibilities towards sherlyn no matter what. It feels a little like rishab's love for preeta has turned into total respect as a really good friend. So to me it feels like even if Rishab and preeta get married ( after Karan giving his blessings to Rishab and his family is not entirely against it) it'd still be temporary. Because as compatible as they are they aren't as passionate or they don't challenge each other at all and no matter whether srishti says something or not preeta still feels different around Karan and srishti just exaggerates it and tries to make her understand. And Rishab cannot instill those feelings in her. At the end of the day you can have a friend who gets and understands you but you need to have a partner who does that and challenges you. And when I meant challenge I don't mean Karan's fights or anything :3 like srishti and sameer are compatible and a little childish but they still have that spark. the only other shows I have watched are bade ache lagte Hain and kkb so in balh, ram and Priya essentially have the same beliefs and qualities except for the fact that he is rich. But they still challenged each other though they were very compatible. It's like that. Sometimes I just feel like they should introduce a new character who has the best qualities of both the Luthra brothers combined. I really like rishab-preeta together even more than preeran tbh,I just wish they had shown passion there as well in a different way.

Then again at the end of the day, it depends on what the cvs are trying to go for. KB is different in the sense that unlike other shows even after like 700 episodes we are still on the fence about who is the main couple. So if ekta wanted to show something different like a relationship of just immense respect and understanding then Rishab would be it. But knowing ekta,she mostly sticks to the cliches. Let's see. And I am really really really really sorry for the rant guysss,just have so much to say😭

_Runa_ thumbnail
9th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: TheM5393

I think I understand, so u r trying to say it is his 'feelings' towards Preeta and his 'egotistic maniac' side who are fighting together, internally. I get it, he is DEFINITELY a very, very complex and complicated character. But SOMETIMES I have these feelings and mind you those 'sometimes' are occuring more 'often'. I just feel like doing some oddly violent things to him. 🤬

Apologies for the rant I just needed somewhere to blow off steam. 😃

I am sure you are not alone having those feelings 😄

Yes, I mean that is where his aggression comes from.

It wasn't a random flashback during the lockdown episode when Rishabh said that Karan wants Preeta to come and break his engagement. Karan does want it! He wants Preeta to solve it all right and give him solid evidence of her innocence. His ego stops him from doing it himself.

He is angry with his turmoil and with Preeta as well. Not because she is a criminal. But because she couldn't prove her innocence. He instigates himself every day remembering "Preeta yeh, Preeta woh..." to maintain his anger and ego.

That's how I feel about him now.

Every single good person in his house believes Preeta. Except Karan. It's like he is playing for the villains' team now. I think we have a right to complain😁

TheM5393 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: anandhi007

Karan is a complex character and not straightforward like Rishab or preeta or anyone else in the show. He is a temperamental egomaniac. His anger and ego are his Achilles heels. His redemption track will prolly focus on that. And as far as preeta goes, it's like she respects Rishab and is attracted to or maybe actually started to like Karan as more than a friend because of everything he did for her. But I completely get where you are coming and yeah,the way he is been behaving since about rishab's wedding is pretty toxic. Like initially it was understandable because he failed to save Rishab from sherlyn so he was taking his anger out on preeta. After that it was out right absurd and obnoxious. (1)So he believes that preeta wouldn't have harmed mahira who she has absolutely no relationship with and is actually her rival but he doesn't believe that she had nothing to do with Mahesh's condition whom she considers as her own father? Then again Karan isn't essentially a bad person, he wanted to expose prithvi more badly than sherlyn and he was actually doing it because be cared for her. And the difference between Karan and Rishab is that Karan is always willing to go over the edge to help people close to him. He lets his temper get over him most times and the fact that he is an egomaniac doesn't help either and it's terrible combo.

Again back to preeta, she is a little innocent in the romance and relationship stuff. Besides the reason why I think there's possibility of Rishab and preeta at some point is because at the end of the day preeta isn't someone's who marries just for love or something. All she wants is someone who respects her and someone she can trust. And Rishab ticks both these boxes and both of them value family and responsibilities. (2)Like Rishab fulfills his responsibilities towards sherlyn no matter what. It feels a little like rishab's love for preeta has turned into total respect as a really good friend. So to me it feels like even if Rishab and preeta get married ( after Karan giving his blessings to Rishab and his family is not entirely against it) it'd still be temporary. Because as compatible as they are they aren't as passionate or they don't challenge each other at all and no matter whether srishti says something or not preeta still feels different around Karan and srishti just exaggerates it and tries to make her understand. And Rishab cannot instill those feelings in her. At the end of the day you can have a friend who gets and understands you but you need to have a partner who does that and challenges you. And when I meant challenge I don't mean Karan's fights or anything :3 like srishti and sameer are compatible and a little childish but they still have that spark. the only other shows I have watched are bade ache lagte Hain and kkb so in balh, ram and Priya essentially have the same beliefs and qualities except for the fact that he is rich. But they still challenged each other though they were very compatible. It's like that. Sometimes I just feel like they should introduce a new character who has the best qualities of both the Luthra brothers combined. I really like rishab-preeta together even more than preeran tbh,I just wish they had shown passion there as well in a different way.

(3)Then again at the end of the day, it depends on what the cvs are trying to go for. KB is different in the sense that unlike other shows even after like 700 episodes we are still on the fence about who is the main couple. So if ekta wanted to show something different like a relationship of just immense respect and understanding then Rishab would be it. But knowing (4)ekta,she mostly sticks to the cliches. Let's see. And I am really really really really sorry for the rant guysss,just have so much to say😭


DON'T BE SORRY!! This is amazing! The FORUM IS FINALLY ALIVE!


This is exactly the sort of discussion I have always wanted to have. I mean clearly we see the show in two very different perspectives but that is GREAT. Which means that for one the makers are successful in what they were trying to do but also in the sense that there is so much more to agree and disagree on.😃


So coming to the bold part (1)- Karan is complex but he is also simple in the sense that he believes what he see's and once he see's he can't unsee. Also, he is a little classist and a egomaniac like Kareena, but once he makes a commitment he tries his best to keep his end of the bargain. HOWEVER, just like Kareena, Karan can also do anything for his family. Although, one could say that his Achilles heel is his ego, but his true strength and weekness is Rishabh. Similar to how Rishabh and Preeta's true weekness and strength are their mother's for Shrishti and Karan it is their respective older sibling. Now, coming to the point of Karan believing Preeta did not push Mahira but he believed that Preeta pushed Mahesh has two-fold reason. First of all Mahira during that entire track played it really smart, she herself did NOT directly blame Preeta for anything, it was technically Sherlyn but even more importantly Karan found it easier to believe that Preeta wouldn't go to that level of extreme for him. Hence, although he was initially confused he did ultimately change his mind the SINGLE moment at the police station when he saw that the evidence for 're-arresting' Preeta was brought by none other than Sherlyn. Karan has been like this from the very beginning, I mean he did NOT believe Preeta when she said Sherlyn was the one who mixed rat poison in her own engagement but when he found evidence himself that Sherlyn did what she did he has not trusted her since. But the issue regarding Mahesh is a lot simpler. As I have already said Karan is a lot like Kareena, he is classist and he believes people that he believes. Mahira is one of the people that he believes, because at the end of the day she IS HIS CHILDHOOD friend AND FAN. When Mahira directly blamed Preeta for pushing Mahesh Luthra he had no reason to not believe her.

(2) Rishabh and Preeta are basically the male and female versions of each other. I believe if only practicality, compatibility and realistic criteria for a successful life partner is what they had to choose from Rishabh and Preeta would choose each other, but ALAS, this is not a realistic life partner show. This show is called 'Kundali Bhagya' aka Horoscope Fate or Fate and horoscope, however one wants to put it. The reality is Karan has because of Preeta's fate entered in her life. As we have all seen for over a year now it has not been a very good fate for her. 😭 The probability of Rishabh and Preeta marrying each other while Karan is still alive is absurd and impossible. Rishabh would NEVER in a million years do that to Karan. There is a reason why the makers have shown him to be a PreeRan shipper. Similarly, I genuinely believe becoming a RishTa shipper is the path he would take as his redemption. But Preeta isn't a toy or a trophy to be exchanged between two brothers. SHE SHOULD LEAVE THEM BOTH AT THAT POINT.

(3) Kundali Bhagya is different in the sense that despite the constant fake promotional barage of Karan and Preeta and all the award functions and the ridiculous amount of fan-service for Karan and Preeta fans in the show without any heed to the plot, they still end up showing very moving and truly emotional scenes between Rishabh and Preeta. As thou they don't want it to die for some reason.

(4) Ekta does stick to cliches. check out her love triangles they are basically all the same.

Cheers👍🏼

jasminerahul thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#7

preeran at the end couple for sure.that's why they removed rishab from the montage n promoting preeran everywhere.they won best Jodi award also


Originally posted by: anandhi007

Karan is a complex character and not straightforward like Rishab or preeta or anyone else in the show. He is a temperamental egomaniac. His anger and ego are his Achilles heels. His redemption track will prolly focus on that. And as far as preeta goes, it's like she respects Rishab and is attracted to or maybe actually started to like Karan as more than a friend because of everything he did for her. But I completely get where you are coming and yeah,the way he is been behaving since about rishab's wedding is pretty toxic. Like initially it was understandable because he failed to save Rishab from sherlyn so he was taking his anger out on preeta. After that it was out right absurd and obnoxious. So he believes that preeta wouldn't have harmed mahira who she has absolutely no relationship with and is actually her rival but he doesn't believe that she had nothing to do with Mahesh's condition whom she considers as her own father? Then again Karan isn't essentially a bad person, he wanted to expose prithvi more badly than sherlyn and he was actually doing it because be cared for her. And the difference between Karan and Rishab is that Karan is always willing to go over the edge to help people close to him. He lets his temper get over him most times and the fact that he is an egomaniac doesn't help either and it's terrible combo.

Again back to preeta, she is a little innocent in the romance and relationship stuff. Besides the reason why I think there's possibility of Rishab and preeta at some point is because at the end of the day preeta isn't someone's who marries just for love or something. All she wants is someone who respects her and someone she can trust. And Rishab ticks both these boxes and both of them value family and responsibilities. Like Rishab fulfills his responsibilities towards sherlyn no matter what. It feels a little like rishab's love for preeta has turned into total respect as a really good friend. So to me it feels like even if Rishab and preeta get married ( after Karan giving his blessings to Rishab and his family is not entirely against it) it'd still be temporary. Because as compatible as they are they aren't as passionate or they don't challenge each other at all and no matter whether srishti says something or not preeta still feels different around Karan and srishti just exaggerates it and tries to make her understand. And Rishab cannot instill those feelings in her. At the end of the day you can have a friend who gets and understands you but you need to have a partner who does that and challenges you. And when I meant challenge I don't mean Karan's fights or anything :3 like srishti and sameer are compatible and a little childish but they still have that spark. the only other shows I have watched are bade ache lagte Hain and kkb so in balh, ram and Priya essentially have the same beliefs and qualities except for the fact that he is rich. But they still challenged each other though they were very compatible. It's like that. Sometimes I just feel like they should introduce a new character who has the best qualities of both the Luthra brothers combined. I really like rishab-preeta together even more than preeran tbh,I just wish they had shown passion there as well in a different way.

Then again at the end of the day, it depends on what the cvs are trying to go for. KB is different in the sense that unlike other shows even after like 700 episodes we are still on the fence about who is the main couple. So if ekta wanted to show something different like a relationship of just immense respect and understanding then Rishab would be it. But knowing ekta,she mostly sticks to the cliches. Let's see. And I am really really really really sorry for the rant guysss,just have so much to say😭

TheM5393 thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: jasminerahul

preeran at the end couple for sure.that's why they removed rishab from the montage n promoting preeran everywhere.they won best Jodi award also


What if they are not? will u be upset?

jasminerahul thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#9

no.from the beginning onwards I love both the jodies.but even in articles they are saying only about preeran.so it's clear


Originally posted by: TheM5393

What if they are not? will u be upset?

anandhi007 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 5 years ago
#10

I just saw yesterday's episode,I was still hoping that maybe he was just kidding to rile her up like he always does so she'd untie him but no. I keep Making excuses for him thinking it's his father so maybe once he gets a perspective he'll redeem. But the cvs have made his character so hard to like. But more than him I dislike preeta more. She is a freaking doctor but she never defends herself using logic and circumstances, it's always emotional and crying and begging Karan to trust her. Rishab is bearable but would still not want him with preeta as long as Karan is in the picture coz that'd be wrong. And they are really good as friends,they should remain that way. They could be each other's well wishers. But since it's Kundali so maybe there's a possibility of them saying this was what's written in the stars or something. Also Correct me if I am wrong but at the end of the day kdb is about two sisters and their fates right? Why do they always make it just about one sister and the other being just supporting or something? They did the same with kkb as well,made it all about pragya after a look which is why the actor playing bulbul quit as there's no growth.

Now they have sidelined Sammy and srishti which means there's gonna be a huge dramatic track involving them as well, I have a feeling by then preeta would be super cold and icy to luthras magically somehow making things harder for them. Or she finally gains perspective says screw you to them after they treat her sister or something :3 but she couldn't even do that when her mother was insulted,so let's see. Sorry this rant went a little off the track. I am pissed off with the way they're showing everything and at the same thing curious to see where they are taking it.

Related Topics

Kundali Bhagya Thumbnail

Posted by: jasminerahul

1 months ago

Chal Mere Bhai ( Come on, brother) Karan Preeta Rishab

Chal Mere Bhai ( Come on, brother) Part 1 I dedicate this SS to my dearest friend Salley who asked me to write a PreeRan Rishab Tejasswi Prakash...

Expand ▼
Kundali Bhagya Thumbnail

Posted by: jasminerahul

4 months ago

Fanboy:Shaurya Preeta Karan Palki SS

Fanboy Part 1 The concept of this SS is inspired by the malayalam movie 'Maanathe vellitheru' which is a psychological thriller.But this SS...

Expand ▼
Kundali Bhagya Thumbnail

Posted by: wws1473

9 months ago

Kundali bhagya went off air...it was not proper ending too

Shaurya is not even aware of his mother..even preetas memories didn't come back too... kareena was still against her too... what kind of show is...

Expand ▼
Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".