Good boy vs Bad boy

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Jahnvi

@adoreyou

Dazzler

Posted: 8 years ago

#21

Originally posted by: Parud78

@Rocking Jahnvi... No offence.. but i could say the same about Rishabh...

helping her find a Job.. Clearing her name in the Chori case... helping her family with 60k for the kumkum bhagya hall ( he over heard preeta and shrishti talk)...

Good folks can do all those things and help a girl... not seek/demand her love in return.. there are folks who are good and try to help others...

just because you help a girl does not mean ..that the girl should fall in love.. she could thank the guy . be grateful ... and give him Respect....

many a times Love can not be explained... so it is up to the girl to choose whom she will develop feelings for...

I am really tired of people saying karan is a Bad Boy... he has a heart of gold...

(apart from being rude to preeta during the earlier episodes)

the way he treats both the dadi's... his mom.. kritika... and finally how he adores..SAMEER..

PreeRan fans do not dislike Rishabh.. (btw i do like Rishabh as a character..he is by no means PERFECT though)

so i wish the show well and if RISHTA is the end game..well good luck to that team...

Firstly @pink when Rishabh found a job for Preeta he didnt know her well he just liked her nature.

@orange there's no character in the show who would have done the same to preeta which Rishabh did , so nobosy can just pick up someone and say that he would hve done that , in the show nobody would have a helped a girl like that he did , in case of karan its quite obvious that if we see anyone known to us ( we hate/love ) getting kidnapped by a group of goons we will help them atleast I will do it without even thinking twice so i said that every Luthra brother would have done the same.

@red when exactly did rishabh go to preeta and asked her to love him ?

@green from which aspect you are saying that he has a heart of gold , i didnt find a single episode regarding that , even i dont find Rishabh having a heart of gold , everyone has their flaws.

@blue nobody considers him perfect , i didnt do it in my comment to which you replied.

And same here if they go ahead with Preeran its okay good luck to the team , i will stop watching the show that dosent mean audience will quit it , i hope the make it up a better story.

Edited by RockingJahnvi - 8 years ago

Quote

Parud78

@Parud78

Navigator

Posted: 8 years ago

#22

Originally posted by: RockingJahnvi

Firstly @pink when Rishabh found a job for Preeta he didnt know her well he just liked her nature.
@orange there's no character in the show who would have done the same to preeta which Rishabh did , so nobosy can just pick up someone and say that he would hve done that , in the show nobody would have a helped a girl like that he did , in case of karan its quite obvious that if we see anyone known to us ( we hate/love ) getting kidnapped by a group of goons we will help them atleast I will do it without even thinking twice so i said that every Luthra brother would have done the same.
@red when exactly did rishabh go to preeta and asked her to love him ?
@green from which aspect you are saying that he has a heart of gold , i didnt find a single episode regarding that , even i dont find Rishabh having a heart of gold , everyone has their flaws.
@blue nobody considers him perfect , i didnt do it in my comment to which you replied.
And same here if they go ahead with Preeran its okay good luck to the team , i will stop watching the show that dosent mean audience will quit it , i hope the make it up a better story.

Simple answer..

Him helping Preeta ... he just fell in Love/Crush/Infatuation at first sight with Preeta so he helped her.. Big deal... There is no MAHANTA in that.. (he did those things cause he loves her)

while Karan does not love Preeta yet ( he hates her in his mind)

Rishabh did not go out of the way and help others in need he only helped preeta..

the rest of the points have already been explained earlier posts..

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Jahnvi

@adoreyou

Dazzler

Posted: 8 years ago

#23

Originally posted by: Parud78

Simple answer..

Him helping Preeta ... he just fell in Love/Crush/Infatuation at first sight with Preeta so he helped her.. Big deal... There is no MAHANTA in that.. (he did those things cause he loves her)

while Karan does not love Preeta yet ( he hates her in his mind)

Rishabh did not go out of the way and help others in need he only helped preeta..

the rest of the points have already been explained earlier posts..

" Rishabh met preeta , she was in need , rishabh helped preeta "

Again its not possible for a person to help everyone in need thats quite obvious because he dosent know about them afterall.

I also explained all my poinions regardng karan in the ealier posts , so not dragging the matter anymore.

Quote

sanju.b

@sanju.b

Navigator

Posted: 8 years ago

#24

first of all i don't get on what basis good & bad tag given to rishabh & karan... flirting with girls doesn't make him bad as he knows his limits
second not all good girls fall for bad boys as so called bad boys are not that bad (having flaws doesn't make someone bad).. based on shows i followed
third... ' something different' or ' Change needed good guy should get girl' this lines are used for rishta but there is nothing new we haven't seen already... there are lots of good guy- good girl couple like manav archana prem heer etc..just like we have many noke jhoke couples.. so its nothing new either ways ..
its just chemistry that matters..which karan & preeta have more for me.. thats it...

Edited by sanju.b - 8 years ago

Quote

CutelySimple

@CutelySimple

Navigator

Posted: 8 years ago

#25

Originally posted by: Val13
Point #1
Rishab has liked preeta from the moment he met her so everything he does is to impress her cause he is a "good guy" and karan is a bad boy and has hated preeta from the moment he met her yet still he helped her when she needed help the most, he has helped to defend her honor and correct me if I'm wrong but isn't that something an Indian girl treasure the most? He did that while he still hates her, he didn't do it because he wanted to impress her or get in her good grace because he is in love with her and wants her to love (although we know he is in love with her) but he doesn't know that yet so it doesn't count. His action of saving preeta actually proves he is an even better person than most because he doesn't have to like someone to help them he just helps people with the kindness of his heart.
Point #2
Rishab is in love with preeta for how many episodes now?
He has yet to confess his love to his mother/family, much less a confession to preeta, karan is not in love with preeta yet he has confessed twice if you count yesterday's discussion about preeta soft spot for karan in her heart. I'm just saying confidence is an attractive trait.

Point #3
If karan was to be eliminated from the show we would have a series filled with "preeta ji you are so nice" "preeta ji your heart is so sweet" "preeta ji you are beautiful" "Rishab ji you are so nice" "Rishab ji you are so good" and the ratings would be crap since no wants to see that all the time it would be like that hot song that's playing on the radio all the time, if you hear it enough times you start to get a headache. I hate to say it but Rishab is boring, he is a nice guy but he is boring.

Point #4
Preeta respects Rishab. she has not once had any other feelings for him but that of great RESPECT, every other kinds of feeling so far came from Rishab's side and not preeta, not even for a second.

Pehli gend par ball boundary ke bahar...completely agree with you

Quote

3dancelover

@3dancelover

Dazzler

Posted: 8 years ago

#26

Alright how about we end this topic before this turns into a full on fan war?

Everyone likes their own ship for own reasons and that is and always will be respected. Hence why they feel the other fandom is doing or thinking wrong. Just for the future try not to bash ANY of the characters because we have to understand they are purposefully written that way and there hasn't been that many episodes for us to completely decipher them yet.

I am only putting this out there cause I have a feeling the topic is going to be closed soon or someone is going to face consequences on IF from MOD and no one wants that.

Edited by 3dancelover - 8 years ago

Quote

MyShiningStar

@MyShiningStar

Navigator

Posted: 8 years ago

#27

I ship both... but i don't consider karan as a bad boy he's just immature

Quote

Aaliyah

@Cookies..

Voyager

+ 2

Posted: 8 years ago

#28

This back and forth really doesn't do much. Karan and Rishabh are both quite flawed characters although they are both very good guys at heart till this point in the show (we don't know about the future). There are certain traits that Rishabh has that Karan doesn't and likewise, there are certain things that Karan has which Rishabh doesn't. Flaws give the characters on paper a real dimension. But that doesn't mean that one is better than the other or if one is the "good boy", the other one is automatically the "bad boy". Not at all. They are good in their own rights and space. Without Rishabh, there is no Karan and without Karan, there is no Rishabh. They are brothers. They complete each other more than any girl can.

Having said all that, certain people will gravitate towards a certain type of couple. If people like a more sweet and simple love stories, they'd prefer RishTa. If people like more spice, intensity, and passion, they'd prefer PreeRan. It's a personal preference. It's not like one would change their personal preference and taste just because someone doesn't agree. So it's better to keep it civil because at the end of the day, you're gonna like who you like and Ekta Kapoor is gonna show what she wants to show period. Also, Karan is the spice in RishTa's story and Rishabh is the spice in PreeRans story. They all go hand in hand. So at the end of the day, whatever gets them the desired ratings are their way to go.

And just for the record, I prefer PreeRan as a couple over RishTa. But in real life, my personality traits are quite similar to Rishabh. But, as an audience, I prefer watching a love story like PreeRan. That's just me.

Quote

SunshineMk

@SunshineMk

Explorer

Posted: 8 years ago

#29

Originally posted by: 3dancelover
Alright how about we end this topic before this turns into a full on fan war?

Everyone likes their own ship for own reasons and that is and always will be respected. Hence why they feel the other fandom is doing or thinking wrong. Just for the future try not to bash ANY of the characters because we have to understand they are purposefully written that way and there hasn't been that many episodes for us to completely decipher them yet.

I am only putting this out there cause I have a feeling the topic is going to be closed soon or someone is going to face consequences on IF from MOD and no one wants that.

Yes please.

I think this topic has been discussed enough and everyone is going a little overboard to prove their points. All of us have our respective ships, let it stay that way, let's not bash each others ships and start a fan war.

This isn't the first post leading to this argument, there have been a lot more and we're all just going around in the same circle over and over again.

So can we just stop with this post, let's live and let live.

Quote

1 2 3

Good boy vs Bad boy - Page 3

Related Topics

Explore Topics