Created

Last reply

Replies

22

Views

2.6k

Users

12

Likes

41

Frequent Posters

Cerealgirl thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#11
She didn't leave just for her guilt. It was more complex than that. She did not then know what she knows now. She did the right thing for the baby, not for herself. And she's not back just to claim his property either.
She left trying to do the right thing for him then. And she's back to do the right thing now. One can argue he didn't nor does he need her help now. But surely the writers see it differently!!
nitarata thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: Cerealgirl

She didn't leave just for her guilt. It was more complex than that. She did not then know what she knows now. She did the right thing for the baby, not for herself. And she's not back just to claim his property either.

She left trying to do the right thing for him then. And she's back to do the right thing now. One can argue he didn't nor does he need her help now. But surely the writers see it differently!!


No, she did what she believed is right. First she said she is doing it for Daadi, TaBhi love... but by the time she left it was clear to her neither Daadi, nor Abhi wanted TaBhi marriage (she forced them all into it with using goodwill and love). So she did this for the baby and the guilt. She admitted to it.

And property I said from his POV for the pre cap line. Of course we all know she hasn't come for the property.
Zaalima_5 thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: Cerealgirl

She didn't leave just for her guilt. It was more complex than that. She did not then know what she knows now. She did the right thing for the baby, not for herself. And she's not back just to claim his property either.

She left trying to do the right thing for him then. And she's back to do the right thing now. One can argue he didn't nor does he need her help now. But surely the writers see it differently!!

yes whatever she did was right.actually she punished herself for abhi's mistake by sacrificing her love and wanted to gave name to that baby.she fulfilled her promise taken in marriage.
Cerealgirl thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: -Tia-


No, she did what she believed is right. First she said she is doing it for Daadi, TaBhi love... but by the time she left it was clear to her neither Daadi, nor Abhi wanted TaBhi marriage (she forced them all into it with using goodwill and love). So she did this for the baby and the guilt. She admitted to it.

And property I said from his POV for the pre cap line. Of course we all know she hasn't come for the property.


However we may want to phrase it, Pragya left because she wanted to do the right thing for the baby. And she also believed doing the right thing for the baby meant making sure the baby had a set of parents.
Cerealgirl thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: kulsum_5

yes whatever she did was right.actually she punished herself for abhi's mistake by sacrificing her love and wanted to gave name to that baby.she fulfilled her promise taken in marriage.


Very well said. Completely agree!
deefan thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#16
Abhi is asking why she couldn't choose to stay with him and enjoy the material benefits to his wealth, something that new Pragya is after. Very pointed question and straight to the point, cuts through the BS IMO.

I'm curious to see what she says- he's trying to get her to give out reasons for her changed avatar, the purpose behind her changed attitude.

Would she say she wants it all for herself, that she never loved him? Whatever she says, hope it's followed by some Abhigya angsty romance 😛
shubh20 thumbnail
11th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#17
Well! A good point to discuss.. Actually it's complicated and my view is a combination of both kinds of views being expressed in this post.. First pragya is good by nature and thereby she couldn't see the baby suffer without having a father.. Ok accepted.. Genuine it is.. Any woman with a conscience would have decided to do what pragya did.. Moving out from abhi's life.. But this is not the only way! Was she really concerned about the baby's future then she could have atleast thought of bringing up the baby herself with Abhi? Let us put aside the practicalities of this option.. Atleast once had she thought? She was claiming that dadi needs pota poti, uniting abhi with love etc etc.. Even after she found that both dadi and Abhi are not interested she didn't stop.. She started her guilt wala dialogue.. So she was concerned more about her guilt than the happiness of people related to this issue.. She literally forced everyone to accept to her decision.. If baby getting a father is the problem then as I said.. She could have well given a thought of parenting the baby herself.. She said when we have OUR child then when I see this child I will feel guilty! so she can't be that generous to claim the other woman's baby as hers right?
I am not bringing tanu into this discussion because she is a witch so no pity for her even if she remains unmarried after giving the baby to abhi and pragya (ofcourse whether she will accept to give the child is a separate point of discussion)

So pragya is right in certain aspects of deciding to give way for the baby and wrong in certain other aspects..
Edited by shubh-aarambh - 10 years ago
TeluguAmmayi thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 10 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: shubh-aarambh

Well! A good point to discuss.. Actually it's complicated and my view is a combination of both kinds of views being expressed in this post.. First pragya is good by nature and thereby she couldn't see the baby suffer without having a father.. Ok accepted.. Genuine it is.. Any woman with a conscience would have decided to do what pragya did.. Moving out from abhi's life.. But this is not the only way! Was she really concerned about the baby's future then she could have atleast thought of bringing up the baby herself with Abhi? Let us put aside the practicalities of this option.. Atleast once had she thought? She was claiming that dadi needs pota poti, uniting abhi with love etc etc.. Even after she found that both dadi and Abhi are not interested she didn't stop.. She started her guilt wala dialogue.. So she was concerned more about her guilt that the happiness of people related to this issue.. She literally forced everyone to accept to her decision.. If baby getting a father is the problem then as I said.. She could have well given a thought of parenting the baby herself.. She said when we have OUR child then when I see this child I will feel guilty! so she can't be that generous to claim the other woman's baby as hers right?

I am not bringing tanu into this discussion because she is a witch so no pity for her even if she remains unmarried after giving the baby to abhi and pragya (ofcourse whether she will accept to give the child is a separate point of discussion)

So pragya is right in certain aspects of deciding to give way for the baby and wrong in certain other aspects..



I agree with wat u wrote..

I don't expect her to mother Tanu's child subh..

I understand her leaving and her guilt is also okay..
Wat was not okay was using his love for her.
If u love me , marry Tanu.. I know he can abruptly say no to Pragya but he was helpless and was in love with her madly.

His situation was similar to Pragya situation when dadi asked her to do drama and hurt abhi for his sake.
She doesn't want it but is doing it for dadi and thinking it will save him.
Similarly he dint want it but he nodded for her because she said she will be happy if he takes care of Tanu baby.

Both can reject doing what they didn't like but they still noded and went on with it because they were cornered.

Regarding the precap , I don't feel bad for him. Yes he is in pain but Pragya was so much in pain too before because of him.

I am actually proud of him. He is behaving the best in this track.even after she snatching everything , he is still in love with her and wants her.He even wants te money mad Pragya.

Auroralights thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: -Tia-


No, that was not to save him. She left him because she could not deal with the guilt of coming between TaBhi baby and TaBhi.



So true. Abhi of course feels no such guilt. He simply agreed to marry his pregnant mistress at the behest of his beloved wife. He would readily have dumped Tannu and the baby he believes to be his, for a happily ever-after with Pragya.
Ismustranger thumbnail
10th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 10 years ago
#20
Abhi's question was smart question regarding pragya's new behaviour means he trying find out why did pragya change and what she wants we all know pragya will answer him rudely about love time will tell whether abhi's love for pragya is true or not

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".