Dilemma at KGH = Trouble in paradise - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

28

Views

2.1k

Users

13

Likes

70

Frequent Posters

aardhan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: vidyasabde

very good analysis.you do it so well.

nothing more to add to it.

Thanks Vidya. 😛 As a doctor, do you find this debate relevant? Do patients come first or rules and how do you make sure that a patient is not short changed? 🤓 And the issue of Nidhi's nomination could be considered borderine harassment in the work place, isn't it? 😳
aardhan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: SD812

Fab analysis Aarti 😊
Definitely Nidhi will go for this conference.We will get to see that next week.Khoobsurat track on it's way 😃

Thank you Shubhangi. 😃 I certainly hope it is the Khoobsurat track, because then the outcome will be positive,😳 because then some situation will come up where Nidhi will prove herself and Ashu will support Nidhi. 👍🏼 Finally somehow both will end up goingto the conference. I am once again looking forward to KTLK episodes. 😃
aardhan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: rrdsu

Brilliant Arti..

Like u mentioned nidhi should not have argued with ashu in coridor...i felt very sad too ashni arguing..specially in front of those girls... liked dining table convo..precap was little scary..chalo dekhte hai monday ko kya hota hai..

Thanks Heena. Nidhi is never tactful. Maybe with more experience, she will gain that maturity to understand what to say, how to say it, when to say and where to say.

All the scenes were well scripted, lets see how the debate concludes...
aardhan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: kaks0211

Top grade analysis Aarti.There definitely is a lot of change in Ashni arguments...Before they would just shout out their own POVs and neither would bother to try to understand each other...now that is not the case...Before it was always Nidhi who used to try and break the ice - but now Ashu does not wait for that...The dinner table convo was indeed very intelligently written and well displayed...A good episode overall - waiting to see how this takes off on monday and what will happen next week..

Glad you liked it Kakali. And I am happy that I am not the only one to realize the change in the tone of the Ashni arguments. 😳 Infact I find that what starts out as a fight, now-a-days quickly gets downgraded to an argument where both are expressing their POVs and both are even listening to each other.👍🏼 Finally they are able to settle their difference quickly and amicably, like they did the other night when the truth about the EMA came out and DD felt humiliated. Ashu pacified and apologized to Nidhi and she felt bad to have caused trouble to DD and herself decided to apologize. 😃

Ashu definitely gets restless when Nidhi is quiet. He may tease Nidhi for being a chatter-box but her silence hurts him. He has demonstrated this more than once. This simply shows how depended he has become on her.
aardhan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#15

Originally posted by: vyoman

Brilliant analysis as always aardhan.👍🏼 Wow... Now a days I am eagerly waiting to read your analysis... Superb. Totally agree with you. For me, it was a fantastic episode...with excellent dialogues, and subtle messages which is the hallmark of KTLK. I felt, according to their characters they behaved...

Thanks vyoman, I am flattered by your kind words. 😳

This situation is interesting and has been handled well, hope it continues like this till the end of this track. And hope KTLK CVs keep coming up with such enlightening tracks that raise some very valid issues. 😛
aardhan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: swati62

I love the way u analyse the episode . it makes u want to watch the episode again and pay attention to the things that u missed in the first place. Since my Hindi is not great the double meanings escape me often. I had loved ur previous post KP'S ART OF SUBTLETY.

Thanks Swati. And thanks for remembering my KP's art... post, if something like that comes up, I will make one of those posts as well. And I am happy these posts help you get a better grip on the dialogs. 😃
aardhan thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 12 years ago
#17

Originally posted by: ithasme

Good pov & analysis, aarti.. I liked the epi.. Ashni arguement ws valid & extremely well directed & scripted.. Aditi shud keep herself @ a distance when it comes to talking abt pvt. Life of ashni with nidhi... Ashu clearly told nidhi that he is ready to support her as a hubby bt as dean he needs to follow what CA-Dr.Dubey orders & rules... BB trying get the cat out in convo with ashni & HK ws superb.. Loved that dinning scene.. Must watch.. Yeh jagada new yr aane tak chalta rahega... As ktlk cvs follows monthly track policy...

Thanks Harshal. 😊 I liked the episode, it has raised a lot of questions that a working couple who work in the same place would probably face today. 👍🏼 And Nidhi is getting influenced by Aditi, but don't you think the same is happening with Ashu as well?

The only thing about Ashu's stance is that he has always told Nidhi to keep their private and professional lives separate and yet this time by keeping quiet isn't he supporting someone who is mixing up their personal and professional opinions? Will this not make Ashu appear like a hypocrite? 🤓 And if this was happening with another junior staff, would Ashu still maintain silence or talk to DD on behalf of the other employee? By refusing to talk to DD he himself has just mixed up his personal and professional life?🤔 I think Ashu is in a tight corner, he is stuck between his principles and his duties, where Nidhi represents his principles and DD his duties. Wonder what is going to be his way out? 😳
Roza_DU thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: aardhan


Very good review once again Aarti..I liked the epi..we got to hear everyone's point of view..only thing I didn't like the way Nidhi confronted Ashu in front of all junior doctors, Ashu was shown embarrassed...Nidhi should have talked to him privately...The dinning table scene was very good,BB & HK were shown after ages...they were really worried seeing their gambhir chehra..


Are rules made for us or are we made for the rules? 🤓 If you ask Nidhi the answer is the former and if you ask DD the answer is the latter. And Ashu so far believes in the former but off late is following the later. I think Ashu always strictly follows Hospital rules & Nidhi always dare to break rules for the sake of patient's well -being ...in early episodes we have seen that when Nidhi used to work in children ward..

So the next question for Ashu is... Who or what is more important, the patient or the rules? 🤓 Interestingly, again he believes in the former but, off late he is following the later.
I think he will realize Nidhi's POV later & agree with her but I'm not sure if he will go to DD to explain her POV.

does that justify the fact that he allowed the patient to be discharged without getting fully treated? Was that a morally correct thing to do, because the patient broke a rule that was not even in existence till 2 days back and for this his boss wanted the patient out? 🤓
Agree with you ..it wasn't morally correct & AShu should have raised his voice in this regard..DD was being very rude to an aged patient, he could have warned him...
he also failed to maintain the dignity of his position as chief administrator because of cancelling Nidhi's nomination..he was really mean to Nidhi while talking to her in his cabin..

I found that Ashu who used to mock her and humiliate her for any small mistake now atleast tries to find out Nidhi's reasons behind her actions. 😃 He may be angry but he still allows Nidhi to have her say.👍🏼 Nidhi, for her part used to get intimidated by an angry Ashu and would become emotional and tongue-tied but not anymore.👏 Now she is more firm and even explains herself to Ashu. And I also find that in most cases these days Ashu realizes that Nidhi has a reason for her actions, 😳 and so does not condemn her outright or sulk or refuse to talk to her. He willingly discusses issues with her and this to me shows how much he has come to respect Nidhi and how much her opinions matter to him now. 😳

Totally agree with you...They still fight but not like before...at least Ashu listens to her POV...now they are more open to each other...in yesterday's epi Nidhi was shown very firm & confident while justifying her actions ...Even Ashu has also been changed,now he takes the lead to make up,I liked the way Ashu broke the silence in the bed room & tried to give safay, before he used to sulk in such situations.

I hope they end this track showing that what is needed is a right balance of all things. Just hope this couple has a new year. 😳
@bold, Me too hoping so, want to see balance of all things...doesn't want Ashu acts in favor of Nidhi in the hospital...just want he tries to understand the reason behind Nidhi's acts & support her actions for the well being of the patients...Nidhi also should keep distance from Aditi, who is more interested in fighting against oldies instead of her actual duty...

Edited by Roza_DU - 12 years ago
koyelbasu thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#19
What a analysis Aarti👏. You deserve this from my side 🤗. Now-a-days I really look forward to your analysis and always liked your POV.

Yesterday one of my posts I had written the same thing that Kgh is one of the best hospitals before
DD's entry and ofcourse without implementing his rules everything was fine. So, it does not prove that he is correct in all his view. If it is then how come KGH is counted as a good hospital? Ashu should realise this. Nidhi broke rule as there was no room for discussion left by DD because of his biased nature. If Nidhi is guilty of breaking rule then at the same time she is correct as per humanitarian ground and as well as a sensitive doctor . But DD has completely failed as doctor and as human being when he told OMji to get discharged. He also failed as a professional by cancelling nomination of Nidhi for such small issue.

It is the time when Ashu should stand for Nidhi and told DD that when it was needed not any so called senior matured doctors, who are supporting him in his views, stand for him for helping in CM's surgery. It was childish, immature Nidhi stand for him and helped him for the surgery and save the hospital and helped to get the extra grant from Govt. for KGH. Today this KGH is damaging her career advancement.

Hope everything goes well and solved within 2episodes and then its Ashni together in seminar, Ashu as lecturer and Nidhi as junior doctor who is attending the lecture and lots of romance with gr8 New Year celebration.😛

Edited by koyelbasu - 12 years ago
sonyjknum thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 12 years ago
#20
Thanks for a wonderful analysis.you make us go through each and every scene once again.
'Of course this rather long review is incomplete without mentioning the two other scenes, the car and dinner. 😃 Very cute, their pain came out so nicely and without any OTT dialog or drama.😔 The song in the radio affected both of them, and looked as if Ashu wanted to talk to Nidhi but she was not in the mood. And then at dinner Nidhi's talk about early diagnosis to correct the problem, again an indication that she did not really want this fight.😳 Finally I felt their love come through when Ashu quoted Nidhi's lines to BB and Nidhi felt bad, so she left her food halfway.💔 SEeing that even Ashu felt bad to have mentioned it and lost his appetite too. Very sublte gestures, each one of them screaming out their love for each other. 🤗"
I have said this before also that we can see their love even in the way they react to each other' s words and actions,very subtle and very emotional.Now,rerarding the episode I really felt that Nidhi arguing in the corridor in front of others may be to show that she is getting influenced by them whereas Ashu goes by his own instincts,right or wrong.Loved the car,dinner and the br scene.


Edited by sonyjknum - 12 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".