What if? - Page 2

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

bc123456

@bc123456

Dazzler

Posted: 13 years ago

#11

choice 1 she may be all for it as she too loves kids will definitely side with ashu

choice 2 no way will she ever agree for mallus baby remember all she asked ashu was that mallu not be a part of their lives what nidhi do you think any woman would agree to have her husbands friend back in their lives ? especially when she treid to kill her

Quote

ApoorvaFan

@ApoorvaFan

Inactive

+ 4

Posted: 13 years ago

#12

Originally posted by: Sujatha.rao
Okay, 'I am back with yet another What if...this time there are two scenarios that I would like you to respond to...

Scenario 1

Mallika is not back. The baby debate has happened and the two year decision has been taken. There is another pregnant woman, maybe a destitute, who has come into KGH. Ashutosh gets very involved in the care of her pregnancy and once the child is born, he starts caring for the child too. Maybe he even wants to adopt the child, assuming the mother wants to give it up. Would Nidhi be happy that Ashutosh is still getting to experience fatherhood even if secondhand...and she gets to do what she wants to do...

Scenario 2

Mallika is back and pregnant. There has been no baby debate at all. How will she react to AShutosh caring for Mallika and her unborn child under the circumstances?

Sujatha, now you are trying to bell the cat and you have come with very apt prespective.

I just greened the lines in Q1 which I think will never effect Nidhi. Only when Ashu wants to adopt, she may think about it a bit but still can give away based on the characterization of Nidhi so far. she has such a big heart to tell Ashu to alert Mallika about Jagan. She may accept for adoption not to satisfy the fatherly instincts but to help a child get better life in the world and society.

Scenario 2:

I strongly believe that its not Mallika's pregnancy but the presence of Mallika in and around Ashu which creates big problems to Nidhi. Nidhi has suffered the most because of Mallika and she has seen Ashu's dumb weakness towards her till now.

Because CVs wanted to create a rift between AshNi using their trusted formula of mallika, they tried to create this drama of Pregnancy as an alibi for Ashu's softspot. Its nothing more than that.

Edited by ApoorvaFan - 13 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Sujatha.rao

@Sujatha.rao

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

#13

Originally posted by: ApoorvaFan

Sujatha, now you are trying to bell the cat and you have come with very apt perspective.

I just greened the lines in Q1 which I think will never effect Nidhi. Only when Ashu wants to adopt, she may think about it a bit but still can give away based on the characterization of Nidhi so far. she has such a big heart to tell Ashu to alert Mallika about Jagan. She may accept for adoption not to satisfy the fatherly instincts but to help a child get better life in the world and society.

Scenario 2:
I strongly believe that its not Mallika's pregnancy but the presence of Mallika in and around Ashu which creates big problems to Nidhi. Nidhi has suffered the most because of Mallika and she has seen Ashu's dumb weakness towards her till now.

Because CVs wanted to create a rift between AshNi using their trusted formula of mallika, they tried to create this drama of Pregnancy as an alibi for Ashu's softspot. Its nothing more than that.

You could well be right...but thanks to virtual platforms, there is scope to understand what exactly a writer is trying to convey...from the horse's mouth so to speak...besides Nidhi has already mouthed the lines to this effect...that she feels AShutosh is doing what he is doing because of her decision to postpone motherhood...so they have already made Mallika's pregnancy, and not Mallika, the bone of contention,...there is no turning back now!

Quote

mudraswathi

@mudraswathi

Stunner

Posted: 13 years ago

#14

Originally posted by: Sujatha.rao

Mudra...the agreement came after the wedding...in fact Ashu told Nidhi of his strong desire for a child only after the wedding!

yes, I took an example.. but nidhi is sure anyway.. she said to her DB that...😳

Quote

Sujatha.rao

@Sujatha.rao

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

#15

Originally posted by: mudraswathi

yes, I took an example.. but nidhi is sure anyway.. she said to her DB that...😳

Woh toh kahegei hi na...she wants to believe that...but DB saw through it...she told Ashutosh that Nidhi had no idea what the decision was costing him...!

Quote

ApoorvaFan

@ApoorvaFan

Inactive

+ 4

Posted: 13 years ago

#16

Originally posted by: Sujatha.rao

You could well be right...but thanks to virtual platforms, there is scope to understand what exactly a writer is trying to convey...from the horse's mouth so to speak...besides Nidhi has already mouthed the lines to this effect...that she feels AShutosh is doing what he is doing because of her decision to postpone motherhood...so they have already made Mallika's pregnancy, and not Mallika, the bone of contention,...there is no turning back now!

Sujatha, I gathered from the forum that the writer is driving this thought. This is what he always tired to do with this show. Take up a strange stand suddenly, change the characteristics and behavior patterns of the characters and throw a googly on us normal people who follow the story line and interpret the characters as per the behaviors exhibited by them.

As per Nidhi's characterization and behaviour she should not have insecurity about this and also from Ashu's POV, though he is old enough, the marriage is just months old and he needs to give space and time to Nidhi. If he had that kind of strong parental desires, those were supposed to be exhibited from day 1 of their marriage. For some months/days Nidhi was trying to become a wify and was roaming freely before this career bug has bitten her and she put pregnancy aside.

What I feel sad is in all this the beauty of the characters is getting lost for the whims and fancies of the writer.

Quote

parmarA

@parmarA

Sparkler

Posted: 13 years ago

#17

sujataji,on sce 1 if ashu want to help we can call it cherity,and if he adopt that child it can call humanity,bec they are needy,and nidhi can understand that betterly,but 2nd sce mallika wants help only befor preg not then.but she is high qua after birth of babay she don't need any help,phy and mentally and her deeds did not allow nidhi to be sympathiside towards mallika

Quote

Sujatha.rao

@Sujatha.rao

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 13 years ago

#18

Originally posted by: ApoorvaFan

Sujatha, I gathered from the forum that the writer is driving this thought. This is what he always tired to do with this show. Take up a strange stand suddenly, change the characteristics and behavior patterns of the characters and throw a googly on us normal people who follow the story line and interpret the characters as per the behaviors exhibited by them.

As per Nidhi's characterization and behaviour she should not have insecurity about this and also from Ashu's POV, though he is old enough, the marriage is just months old and he needs to give space and time to Nidhi. If he had that kind of strong parental desires, those were supposed to be exhibited from day 1 of their marriage. For some months/days Nidhi was trying to become a wify and was roaming freely before this career bug has bitten her and she put pregnancy aside.

What I feel sad is in all this the beauty of the characters is getting lost for the whims and fancies of the writer.

He does like to surprise. And yes, the present conflict is extremely contrived and not in tune with their characters...but then, this is what he has chosen to do...and we can't do much more than protest when we feel he is going against their grain...but then, they are his to do with as he pleases...so, what choice do we really have?!