Why cant it just be story b/w two people ??

kvva thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#1
Hi, This is my first post here. A post from a rather dissappointed fan here.
I started this serial with lots of hopes, because of the unusual subject. It has nice, rich story and good scope. An orphan, given apnapan from a loner who became loaner because of his own rules and regulations. The oprhan gets too attached, the loaner realizes he is stubborn gets back to his family during his end and orphan is orphaned suddenly again. He gets into a shell. A good 10 plus years later an young bubbly and interfering girl enters his life. What happens when the two meet? The story had lots of richness.
But I was dissappointed very soon with Dr. Nidhi being overliked by everyone. I mean hardly they showed any time duration for which she had become so popular. I dont understand the need for medical backdrop now in this serial. I almost gave up and started watching again.
Mallika was not really a vamp, she is reacting and is not scheming. That is she is a grey character and not a negative one. Atleast one better thing. But what was the need of that bhabhi of her, a complete negative character ?
Last two to three episodes were better. Nice to see the various characters and their involvements in the story (minus that bhabhi) and their reactions.
Then suddenly another entry and then another one.
Now I have a big question here? Why is a third person required here ? Why could it just not be the story of Dr A and Dr N. Why they should be guided or opposed by some x y z.
What I mean is this story had so much scope and could have been a great story, had it been just the story b/w the two. But why others are required in their story. To prolong you can add more parallel stories (e.g., Dr. R and Anji and so on). But why these two had to realize and accept their feelings only with the help of one or two or three or four more characters.
Can really the indian makers never make a good serial. Is it because of this no time limit on the searials. I guess we will watch good sensible ones, only if go back to the olden time limits, like 3 month or 6 month serials. Otherwise, the maker only concentrates on keeping on attracting TRPs and prolonging than really on the story.

Created

Last reply

Replies

80

Views

7.3k

Users

11

Likes

152

Frequent Posters

kvva thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#2
Forgot to add another point !!
Pachpan Khambe Laal Diware was another such story. A very nice drama. Mita Vashist is the loner, aged bachelor who is a teacher by profession and Aman Varma (I guess the character name was Neil) is a young guy who enters her life. Beautiful story and story mainly revolves only b/w the two.. She is loner because of family requirements and crossed the usual age of marriage. Unfortunately, we dont have it stored anywhere.
I was not expecting to the level of Pachapan Khambe.. but I thought it would have good story to some extent..
rabzonedge thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#3
yup u r correct..they have deviated from original story line...i m pretty sure that was simple n subtle..the main prob here is trp is low...so in order to increse trp...they r bringing new characters..playing n twisting the storyline...once th trp is stable we can hope for the regular storyline...this is d story of nidhi-ashu..n it shud stay that way...
rabzonedge thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: kvva

Forgot to add another point !!

Pachpan Khambe Laal Diware was another such story. A very nice drama. Mita Vashist is the loner, aged bachelor who is a teacher by profession and Aman Varma (I guess the character name was Neil) is a young guy who enters her life. Beautiful story and story mainly revolves only b/w the two.. She is loner because of family requirements and crossed the usual age of marriage. Unfortunately, we dont have it stored anywhere.
I was not expecting to the level of Pachapan Khambe.. but I thought it would have good story to some extent..

wow-u know this is my fv novel by usha priyamvada...i have never watched d serial..only told by my parents...i have read dat novel many times...loneliness n sacrifices made by protagnist touches ur heart...

yanks28 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#5
ur right and soon this story will be a love triangle it seems, with Rohan (Karan Wahi) entry
kvva thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: rabzonedge

wow-u know this is my fv novel by usha priyamvada...i have never watched d serial..only told by my parents...i have read dat novel many times...loneliness n sacrifices made by protagnist touches ur heart...

I was very young when I watched it. So, I dont remember the story well. But it was such an wonderful story that, the effects of that story will never leave me. And mita vashist was a wonderful actress. Too good. I still remember lots of vague pictures of that serial. The name itself was so meanigful. Thanks, I did not know that it was a novel. I should read it ..
kvva thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: yanks28

ur right and soon this story will be a love triangle it seems, with Rohan (Karan Wahi) entry

Then what is the difference in comparison with the other serials ??
rabzonedge thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 13 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: kvva

I was very young when I watched it. So, I dont remember the story well. But it was such an wonderful story that, the effects of that story will never leave me. And mita vashist was a wonderful actress. Too good. I still remember lots of vague pictures of that serial. The name itself was so meanigful. Thanks, I did not know that it was a novel. I should read it ..

yup..serial must have been good..as d novel is too too good...u must read it...

yanks28 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Achiever Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 13 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: kvva

Then what is the difference in comparison with the other serials ??



none at the moment. they are so impatient with the TRPs and it's like they're scared...how abt trusting the original concept...
Armu4eva thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: kvva

Forgot to add another point !!

Pachpan Khambe Laal Diware was another such story. A very nice drama. Mita Vashist is the loner, aged bachelor who is a teacher by profession and Aman Varma (I guess the character name was Neil) is a young guy who enters her life. Beautiful story and story mainly revolves only b/w the two.. She is loner because of family requirements and crossed the usual age of marriage. Unfortunately, we dont have it stored anywhere.
I was not expecting to the level of Pachapan Khambe.. but I thought it would have good story to some extent..


U bring back memories...so beautiful...that.. todays tv makes me.. want to cringe ...

Not jus pachpan khambe.. kashish ...farman. ...udaan... sailaab these were cult classics..!! Simple stories ...to the point.. tight script.. and beautiful performances n excellent executions..!!

But if only...today was such a time...!!

Back then the DEMON called TRP din exist... n the need to... please it by hook or crook din exist either..!!

@KTLK ... i thot so too.. like u.. it wuld b different... the story based on a classic wuld b a pleasure to watch.. but.. alas.. barring few ups.. .there has been majorly only downs in the story...!! The flow is non coherent... the 'romance' is at lightening speed.. n there is absolutely no development of the side tracks/parallel tracks..!

Barring MB-Kritz.. n their chemistry... i find it a very... normal fare... nothing to write about home!


Having said all of the above... is there seriously ..any other show.. where ...there arent a gamut of ppl ..either trying to separate the lead couple... or some sensation.. triangle.. or some blast from past...or tons of advisers... or love gurus????? (I can slot every single of the top 10 shows in these categories)!!

We want ..change.. we want quality... but.. are our MAKERS capable of it???? Sadly.. it doesnt seem to .be the case... n thats the FACT of life...!! I guess at the end of the day.. .the Cvs jus think from... 'Take it or LEAVE it' perspective... so ..there... i guess.. we are all doomed..! 😆

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".