Is this really Nidhi's fault? - Page 2

Created

Last reply

Replies

29

Views

2.7k

Users

10

Likes

56

Frequent Posters

minizz thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#11

Originally posted by: PurpleFairy


Play? Isn't that being a little harsh? I mean, she didn't do it on purpose, na? And again, I'm NOT trying to defend her so please don't jump on me like I'm okay with her irresponsibility😆.😆
I'm just trying to see the other side of the coin about how fatal it can be when someone is forced to join this profession. Nidhi made this mistake unknowingly. That doesn't lessen the damage done of course, that's the worst part in medicine (:
And ya, I love how Mallika put it😳
And lol, of course. This is a show. She will eventually discover that she loves the profession🤣.🤣


It's true that she doesn't want to be a doctor but once you accept the responsibility, you have to follow through.Nidhi was careless today and because of that a boy's life is at stake.This incident will make her understand that she cannot do her own thing cause her decisions might affect the lives of others.I loved the scene with Mallika.The dialogues were good.
.Jane.. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 13 years ago
#12

Originally posted by: starasdf

Sorry I have to disagree, whether she wants to be in this profession or not, someone's life is not to be take lightly.

I do understand what you are trying to get at, that she has no interest in this profession thus no concentration, but no there is no excuse for her irresponsibility. Doesn't matter if you like it or not, as soon as you step in to save someones life and come in front of a person as an doctor nothing is excused. Because her 'little' mistakes could take someones life. She obviously didn't know that but now she does and she needs to know this on a serious note. So I am completely OK how Ashutosh dealt with Niddhi.

And yes I do think she will love the profession in the future. Maybe when she saves someones life and sees how great-full they are to her. Or seeing how much Ashutosh loves saving people's lives and understand's why.

Star⭐️


I respect your opinion. I've made my stand pretty clear and it's perfectly fine if you disagree with it. You have your point and to each his own😃
SatanLaughs thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#13

Originally posted by: PurpleFairy



<font color="#cc00ff">Hey, hun! </font>
<font color="#cc00ff">Ermm..ya about PKYEK. Well I don't follow that show anymore and I'm sure you know why.</font>
<font color="#cc00ff">About the AT, just lack of time 'coz of upcoming exams. Don't worry. I'll be back there soon. I miss you guys too🤗</font>
<font color="#cc00ff">And thanks for agreeing😳</font>

<font color="#cc00ff">@Tanu: Seconded😉</font>


wel, so u r cmpltly off pkyek.? Dats BAD news.. :(..doh i kno d reasn..! & dats d saddest part.. Bt, r u off abhay-piya as wl ? :P :D :D
.Jane.. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 13 years ago
#14

Originally posted by: minizz

It's true that she doesn't want to be a doctor but once you accept the responsibility, you have to follow through.Nidhi was careless today and because of that a boy's life is at stake.This incident will make her understand that she cannot do her own thing cause her decisions might affect the lives of others.I loved the scene with Mallika.The dialogues were good.


Isn't that the whole point? She didn't 'accept' the responsibility, she was forced to. And I know how tough it can get and one ultimately has to succumb to family pressures.
And I think I've said ample number of times that I do not approve of the boys life being at stake at all. I was just trying to put her viewpoint across, whether justified or unjustified😃
Maz. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#15
You are right..I kinda agree...but the deal here is essentially about her behavior..when entrusted with a responsibility she has failed on her part. So though Ashutosh is scolding her for this particular incident, it also is about how she should realize that any task assigned has to be dealt with some amount of seriousness be it whatever profession. Just because these were children here she got carried away, while the other night she was a true pro. So what Ashutosh is implying is that one day you can be the star but a tiny mistake can make all that come crashing down and it costs dearly if you are a doctor.

She was forced into working here..that's right, but as an adult she too has agreed to work in the hospital even if was reluctantly.. she has to understand that there will be challenges she has to face and should be in a position to confront them.
.Jane.. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 13 years ago
#16

Originally posted by: honey_bunch


wel, so u r cmpltly off pkyek.? Dats BAD news.. :(..doh i kno d reasn..! & dats d saddest part.. Bt, r u off abhay-piya as wl ? :P :D :D


I can be off anything and everything but never AbhIya. I still love them and follow their scenes but that's about it. Other than them, the show's over for me😛

P.S. We're spamming my topic🤣.🤣
Armu4eva thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#17

U remembered my name.. 😛.. yay... 🤗

Looking forward to.. yapping with u.. more n japping AshNi ke gun 😳
.Jane.. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 13 years ago
#18

Originally posted by: Maz.

You are right..I kinda agree...but the deal here is essentially about her behavior..when entrusted with a responsibility she has failed on her part. So though Ashutosh is scolding her for this particular incident, it also is about how she should realize that any task assigned has to be dealt with some amount of seriousness be it whatever profession. Just because these were children here she got carried away, while the other night she was a true pro. So what Ashutosh is implying is that one day you can be the star but a tiny mistake can make all that come crashing down and it costs dearly if you are a doctor.

She was forced into working here..that's right, but as an adult she too has agreed to work in the hospital even if was reluctantly.. she has to understand that there will be challenges she has to face and should be in a position to confront them.


I think you sum up everything I feel about the situation as a whole. This post was just Nidhi's PoV.
As far as her carelessness is concerned, nothing justifies that and Ashutosh had every right to blast her.
Thanks for dropping by (:
.Jane.. thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 13 years ago
#19

Originally posted by: Armu4eva

U remembered my name.. 😛.. yay... 🤗

Looking forward to.. yapping with u.. more n japping AshNi ke gun 😳


Everyone knows your name! You're every forum's gossip queen🤣.🤣
Yep! I shall be more active post December when my exams are done and the show will also be at it's peak, hopefully!😃
If handled properly by the writers, AshNi can be a very deep and intense couple, just the kinds I love to watch and trace the journeys of❤️
Edited by PurpleFairy - 13 years ago
minizz thumbnail
13th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 13 years ago
#20

Originally posted by: PurpleFairy


Isn't that the whole point? She didn't 'accept' the responsibility, she was forced to. And I know how tough it can get and one ultimately has to succumb to family pressures.
And I think I've said ample number of times that I do not approve of the boys life being at stake at all. I was just trying to put her viewpoint across, whether justified or unjustified😃


but that is the point here.This is a noble profession where you are responsible for a person's life and death.So she cannot be careless.If she didn't want to become a doctor she could have simply failed the exams😆'saanp bhi mar jaaye aur laathi bhi na toote'kind of thing. instead she went ahead and got the 14th rank 😃but I feel in her heart she does want to fulfill her mom's last wish...so all this rebellion is just hogwash and she will come around soon.and for that this 'sahenshah' incident was necessary.Something to move the story forward...that's all.At the end of it all it's just a show and we know she will become the city's best doctor😆so all good

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".